News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fediverse by deltarholamda on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:41PM (#31251150)
> I've been pitching this idea for years and no one's ever given a serious critique of the idea.

It would dilute the Twitter brand and divide internal resources. That's the main critique I can think of. Would never happen while Twitter was a publicly traded corporation. Under private ownership, it very well might happen.

I think the Fediverse idea is great, but people are dumb. @somebody is about as far as most people can handle. @[email protected] is confusing, and nobody will understand. Imagine having to explain bang paths to Fred in accounting so he can send an electronic mail.

Never underestimate how obtuse the average computer user is. They can be taught, but it takes many, many years before it becomes common enough that people grok it without trouble.

(I like your idea, btw.)

Re:Fediverse by dash2 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:02PM (#31252144)
It's strange to argue that people are stupid because they don't want to deal with irrelevant technicalities. Are they also stupid because they prefer domain names to IP addresses?
Re:Fediverse by deltarholamda on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @05:22PM (#31253754)
Fair enough, swap out "ignorant" if you want. The learning curve for Internety-thing is pretty steep, which is why people like "Find us on Facebook!" so much.

But what I was doing was comparing Fedi @[email protected] to old-school bang paths. It's unlikely to take off among the masses until significant time passes. Heck, even email addresses baffle enough people to make me doubt whether all of this Internet stuff was worth the trouble.

Re:Fediverse by riffic on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @05:29PM (#31253835)
> "Find us on Facebook!"

ah, the modern take on "AOL Keyword:" from the late 90s.

Re:Fediverse by riffic on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:51PM (#31251273)
fair critique and absolutely reasonable considering why they've never done it. It just seems like a more ethical business model than selling ads and data licensing (https://octodon.social/@jalefkowit/108216691483123862).