News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by kamranjon on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @03:59AM (#31245839)
For those looking to actually edit video professionally on Linux you can’t really beat the free version of Davinci Resolve. Over the past 5 years it has become an incredibly competent non-linear editor alongside being the industry standard for color grading. I’ve honestly tried everything under the sun on Linux for video editing and nothing beats it. If you’re looking to stay open source I think blender is starting to become more competent but still a bit of a task getting it setup for doing serious NLE video work.
Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by easytiger on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @04:36AM (#31246039)
I have pretty modest video editing needs and have been using shotcut on linux. I'm aware of Davinci Resolve but had always assumed (for no reason other than few commercial developers do) they wouldn't have a linux version let a lone a free one. Thanks for the tip off!
Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by emptysongglass on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @07:23AM (#31246983)
Or you can use Lightworks used to edit Wolf of Wall Street among other Academy features.

Also be aware that Resolve does not support integrated graphics (but only on Linux, bizarrely).

Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by linsomniac on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @10:11AM (#31248522)
I really liked Lightworks several years ago when I was evaluating all the video editing packages, except for the pricing structure at the time. It was really easy to pick up, and worked great under Linux.

My memory was at the time the only pricing option was a subscription model, and I don't do videos very frequently. I knew I'd be annoyed at paying $20/mo for the many months when I wasn't using it. More recently I've seen that they have a "buy outright" option for around $300, which I would have lept at back when I was first looking at it. But I've since moved on to Resolve.

Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by Flex247A on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @11:20AM (#31249399)
Lightworks has a perpetual free licence mode too, provided you have to login every 90 days.
Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by belthesar on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:13PM (#31250786)
For clarity, this is because Resolve seems to require OpenCL support. I haven't tried it myself, but the beignet package might serve to provide OpenCL support. I had a similar issue when using the OS AMD drivers and using Resolve, which don't come with OpenCL support.
Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by marcodiego on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @10:27AM (#31248743)
If you're not a professional (beginner, hobbyist or amateur) kdenlive is probably good enough.
Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by linsomniac on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @10:08AM (#31248489)
Several years ago I spent several days trying to get Resolve working on Linux and had absolutely no luck. More recently I found a script that would repackage the Resolve installer as a Deb package and that seemed to work pretty slick.

https://www.danieltufvesson.com/makeresolvedeb

In my case, the machine I was trying to run it on just wasn't powerful enough.

Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by ageofwant on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @11:03AM (#31249208)
That might be so, but I have been bitten with every single "Free" closed source tool I've ever used when it went away in some way or the other. Unless the free tool is totally unusable or the non-free one 5x more "good", I'd rather use the time to get good at a os tool that will just get better year after year.
Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by avinassh on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @08:14AM (#31247332)
I have heard about Resolve for color grading, but how good it is when it comes to editing? Is it simple and intuitive enough to make few edits, add titles for YouTube videos?
Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by linsomniac on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @10:19AM (#31248613)
I'll echo another comment that a few Youtube videos and off you go. It's pretty easy, I'm a video editing neophyte and thought it was easy to pick up.

The thing about Resolve is: You aren't going to outgrow it. It's easy enough for doing simple edits, but if you want to do fancy stuff with it, it can do it. You won't outgrow it.

That said, I spent a stupid amount of time with performance issues in Resolve. My cameras output H.264 or something, and I'd have to convert it to ProRes to edit, a process that took huge amounts of space and time. This was under Windows. Even with that, performance was still pretty bad. One kids concert video took me around 40 hours of editing to get an hour of final footage.

Prior to that video, my desktop machine did a better job with ProRes, but it got milk spilled on it during the home schooling of 2020.

However, and this isn't a solution that everyone can or should do: Resolve on the new Macbook Pro boxes is amazing and will handle anything I throw at it, without having to go through the hoops of converting to ProRes and the like.

Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by ByThyGrace on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:02PM (#31250665)
I've not used Resolve but I've tried pretty much all Linux NLEs. Here are some questions arising from my workflow:

How about resource file support for non-standard (as in TV/cinema) parameters, such as video framerate, video resolution, video formats? How about integrating these into the timeline, including per-clip pan/zoom?

Have you used Vegas Pro (for Windows)? I feel like no Linux NLE is able to replicate the flexibility Vegas Pro allows you in treating each clip as an independent, resizable, transformable asset. Instead, many NLEs enforce an "all clips must keep the same parameters as the project file" rule, where e.g. you can't incorporate a 60FPS file into a 50FPS project.

Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by linsomniac on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:50PM (#31252005)
I'm not really sure about your second paragraph, that's not something I've tried doing.

Resolve works like this: You set a project parameters (resolution, framerate being the big ones), either manually or it is set by the first clip you bring in. Then you can bring in clips that don't match those values, and they are just, at render time, converted to the target resolution/frame rate.

You can take clips in your timeline and make a composite clip out of it, basically rendering it within the project to a new artifact, I usually use that primarily for combining the 5m clips my camera breaks things down into into a single large clip, but I think you can also put panning on that. I haven't used Vegas Pro, that sounds pretty slick.

Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by brainwipe on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @08:23AM (#31247401)
Not OP but its editing is also pretty advanced and with some YouTube tutorialling, it can muster some effects you might find in Adobe After Effects. Resolve has replaced Adobe Premiere Pro for me. I'm happy to have saved the subscription fee!
Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by 120photo on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @09:30AM (#31248050)
I was a old Final Cut Pro guy (never really got into the new X version). I was able to pickup resolve just fine and they make great improvements each year. If all you are doing is YT videos with titles this may be overkill, maybe Kdenlive.
Re:Pitivi, a free and open source video editor for Linux by skykooler on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @10:33AM (#31248806)
Blender is great for compositing and visual effects, but really falls down on the audio side of video editing.