Re:2022 Mac Studio (20-core M1 Ultra) Review
by JohnTHaller on Thursday April 28, 2022 @09:44PM
(#31200425)
The 5900X can do 24 threads, so why artificially limit it to 16 threads? Unless that's because the M1 Ultra has 16 performance cores. Why include the 3 year old 3700X? Why not include the 32 thread 5950X which can be had in a complete system for 1/3 the price of the Mac Studio M1 Ultra?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:2022 Mac Studio (20-core M1 Ultra) Review
by simonh on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:48AM
(#31202143)
This isn’t a scientific study, it’s one guy who reviews the pro Macs he gets to work on. Also he’s been using the same benchmark for years and the figures for previous Mac Pros are historical, so past tests weren’t conducted with any knowledge of the M1 architecture.
Re:2022 Mac Studio (20-core M1 Ultra) Review
by threeseed on Thursday April 28, 2022 @09:56PM
(#31200490)
They clearly just picked 16 threads because it is enough to demonstrate the point.
M1 only has 4 performance cores and they still ran it with 16 threads. So it's not like they are trying to skew the benchmark by not showing the potential of the 5900x.
Also the 5950x is 2 years old and still is an active product.
Re:2022 Mac Studio (20-core M1 Ultra) Review
by danieldk on Friday April 29, 2022 @06:15AM
(#31203405)
The performance generally regresses when using more threads on the Ryzen CPUs.
Also, maybe I can only benchmark on the hardware that I actually have?
Re:2022 Mac Studio (20-core M1 Ultra) Review
by hedgehog on Thursday April 28, 2022 @10:07PM
(#31200570)
The 5900X is a fine reference as a common chip. The peak performance should be at 12 threads, it has 12 cores, and that's what the table appears to show.
Re:2022 Mac Studio (20-core M1 Ultra) Review
by sharken on Friday April 29, 2022 @01:32AM
(#31201787)
It would make more sense to compare systems with similar price points.
In this case that would mean ThreadRipper systems and not Ryzen.
Re:2022 Mac Studio (20-core M1 Ultra) Review
by danieldk on Friday April 29, 2022 @06:18AM
(#31203422)
Sure, if I had a ThreadRipper, I’d be happy to add the results. I don’t have an M1 Ultra either, but someone was kind enough to do the benchmark for me.
Re:2022 Mac Studio (20-core M1 Ultra) Review
by bigiain on Friday April 29, 2022 @04:59AM
(#31202980)
For the guy who, you know, actually did the comparison here... Of _course_ it makes most sense to compare the new system he has on his desk with the previous systems he's already done relevant performance tests as comparison points.
If you want a comparison between a Threadripper system and an M1 Ultra system, I'd be fascinated to read your blog post with your results.