News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by zeristor on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:42AM (#31191334)
The talk of Japan releasing some water with a bit of Tritium reminded me "that there's Uranium in them there sea water" 4Bn tonnes of it.
Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by arcticbull on Thursday April 28, 2022 @08:33AM (#31191717)
Yup, enough to sustain 1,000 x 1,000MW reactors for 100,000 years. Seawater extraction of uranium is renewable since geological processes replenish that circulating uranium as it is extracted, too. [1]

[1] https://www.ans.org/news/article-1882/nuclear-power-becomes-...

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by Retric on Thursday April 28, 2022 @09:22AM (#31192130)
There was a math error at 1TW, 4 billion tons lasting 100,000 years means 100,000 billion tons lasts 100,000 years / 4 * 100,000 = 2.5 billion years. Though I wouldn’t be sure of the rest of those calculations.

Of course that’s also ignoring the natural decay rate of uranium, and the fact the global electricity consumption is already close to 3TW and rising rapidly. Or the fact that the chemical replacement rate likely depends on the amount of Uranium left in those rocks etc etc. None of which is important in the short term but it seriously undermines their argument.

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by zeristor on Thursday April 28, 2022 @11:52AM (#31194062)
There is the other angle to global warming beyond CO2, that heat engines produce heat itself which directly heats the Earth.

I hadn’t thought of that angle until I read Gerald K. O’Neil’s book 2081

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2081:_A_Hopeful_View_of_the_Hu...

The upshot being at a certain point it would be wise move heavy industry into space.

Of course rocket fuel production, rocket launches, and material orbital de-acceleration down to Earth would be issues.

My point being that Nuclear power will at some point have its own issues.

Edit: GOK’s book in question being 2081, not 2086 (confused with Japanese Anime ‘Thunderbirds 2086’

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thunderbirds_2086)

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by cookingrobot on Thursday April 28, 2022 @05:17PM (#31198330)
In general adding heat to the earth doesn’t really matter, because it’s constantly radiating to space. The sun shines adding a ton of heat all the time, and the same amount radiates out. Running some more power plants isn’t going to compete with the amount of energy we’re getting from the sun.

The problem comes if you add an insulator (greenhouse gas) that raises the equilibrium temperature.

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by Retric on Thursday April 28, 2022 @03:26PM (#31197085)
Solar power doesn’t need a heat engine and can therefore avoid heating the atmosphere. We would need to be using something like 20,000 times as much energy before moving off the earth becomes useful.
Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by titzer on Thursday April 28, 2022 @10:02AM (#31192571)
The half life of U-235 is 700 million years.
Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by Retric on Thursday April 28, 2022 @10:09AM (#31192637)
Yes, and obvious if you are predicting out 2.5 million years that’s important. Though U238 is more plentiful and has a half life of 4.468 billion years. So, if the reactor needs a fixed amount of U235 that’s an issue but if you change the designs it’s less of a problem.

Really, it’s just more complicated than I wanted to get into.

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by titzer on Thursday April 28, 2022 @10:24AM (#31192836)
> if you are predicting out 2.5 million years that’s important

I believe the stated claim is that there is enough fuel for 100,000 years, which is about 7000x smaller than the half-life of U-235. Even then, 2.5 million years with a 700 million year half-life is absolutely negligible. It's exponential decay, not linear, so you won't even get a 1% reduction.

> U238 is more plentiful

It's not radioactive enough; you need to subject it to a neutron flux to get something fissile, e.g. P239 through exposure in a reactor (https://www.britannica.com/technology/uranium-processing/Con...), which incidentally is what breeder reactors are designed to do.

If we're talking breeder reactors, then we have several orders of magnitude more energy available to us than the above calculations.

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by Retric on Thursday April 28, 2022 @12:50PM (#31194866)
> million years

that was a typo it should have been billion.

“It is impossible for humans to extract enough uranium to lower the overall seawater concentrations of uranium over the next billion years, even if nuclear provided 100% of our energy and our species lasted a billion years.”

At which point decay rates do matter.

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by YetAnotherNick on Thursday April 28, 2022 @08:54AM (#31191857)
> Seawater extraction of uranium is renewable since geological processes replenish that circulating uranium as it is extracted, too.

No, it's not. Uranium once used in reactor is literally changed to other elements. And the radioactive waste is sealed in container safe for 100s of 1000s of years.

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by DennisP on Thursday April 28, 2022 @09:12AM (#31192030)
GP's claim is that seawater uranium is replenished from natural processes, not from reactor waste. That claim is true, and their link describes why. Here's another article:

https://cna.ca/2016/07/27/theres-uranium-seawater-renewable/

There is of course a finite amount of uranium on the planet. But there's also a finite amount of fusion fuel in the sun. Neither will run out before the sun boils the oceans.

If we keep using fission long-term, it will likely be in the form of fast reactors, which get a hundred times as much energy from natural uranium because they don't just fission U235, but also U238 and transuranics. (Because of that, the waste from fast reactors only has to be securely stored for 300 years.)

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by lazyier on Thursday April 28, 2022 @09:33AM (#31192231)
> No, it's not. Uranium once used in reactor is literally changed to other elements. And the radioactive waste is sealed in container safe for 100s of 1000s of years.

Sort of. What you are talking about is a technical problem and it has a solution. (and as others pointed out is not directly related to the subject at hand)

Conventional nuclear reactors require a certain level of purity in the uranium to provide stable operation. As the uranium breaks down the fuel becomes less stable. After a while they remove the fuel and then place it into storage.

However that uranium is not used up in that process. Most of it is still there. Which is one of the reasons why it's so difficult and expensive to store safely.

Theoretically you can recover that fuel in breeder reactors. Essentially recycling it. So it can be re-used in conventional reactors. The breeder reactors will still produce usable electricity as well.

And this can be done multiple times. Up to the point were most of the fissionable material is used up and it is much less radioactive and safe to handle. At that point you would combine the waste with clay and bake it into ceramic vessels that can be safely transported and stored indefinitely.

The reason why this technology hasn't moved forward is mostly to do with a couple facts. The first one being that nobody is allowed to do anything with the 'waste' as it is Federally controlled and not owned by the power company. So the operators can't do anything with it even if they wanted to.

And the second one being that during the cold war USA and other countries created vast amounts of purified uranium as part of their nuclear programs. And they have no place to put it and no use for it other than being put through nuclear reactors.

The amount of potentially unlimited power left laying on the table because of politics, paranoia, and fear is mind boggling. If recycling is implemented we currently have many multiple generations worth of fuel stockpiled.

It could put a end to the use of fossil fuels used for energy generation within our lifetime. Which is something that is not possible with wind or solar.

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by Retric on Thursday April 28, 2022 @09:37AM (#31192267)
That’s basically abusing the word uranium as U235 is used up while U238 is largely not in current designs.

Reprocess spent fuel lets you extract the leftover U235, but it’s a small percentage of the original amount. What you want is something like the CANDU design which is far less dependent on U235. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CANDU_reactor

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by arcticbull on Thursday April 28, 2022 @11:01AM (#31193296)
U238 isn't used in current designs because there's so much U235, and the input cost of using U235 is low enough relative to the value of the electricity generated that it's not worth using the U238 - generally speaking. It however can be used in fast neutron reactors or breeder reactors. [1]

[1] https://energyeducation.ca/encyclopedia/Breeder_reactor

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by Retric on Thursday April 28, 2022 @01:04PM (#31195048)
Your general point is correct, however both U238 and U235 are are consumed by commercial reactors right now.

U238 > U239 decay into neptunium-239 which then decays into Plutonium-239. Essentially there is so much U238 in the reactor and so many neutrons flying around the above just happens.

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by arcticbull on Thursday April 28, 2022 @01:18PM (#31195237)
I was under the impression commercial reactors consumed like 1% of the available U238 vs the fast reactors which got closer to 70% (based on the article linked as [1]).
Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by Retric on Thursday April 28, 2022 @01:24PM (#31195342)
Yea, it depends on the fuel and design but in absolute terms the percentage of U238 fuel used is low. However the ratio of 238v235 consumed is much closer because there is so much more U238 than U235.

To simplify if 4% of the fuel is U235 vs 96% U238. While spent fuel is say 1% U235 vs 95% U238/P239 then 3/(3 + 1) = 75% of the fuel used was U235 and 1/(3 + 1) = 25% of the fuel used was U238. Actual numbers are different, but you get the idea.

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by arcticbull on Thursday April 28, 2022 @01:44PM (#31195660)
Thanks for the clarification!
Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by lazyier on Thursday April 28, 2022 @10:35AM (#31192958)
Yeah. I am no expert by any means.

I was thinking of something more along the lines of an integral fast reactor were the heavy elements are removed and reused in the reactor leaving the waste "purified" of those heavy elements. So the really dangerous stuff never leaves the building and is used up to produce energy.

This means instead of having waste that is dangerous for tens of thousands of years you only have to worry about it for a few hundred.

But I guess the some of the output from a IFT then could be used in something like a CANDU reactor?

So you could use the combination of the two to use up most of the fissionable material and until the waste is so depleted that it is useless and is turned into ceramics or glass and safely stored.

Something like that.

Regardless this means that nuclear reactors provide the closest we can possibly get to truly renewable energy source and provide a path forward away from fossil fuels that could meet the energy budget of the planet for the next hundred thousand years or so.

Anybody who really cares even a little bit about the environment and global warming should be clamoring loudly for this sort of tech.

Large scale nuclear power production combined with locally produce small scale (I mean distributed) solar makes a lot of sense, IMO.

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by gotstad on Thursday April 28, 2022 @09:00AM (#31191926)
But the discussion of whether something is renewable is also a complex topic that is only true to some extent. Renewable energy sources (Wind and Solar) are technically not renewable - the production of the equipment uses raw resources that we (today) cannot renew indefinitely.

However, for both Nuclear and Solar/Wind energy we do know, that the energy sources are sufficiently abundant to sustain us almost indefinitely without us upsetting other ecological balances.

Re:Fishing uranium from the ocean with a spider-silk line (2... by Symmetry on Thursday April 28, 2022 @09:14AM (#31192050)
If you look closely enough the sunlight that powers solar panels also comes from the fusion of hydrogen that will be literally changed to another element. But I think it's still fair to call solar renewable because the sunlight hitting the Earth is continually renewed. And while the amount of Uranium on Earth is fixed the amount of uranium in the seas is renewed from that much larger stock, so I think calling extraction of sea uranium is fair.