Re:Indigenous Myth and Science: From Egypt to New Zealand
by tensor on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @03:09PM
(#31171772)
He is using the dictionary definition of science: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/science
Specifically 1. The use of the scientific method, which is concerned with the physical world and its phenomena.
I'm not going to debate your incorrect assumption about his statement. To anyone who practices science it's abundantly clear what he was saying, and it is in no way saying that "intuition" or anything else somehow doesn't exist, only that these are not valid ways to knowledge about the physical world. I agree with that.
Again, these other things can be useful, but they should not be confused with knowledge of the world as learned through science.
> nor is he saying that in the absence of empirical knowledge you shouldn't use other less rigorous information to make decisions.
As I read it, he's saying that only empirical knowledge exists [at least in the context of "real world" or physical phenomena], rendering the term 'empirical knowledge' essentially redundant. How could you use non-emperical knowledge if such a thing doesn't even exist?
Limiting the scope of consideration to simple physical phenomena: What about your innate intuition about the way physical objects behave? Is there no use for that? Nobody gets out a pencil and solves kinematic equations every time they try to catch a baseball. There's a great deal of utility to be found in the intuitive knowledge of how the physical world works.