News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Indigenous Myth and Science: From Egypt to New Zealand by rayiner on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @01:24PM (#31170344)
I think it's important to distinguish between empirical knowledge and other mental states or impressions, because they differ fundamentally in their reliability.

This addresses a real problem that exists: people treating the work of credentialed scholars in the areas of philosophy or social commentary as disclosing "facts" similar to the work of scientists.

> A few examples of knowledge that isn't empirical: Using your shared humanity to intuit what somebody else is feeling, in order to have compassion for them. Creating art that you know is aesthetically pleasing, without first performing any empirical analysis of what that even means.

Knowledge based on experience and trial-and-error is still empirical--i.e. based on "sense experience." Artists paint stuff and then observe how people react to it. Farmers learn from inherited experience and their own experience with harvest cycles.

That said, it's less rigorous than knowledge based on controlled experiments and theoretical closed-form analysis, so I would call it more "skill" or "experience" than "knowledge."

> Knowing that all humans deserve human rights.

This is the opposite of knowledge, it's a non-falsifiable belief or moral assertion.

Re:Indigenous Myth and Science: From Egypt to New Zealand by robonerd on Tuesday April 26, 2022 @01:52PM (#31170754)
> Knowledge based on experience and trial-and-error is still empirical--i.e. based on "sense experience." [...] Artists paint stuff and then observe how people react to it.

Artists do this, that is true. But they don't exclusively do this. Artists may also develop their skill in private through introspective means. Furthermore this analysis is almost always qualitative in nature; artists or their audience assessing distinctly qualitative properties of the work.