News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by jamesbritt on Saturday October 15, 2011 @10:02PM (#3116324)
Perhaps, but:

"A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects."

     -Robert A. Heinlein
http://elise.com/quotes/a/heinlein_-_specialization_is_for_i...
Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by pewpewlasergun on Saturday October 15, 2011 @10:55PM (#3116394)
Why is this quote worth considering or insightful? What does it add to the discussion? Have you done half of those things? Did you really get anything out of it? Some insects specialize, some do not. One could just as easily say farming is for insects, or flying, or a multitude of other things. Just because several species of insects do something does not mean we should not.

This quote, along with a few others, seem to be always dropped into internet discussions with no context or explanation, and I never see them add to the discussion.

Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by JoeAltmaier on Saturday October 15, 2011 @11:36PM (#3116456)
Sure, lots of us have done more than half of those things. Its supposed to be illustrative of how a person is a gadget for figuring out how to do whatever comes along, instead of being programmed for a particular life plan.

But you knew that. I'd have to wonder why the pedantic complaint?

Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by JoshTriplett on Saturday October 15, 2011 @11:39PM (#3116462)
Because you didn't say any of it. The quote is amusing; using the quote to contrast with the post it replied to adds much more. And personally, I got something entirely different out of the quote than you did, and I found the point of view you just explained interesting.
Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by JoshTriplett on Saturday October 15, 2011 @11:39PM (#3116463)
The quote doesn't substitute for a good response, though there's always the chance that someone hasn't seen it. However, the contrasting points of view seem useful.
Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by greyish_water on Sunday October 16, 2011 @12:40AM (#3116550)
Repeaters of that quote invariably neglect to mention that those are the words of a fictional character that lived to be at least two thousand years old.
Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by dredmorbius on Sunday October 16, 2011 @03:59AM (#3116829)
There are plenty of fictional characters whose remarks are both widely quoted and found to be enlightening and/or inspirational to many.

Several are currently running for President.

Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by doty on Sunday October 16, 2011 @01:49AM (#3116646)
It's an interesting and eloquent statement, and worth thinking about. There's no need to resort to ad-hominem attacks against whoever said it, no matter how fictional they might be.
Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by ramchip on Sunday October 16, 2011 @02:55AM (#3116748)
I don't think you can call that an ad hominem attack. For one, he's not talking about the actual author of the quote (the writer), and for two... well, it's just not an attack at all.

I find it very relevant that a person who does all these things is a (fictional) character that lives for thousands of years; that means he has plenty of time to learn a lot about many different fields and trades. Normal humans don't have this luxury.

Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by dredmorbius on Sunday October 16, 2011 @04:01AM (#3116832)
I've lived roughly half a normal lifespan and have accomplished most of that list myself. No need to live for thousands of years.

Methinks you've missed the point.

Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by doty on Sunday October 16, 2011 @10:49AM (#3117410)
Sure I can. The argument was challenging the merits of the statement based on some quality of the entity that made the statement, not based on the statement itself. It's the very definition of "ad hominem".

You can argue that the sentiment expressed by the fictional character is impractical, as you do in the last part of your comment. I disagree with you, but that's neither here nor there.

Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by JoshTriplett on Saturday October 15, 2011 @11:37PM (#3116459)
The contrasting points of view seem useful. On the one hand, we need amazing specialists, to advance the state of the art in a field to a new level. On the other hand, we need amazing generalists, to find novel ways to put advanced technologies together, and to help bridge the gaps between levels of expertise. Slowly, the baseline level of knowledge goes up, and the depths of both specialists and generalists can encompass more.
Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by jacques_chester on Saturday October 15, 2011 @11:01PM (#3116402)
Perhaps, but social insects like ants and bees show far less specialisation than humans do. They rely on the emergent behaviour of thousands or millions of essentially identical units.
Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by dalke on Sunday October 16, 2011 @05:58AM (#3116994)
It doesn't say "do it well", so yes - I have done most of those and think can do all of them ... poorly.

For every human to be able to plan D-Day, conn a sub around the world, design the Burj Khalifa, program like Peter Norvig -- that's going to be both unlikely and a waste of resources since it excludes building engines, harvesting, sculpture, and so many more aspects of what humans can do.

Re:Dizzying but invisible depth by wallflower on Saturday October 15, 2011 @11:11PM (#3116416)
There is a school up in the Northeast that could teach a number of the harder, manual skill items on that list:

http://www.bc3.edu/heritage-school/about-heritage-school.asp

Blacksmithing, etc.