Re:Why Sex? To Keep Parasites at Bay, of Course
by ScottBurson on Saturday October 15, 2011 @05:39PM
(#3115871)
> (the worm has sex inside the duck)
So this theory explains why the snails have sex, but it doesn't so clearly explain why the worms have sex -- since they are the parasites in question.
I don't know why there has to be just one reason that organisms have sex. If there's anything we know about biological systems, it's that most structures serve multiple functions.
Re:Why Sex? To Keep Parasites at Bay, of Course
by sliverstorm on Saturday October 15, 2011 @06:56PM
(#3116033)
I don't know why there has to be just one reason that organisms have sex
I'm inclined to agree. I'm not sure why the author limits themselves to parasites. Parasites are not the only selective pressure that can be addressed via genetic recombination.
Re:Why Sex? To Keep Parasites at Bay, of Course
by praptak on Sunday October 16, 2011 @02:42AM
(#3116731)
> I'm not sure why the author limits themselves to parasites.
Parasites are distinct from most other selective pressures: they constantly adjust to whatever adaptations the host has come up with. Other pressures do not have this property - the desert doesn't get much drier because some plants adapted to the lack of water.
This also explains why worms have sex - even if they don't have parasites of their own (they most probably do), they need to adapt to their hosts' countermeasures.
Re:Why Sex? To Keep Parasites at Bay, of Course
by jkuria on Saturday October 15, 2011 @07:55PM
(#3116147)
thank you for saying this! I re-read the second theory a couple of times and I wasn't sure I quite got it. It seemed like the difference was a minor technicality, which made the article much less compelling. Flushing out bad genes (vulnerable genes) out of the genome so that the next generation is stronger isn't all that different from changing locks on the cells to protect against parasites attacking the offspring.
Re:Why Sex? To Keep Parasites at Bay, of Course
by iwwr on Saturday October 15, 2011 @07:39PM
(#3116122)
Sexual reproduction allows more than gene shuffling, it permits traits from multiple lineages to come together in a single individual. Adaptations only need to be developed in one individual of the gene pool for the descendants of that population to have a chance to pass it along.
Re:Why Sex? To Keep Parasites at Bay, of Course
by VladRussian on Saturday October 15, 2011 @11:32PM
(#3116449)
any theory of sex is incomplete until it addresses why there are 2 sexes (even if one organizm can carry both sexual organs it is still 2 distinct sexes). It may seems obvious, yet a science theory must address it scientifically. All the shuffling, flushing, etc.. of genes would also work in 3, 4, ... sexes schemas. It will have different statistical distributions and the theory must prove that whatever goal of sex existence, it is somehow optimal with 2.
Re:Why Sex? To Keep Parasites at Bay, of Course
by mv on Sunday October 16, 2011 @01:15AM
(#3116605)
no that doesn't at all. Why not have any two humans mate to have offspring? there are 23 pairs of chromosomes and only 1 pair is sex determining. doesn't really make sense to have male/female especially since the 'male' physical characteristics are small enough to be present in a female also.
Re:Why Sex? To Keep Parasites at Bay, of Course
by praptak on Sunday October 16, 2011 @02:07AM
(#3116680)
You think that finding one suitable partner isn't hard enough already? Joking aside - the complexity of getting 3 specimens of suitable sexes to produce offspring is probably what kills this possibility.
And the most benefit in terms of shuffling is between having recombination (sex) and not having it at all (cloning.) It is not evident to me that there's significant additional benefit from introducing the hypothetical 3rd sex.
Re:Why Sex? To Keep Parasites at Bay, of Course
by akkartik on Sunday October 16, 2011 @05:24AM
(#3116943)
"Red Queen" is one of my all-time favorite books, up there with "The Fates of Nations" by Paul Colinvaux. Both instantly and completely changed how I saw the world around me.
Actually, it's okay to have a theory that gets disproved. That's how the process is supposed to work.
So this theory explains why the snails have sex, but it doesn't so clearly explain why the worms have sex -- since they are the parasites in question.
I don't know why there has to be just one reason that organisms have sex. If there's anything we know about biological systems, it's that most structures serve multiple functions.
(via sex). This is why.
I'm inclined to agree. I'm not sure why the author limits themselves to parasites. Parasites are not the only selective pressure that can be addressed via genetic recombination.
Parasites are distinct from most other selective pressures: they constantly adjust to whatever adaptations the host has come up with. Other pressures do not have this property - the desert doesn't get much drier because some plants adapted to the lack of water.
This also explains why worms have sex - even if they don't have parasites of their own (they most probably do), they need to adapt to their hosts' countermeasures.
3 genders will allow even more gene shuffling and multiple lineages to come together in a single individual.
And the most benefit in terms of shuffling is between having recombination (sex) and not having it at all (cloning.) It is not evident to me that there's significant additional benefit from introducing the hypothetical 3rd sex.
praptak's second paragraph seems like a decent explanation why 2 seems to be the typical number.