News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra... by vkou on Friday April 22, 2022 @03:39PM (#31127010)
Why do you assume a democracy can't censor?

All that a democracy is is a form of government where people elect some part of the legislature and the executive. If the electorate wants censorship, then the electorate will get censorship. If the electorate doesn't care much either way about censorship, but the people they elect do, then they will get censorship.

Re:Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra... by lolinder on Friday April 22, 2022 @03:50PM (#31127159)
There are two kinds of censorship:

1) Censorship of "offensive" content (for some definition of "offensive"), applied equally to all people.

2) Censorship of political opponents, either overtly (as in Russia) or under the guise of censoring "offensive" content.

A democracy can theoretically sustain itself while engaging in censorship of type 1. A democracy that has chosen to engage in censorship of type 2 is on its way to becoming an authoritarian regime, even if that censorship has public support in the short term. Eventually, the opposition is slowly but surely silenced altogether, and you end up with single-party authoritarian rule. Your vote doesn't matter if no one is allowed to campaign against the status quo.

Further, I would argue that it is very difficult to prevent type 1 censorship from turning into type 2 censorship, because the party in power is always incentivized to use any tools they have to stay in power. It is more sustainable for a democracy to take a firm stance against censorship of any form than to try to walk that line.

Re:Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra... by leephillips on Friday April 22, 2022 @04:06PM (#31127354)
Very well said, I think. I would add that (1) and (2) overlap, as well. For example, speech railing against sharia might be classified as offensive to Muslims. But it becomes a political issue if a party or candidate supports a policy of allowing some limited form of sharia to have official status.
Re:Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra... by vkou on Friday April 22, 2022 @05:07PM (#31128151)
> A democracy that has chosen to engage in censorship of type 2 is on its way to becoming an authoritarian regime, even if that censorship has public support in the short term.

Depends on who the political opponents are. There's a vast gulf between single-party rule, and a oligopoly of parties that censor their opponents, but not eachother. The former is seen in a place like Russia, the latter is what we have seen for decades in many Western countries. (See: The Red Scare as a great example of this.)

> I would argue that it is very difficult to prevent type 1 censorship from turning into type 2 censorship, because the party in power is always incentivized to use any tools they have to stay in power.

It's actually easy, what you need is a strong bureaucracy that maintains social norms, due to its inertia. As long as we can all shake hands and agree to treat, say, commies as a common enemy, but treat eachother as gentlemen, that sort of status quo can be maintained indefinitely.

That bureaucratic inertia is what will protect you from despotism, not the letter of the law.

Re:Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra... by leephillips on Friday April 22, 2022 @03:48PM (#31127126)
Good point. What I mean by “not a democracy” is not democratic in a meaningful, functional sense. So if people can vote, but they’re not allowed to share political opinions freely, and specifically if the government decides what you’re allowed to say, then the voting becomes meaningless—or at least, less meaningful. My vote is not informed by what I know about the candidates or various political issues if I’m only allowed to read what the party in power allows me to read.
Re:Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra... by stjohnswarts on Friday April 22, 2022 @10:19PM (#31130778)
Also pure democracies don't really exist. for example the US is a democratic republic and the bill of rights has (until recently) stopped a lot of companies, people, and state governments from running over the rights of an individual to speak their mind (or religion or whatever) without fearing reprisal from the government. I'm afraid with the far right SCOTUS that we have currently though those individual rights are likely to be taken away to allow more police actions in our country as republicans increasingly push to remove hard won civil, racial, and gender equality rights.
Re:Indian lawmaker arrested after tweet criticising Narendra... by FerociousTimes on Friday April 22, 2022 @05:05PM (#31128128)
There's liberal and illiberal democracy, and I think for the majority of people here when democracy is mentioned, the former is the one that comes to mind not the latter.

It's all about freedoms and liberties after all.