My point about "weak typing" is this: if someone says "hey, I'm designing a new language, its type system is going to be weak", they gave you no information whatsoever about the type system other than maybe "some people on the Internet will probably complain about it".

That's why it's useless to say things like "it's about as weak as a static typing system can be" and "has been historically considered weak".

If you had explained your objection to C's type system (like you have now), I wouldn't have said anything. And I've been on the Internet long enough to have seen C's typing is historically referred to as "weak" because X for *many* values of X, so I disagree that that's the only or even main objection.