News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by hoseja on Thursday April 21, 2022 @01:51PM (#31112845)
Why isn't it possible to do this industry at less than razor edge?
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by joenathanone on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:04PM (#31113030)
The lithography machines and factories are prohibitively expensive, it can take years of production to break even, if you over build you may just end up in the red. Additionally the fabs have a limited lifespan when they are cutting edge and able to produce premium chips.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by rednerrus on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:14PM (#31113184)
Then shouldn't the government be involved in ensuring we have what's necessary? Seems like strategic reserves are in order here.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by lsllc on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:24PM (#31113323)
It's not unprecedented -- during the cold war, the US Air Force spent $279M (~$3B in today's money) on building some of the largest presses in the world specifically to enhance the capabilities around building complex and strong aircraft parts:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_Press_Program

Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by blamazon on Thursday April 21, 2022 @08:53PM (#31117003)
Fascinating link! Check out this titanium bulkhead for an F-15 before and after pressing:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/9e/F15_bulk...

Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by stevenhuang on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:34PM (#31115464)
Wow. Attached is a fascinating doc going through the specs and construction process of this feat https://web.archive.org/web/20120227025023/http://files.asme...

It has pictures!

Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by 55873445216111 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:25PM (#31113334)
In practical terms, the government is just too slow to actually help. They always shoot behind the target. The semiconductor market is cyclical. By the time the CHIPS Act, etc, actually get passed and implemented, the market will already be in oversupply and voters/politicians will complain about government handouts for these companies.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by thorRay8383 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:43PM (#31114929)
In practical terms the government is intentionally hamstrung to appear incompetent:

https://about.usps.com/who-we-are/financials/annual-reports/...

With a vote Congress destroys budgets and the narrative is the PO sucks.

Government incompetence is private interest driven propaganda

Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by anamax on Friday April 22, 2022 @12:41AM (#31118285)
Govt incompetence is a reality.

You can argue that govt need not be incompetent, but it's foolish to act as if the US govt is competent until it actually is competent.

That's true regardless of how good things could be if the US govt was competent.

Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by squeaky-clean on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:57PM (#31115684)
But Congress is part of the government. So it's hamstringing itself. It's the same line of thought when some large dinosaur of a company purchases a startup. "Welp, startup is going to suck in 2 years." It's not the startup's fault, but to the consumer it's still going to suck. It doesn't really matter why.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by ncphil on Thursday April 21, 2022 @10:13PM (#31117473)
No. Congress is not "part of the government". Sure, they get government paychecks, but they're the legislature not the executive. They don't "do" anything, just direct that it be done. All but a few are millionaires who make more income from non-government sources than that paycheck. By virtue of their office, they're also well connected: able to get lucrative board memberships for their kids in Ukraine, or Arkansas. As part of the upper echelon of society they share the interest of the rest of their class in not only making the government appear ineffective, but also ineffective in fact. A competent government might be a threat to their power, after all: as would an unbought section of their own chambers. Hence the critical need for a disciplined two party duopoly that savagely suppresses all competition.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by squeaky-clean on Friday April 22, 2022 @10:23PM (#31130800)
> but they're the legislature not the executive

The government has multiple branches... They're the legislative branch.

If we're going by your logic, the executive branch is the one that is not part of the government because they don't get to decide how to govern.

https://www.whitehouse.gov/about-the-white-house/our-governm...

https://www.usa.gov/branches-of-government

https://people.howstuffworks.com/three-branches-government.h...

> All but a few are millionaires who make more income from non-government sources than that paycheck. By virtue of their office, they're also well connecte

All of this is true for the executive branch too.

Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by MisterMower on Thursday April 21, 2022 @10:45PM (#31117657)
“Congress is not part of the government.”

Thanks for letting me know I can ignore everything you wrote after that idiotic statement.

Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by thorRay8383 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @06:27PM (#31115950)
Incorrect. Congress can muck up government for everyone while investing in stocks, and receive unlimited campaign cash to help keep their job mucking up government.

As individuals, Congress is doing fine by its members

Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by squeaky-clean on Friday April 22, 2022 @10:28PM (#31130824)
Yes, it's correct. It's the government mucking up itself to benefit the individual's personal interests. That doesn't mean they're not part of the government or not mucking up the government.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by metalliqaz on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:04PM (#31114547)
don't know why you were downvoted for that. it is clear in 2022 that it's a national security issue
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by paulmd on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:40PM (#31113539)
They are, and TSMC and Samsung aren't happy about it (nevermind that both Samsung and TSMC are de-facto quasi-state enterprises themselves[0]).

"Hmm, I wonder who that sign is for..."

https://archive.ph/kvlnp / https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-03-28/tsmc-sams...

It started with getting TSMC to build a fab in Arizona, but to be fair it's a small fab (25k wafers/month) and 5nm will not be leading-edge by the time it's operational. Presumably the point of that fab is traceability/domestic sourcing for the defense/intelligence community - I'd expect that to mostly be used for products to be sold to the USG, and that's how it's sized, just what they'll need for defense. But this new initiative looks like a sea change to me - both in US chipmaking and foreign policy.

I think the situation in Ukraine with neon supply (used in older processes, like the automotive chips that are already in shortage...) has finally struck the fear of god into US policymakers. It's increasingly clear that the supply chain is dangerously single-source in many many areas (EUV and high-end DUV litho machines, fine chemicals and high-end passives, ABF film, etc), and any problem in any area of the world can have huge implications, because the "build one part in every country" strategy means conflicts are going to disrupt something. You reduce the risk of a black-swan event taking out the whole industry at once, but you also increase the risk of at least some disruption happening, and at this point any disruption is catastrophic in itself.

But beyond that, China is taking advance of the world being distracted by russia to rattle the saber with TSMC again and that's ultimately just not a tenable situation. Not just on China's part either, Taiwan is working the situation too and that's a problem too.

Not only could china blow up the world's chip supply by starting a war with Taiwan, but TSMC has that leverage at any time too. A fab is a tuned swiss watch, even simply wiping all the computers used to run it (or getting cryptolockered like happened a year or two ago) or opening the fab up and allowing it to be contaminated would basically halt production for a period of at least months, and that's practically trivial to do. Actively destroying certain machines could put the fab out of action for years, and blowing up a couple EUV machines is easily within reach of nationalists/partisans at TSMC if it came to it. Even beyond physically having the fabs on US soil, that means that TSMC and Samsung (and thus their respective governments) have leverage over US policymakers in terms of US national foreign policy - and letting foreign corporations have leverage over US foreign policy simply is not an acceptable situation. It's been a boiling-the-frog situation getting here but China rattling the saber over Taiwan while Russia is invading Ukraine is beyond the redline and the situation can't be allowed to persist.

Even if the US gets enough TSMC-owned capacity to not be completely dependent on Taiwan itself - what if China invades Taiwan and the US decides to allow Taiwan to fall? TSMC could destroy (or seriously damage) their US fabs in retaliation and still blow up the US (and world) economy. And the only other cutting edge fabs in the world are Samsung and Intel... and Samsung is sitting under the barrels of tens of thousands of North Korean artillery pieces, and now they've got nukes and ICBMs too. They have older fabs in Texas but all their cutting-edge stuff is in South Korea. It's not a problem today, but these are strategic projects with a 20 year spin-up time (given all the associated industries that need to be replicated) and foreign policy issues can easily crop up within a timespan of a year or less. What happens if North Korea gets antsy and Samsung doesn't think the US is committed enough to the defense? Samsung could basically do the same thing as TSMC if they really wanted too, and now you've got two quasi-state enterprises with leverage over policymakers.

Global Foundries, too, is owned by an Abu Dhabi sovereign investment fund, they're not cutting edge, but they're yet another potential state-level player.

Fabs are strategic infrastructure and letting foreign nationals control delicate, easily-destroyed strategic infrastructure simply isn't acceptable anymore, period. And the US is explicitly and specifically choosing to disarm the Sword of Damocles that Taiwan has used to exert control over US foreign policy, going forward TSMC won't be able to use the fabs as leverage - which obviously has huge implications for Taiwan's foreign policy, this really calls into question the long-term commitment of the US to the defense of Taiwan. I don't think we're gonna abandon them tomorrow by any means, but in 10 years there is going to be a different balance of power. Both of those are huge foreign-policy sea changes.

But yeah, the idea of "the end of history" and that globalization means that nobody is ever going to get into any conflicts ever again because "gosh, we're all just so economically intertwined" is dead - it's obvious that conflicts will happen and the intertwining just means that we have tons of economic problems when it does. That's another sea change. It's not going to stop neoliberals from doing it anyway, corporations will still lobby for deregulation and offshoring and tax cuts because it makes them money and neoliberals will generally oblige, but this is a signal that policymakers are starting to be aware that they can't just handwave and "the free market will take care" of strategic industries with massive foundational implications to downstream products and the industry as a whole. Globalization doesn't mean strategic industries aren't strategic.

[0] TSMC and Samsung are both quasi-state enterprises. TSMC is explicitly intertwined with Taiwan's foreign policy, they were the ones to negotiate for vaccines for taiwan for example, and Taiwan recently used the threat of cutting off TSMC's water (during shortages) as leverage in negotiations/etc. Samsung is a chaebol, one of the megaconglomerates that essentially run Korea's government shadowrun-style (this is how they industrialized from basically nothing to cutting-edge in 40 years, intense and tight corporate-state coordination). And this isn't just US-style "corporations donate to everyone", Korea's presidents have been repeatedly convicted of corruption for benefiting Samsung, and other actions are almost certainly happening behind the scenes that don't see the light of day on newspapers or can't be proven with hard data. Both Samsung and TSMC are either instruments (TSMC) or puppeteers (Samsung) of their states' foreign policies and cannot just be viewed as big corporations, they are players on the international stage in themselves.

Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by collaborative on Thursday April 21, 2022 @07:56PM (#31116641)
Give Taiwan and SK nukes then. Since that's the only thing stopping aggression these days. Both countries are perfectly capable of the responsibility
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by deelowe on Friday April 22, 2022 @09:24AM (#31121260)
I'm not so sure that would be a good idea.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by ajsnigrutin on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:55PM (#31115064)
Premium fabs, premium chips, and shortages of everything, from modern ("premium") graphics, to shitty DIP AVRs (relatively old tech). New fabs can still produce old chips when needed, and we need all of the chips now, and a bunch of the "new tech" chips, will still be needed in 20+ years, so that fab line can still operate then.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by joenathanone on Thursday April 21, 2022 @08:14PM (#31116762)
The difference is being able to manufacture a chip that retails for multiple thousands of dollars in the case of server chips or in the case of chips that go into coffee machines or cars for cents or dollars each. Premium chips demand a premium price. When you send billions on your factory you don't want to be stuck making low profit chips.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by ajsnigrutin on Friday April 22, 2022 @08:01AM (#31120548)
Well yeah, but now ("current few years"), you'll be able to manufacture expensive, premium chips, and after a few years, new, "smaller" tech will be used for those, and you'll still be able to use your (now older) tech to produce older chips.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by 55873445216111 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:30PM (#31113408)
It takes >$10B and >2 years to build a fab which will be effectively obsolete ~2 years after it opens. If it doesn't open on schedule or is underloaded, the ROI goes negative almost immediately. (I somewhat oversimplified this of course but it's to make the point.)
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by hoseja on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:08PM (#31113906)
Obsolete? Automakers etc are huuuungry for old chips.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by 55873445216111 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:38PM (#31114236)
Yes but there is a huge technology gap. example: Automakers need a lot more small low-power MCUs built on ~130/90nm process. A 14nm fab that started 2 years ago is never going to be producing those 130/90nm MCUs. Furthermore, the semi toolmakers that produce the tools needed to build 130/90nm chips stopped making those tools years ago. This is a rabbit-hole that just keeps going. The problem isn't going away soon or easily.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by mjevans on Thursday April 21, 2022 @04:50PM (#31115012)
Maybe three different 'bands' of production:

  * cutting / bleeding edge (as now)
  * 80/20 trailing edge (5 year LTS of cutting edge)
  * Cost focused 'lifetime' LTS
It seems like the cutting edge is built, and transitioned to the 80/20 already. It's that cost focused bulk components / entry level that lacks investment or even planning.

Maybe that's where some industry development and co-ordination from regulators could help establish a market that's healthy.

Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by StillBored on Thursday April 21, 2022 @03:41PM (#31114272)
Not just automakers, and not just old fabs. Not everything needs the latest bleeding edge process. So, even then some of the old processes get updated to support larger wafers.

Ex: brand new 65nm fab:

https://www.electronicsweekly.com/news/business/bosch-opens-...

So, 10-15 year ROI easy, and I'm guessing that might stretch even further as the trend to ever smaller nodes slows. AKA I'm betting 2nm doesn't look nearly as aged in 2040 as 90nm looks today.

Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by sct202 on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:00PM (#31112982)
It wasn't razor edge in 2009, when TSMC was running a 40% utilization rate. Forecasting is hard, and when you have in recent experience a massive glut it makes companies conservative about demand forecasts and investments.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by xxpor on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:06PM (#31113075)
See also: oil "capital discipline" right now
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by deelowe on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:21PM (#31113280)
I'm not sure I agree with some of the responses. The issue is that the price to build or retrofit fabs goes up significantly with each generation. Only a few companies have been able to survive given the amount of financial risk involved.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by blihp on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:04PM (#31113025)
Because that's not where you end up in a world without numerous serious competitors.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by Macha on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:15PM (#31113197)
I would generally assume a lack of competitors would lead to a decreased need to innovate and therefore fatter margins.
Re:TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unr... by blihp on Thursday April 21, 2022 @02:46PM (#31113630)
Right, which is pretty much where we are now: very fat margins largely because fabs have been banging up against capacity for a while now because they could. (i.e. to avoid the risk of overcapacity... why take a chance if you don't have to?) In a more perfect world with healthy competition, one or more of them would see the lack of capacity and see opportunity to take the risk to build a new fab to take some of that business. The fact that it's basically governments saying 'you will do this' tells you everything you need to know about how much the players are really driven by competition.

It's a great time to be a semi manufacturer: TSMC has customers like Apple funding their expansion, Intel has the U.S. government funding theirs. Can you blame them? A decade of record profits isn't what it used to be...