The scientists probably didn't take this into account because they assumed their setup already compensated for all kinds of clock drift... I wouldn't call this an epic failure just yet, because even if this turns out to be the root cause it's a pretty standard type of mistake as far as science experiments go. That's why we have independent reviews, and that's why they are necessary.
I am seriously doubtful that these neutrinos are traveling faster than light, but I've also been skeptical of this argument since it was presented. It would be pretty hard to have observed this if they weren't looking for it because they would have to sift through old data. For example, for SN 1987A the FTL neutrino event would have preceded the visible light neutrino event by over four years.
They could go through all of the old data, to be sure, but they would have to specifically have had to be looking for something which they think fundamentally is impossible in order to find something like this. So, if these events were even recorded at all, it's certainly not clear to me that they would have done this (at the time of the FTL announcement, that is- of course, they should be doing it now).
it's a pretty standard type of mistake as far as science experiments go
Yes, but when one makes it this far it is big news. No matter what I give props to the scientists to publicly invite the scrutiny they did. That took balls.
So I shouldn't post when I'm annoyed, because then I tend to bark at things that are not what they appear to be.
This is even less than a trivial application of special relativity, it's literally a third grade "distance = rate x time" problem:
Skipping over the relativistic stuff, which is quite frankly unnecessary (or rather, it's necessary, but the CERN authors apparently already included the corrections), the only two equations of import are (re-named vars for lack of LaTeX):
1) time_baseline = dist_baseline / c
2) time_observed = dist_baseline / (c+v)
where v is the speed of the satellite. In other words, if two things are moving towards each other, then you should use the combined velocity to compute the time. Duhhh...
Now, the fact that the difference in these formulas turns out to almost exactly explain away the problem is certainly suggestive, I'll be honest about that.
But if this was all there was to the story, it would be massively embarrassing for someone at CERN, this is the type of error I mentally ruled out immediately because these people should be way too careful to be making elementary screwups like this. This is the type of error that freshmen lose points for on a mechanics 101 test, not one that eludes dozens of physicists working around the clock for a month.
So I'm skeptical here; it's not that the author of this paper is wrong (though there are credibility red flags in the paper, even beyond the fact that he's not a physicist [he's a computer guy], like the fact that he defines gamma as the inverse of the commonly used relativistic quantity, something that indicates only a passing familiarity with the field), it's that I'm not sure that the CERN guys could reasonably be assumed to have made this mistake.
Then again, maybe everyone else looking over the work also assumed that they'd dotted their i's, and didn't bother checking the trivial stuff. It's certainly happened before...
The GPS system was not remotely designed for this level of accuracy. The issue here could really be a misconception of how well GPS works and what it was designed to do. GPS, like all technology, has a distinct difference between theory and practice and is also engineered for certain use cases. It may be that no one really thought about this stuff until now because we're talking such tiny increments of time over such large distances.
Regardless, its early in the game to know whats going on, but I'd be really surprised if suddenly neutrinos were FTL and no one noticed until sometime this year. This is starting to look like another case of super-smart over-specialized eggheads making assumptions and not seeing the big picture, like when NASA/Lockheed lost the Mars Climate Orbitor over imperial to metric conversions.
What a fucked way to spin this -- the group asked for outside help in explaining their results and finding any mistakes.
Seriously, if you're claiming you're doing FTL, asking for outside help isn't some noble act, its pretty much required. The idea that these guys are infallible and systemic errors never happen is incredibly naive.
Christ, remind me never to get between nerds and their starship Enterprise fantasies.
The GPS receivers they used are form Septentrio, and this guys know their shit. I can't find a reference right now, but if I remember correctly one of their claims to fame is detecting an error in GLONASS, the Russian gps system.
Compensating for special relativity in the timing calculations was a job that had to be done, and done perfectly, long before the first GPS satellite was launched.
My guess is that the bug will indeed turn out to be a relativity issue, but a consequence of GR rather than SR, arising from the fact that the detector cavern is under 1400 meters of rock.
The point to remember that there are so many possible factors that could mess up their results, that the error estimates that were published by the OPERA team were way too low.