News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by eru on Monday September 22, 2008 @09:05AM (#311088)
While it may seem lame it's entirely within the system. Voicing your opinion with a comment/submission is as acceptable as up and down voting - as far as I am concerned.

Though I do not like to read complaints that much, either.

Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by robg on Monday September 22, 2008 @09:52AM (#311120)
Actually, it's not supposed to be in the system:

Please don't submit comments complaining that a submission is inappropriate for the site. If you think something is spam or egregiously offtopic, you can flag it by going to its page and clicking on the "flag" link. (Not all users will see this; there is a karma threshold.)

http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by eru on Monday September 22, 2008 @12:50PM (#311332)
OK, thanks for pointing that out.
Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by Jem on Monday September 22, 2008 @11:20AM (#311209)
> Please don't submit comments complaining that a submission is inappropriate for the site

Isn't that exactly what you're doing too, though?

Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by robg on Monday September 22, 2008 @11:31AM (#311224)
The guidelines don't matter for this discussion? It seems to me it's the only thing that should matter. Without them, this site has no focus whatsoever.
Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by Jem on Monday September 22, 2008 @12:23PM (#311303)
No, that's not what I'm saying. Although I agree with the OP that the political stuff is getting dull, I believe you have a point about the guidelines (that means I agree with you). However, complaining that the OP is going against the guidelines and therefore doing the same thing yourself seems somewhat hypocritical. Of course, here I am doing exactly the same thing really.

Surely you could just do what you/others have told the OP to do, and flag the 'submission'?

Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by aslkjdf on Monday September 22, 2008 @11:35AM (#311234)
robg. Regarding the site having focus. I suggest you re-read the guidelines. When the guidelines are as vague as "If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic." it's not as easy as just throwing the guidelines at someone.
Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by robg on Monday September 22, 2008 @11:39AM (#311237)
You're missing the point. The guidelines are the only thing that should matter. Without them, this community has exactly zero form.
Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by ivankirigin on Monday September 22, 2008 @09:13AM (#311091)
It is indeed within the system. I wasn't saying he shouldn't be allowed to post it. I'm saying it's a lame post that I won't upmod.
Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by imgabe on Monday September 22, 2008 @09:26AM (#311101)
I agree. The signal to noise ratio isn't helped by adding more noise.
Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by 13ren on Monday September 22, 2008 @09:59AM (#311130)
If the "system" includes the guidelines, then it's not within the system.

Please don't submit comments complaining that a submission is inappropriate for the site. http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by streety on Monday September 22, 2008 @10:35AM (#311165)
Does a submission count as a post?
Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by 13ren on Tuesday September 23, 2008 @04:57AM (#312220)
Guideline-lawyer! :-) I assume that by post, you mean comment.

Please don't submit comments complaining that a submission is inappropriate for the site.

(1). I suggest that the "intention of the guideline" is to reduce cluttering the site with meta-discussion, and it would serve this purpose best if comment was construed as including a submission.

(2). in terms of the "letter of the guideline", what is the meaning of the words comments and submissions? The guidelines have separate sections for each, and clearly use the terminology used else on the site, which talks of comments on articles and articles that are submitted. A broader construction of "comments" as "things that comment on other things" is not the literal meaning.

Therefore, I agree that the excerpt about comments does not include submissions, and I was wrong. However, I think it should include submissions. :-) Another argument is that submissions about the site are not "On-topic", by this definition:

On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.

I'm not sure that complaining about the site, and attempting to modify other people's behaviour, gratifies one's intellectual curiosity (in contrast, a discussion about how a social site can be run does do this).

However, I think in future, I might leave all such discussions to my betters, and focus on things that I find interesting, instead of trying to "improve" the site.

Re:Pleading with YC: Enough with the political & financial n... by streety on Tuesday September 23, 2008 @08:25AM (#312313)
"I assume that by post, you mean comment."

I feel I've been caught out on my speelling while commenting on someone else's. Shame on me!

"However, I think it should include submissions. :-)"

I agree completely.