"In a tweet from the proceedings, Reuters’ Dan Levine said that Koh “held both tablets above her head, one in each hand,” and “asked Samsung lawyers to identify which was which.” Levine said it took Samsung’s legal team “a while to do so.” This, and repeated references made by Koh about how “similar” the Apple and Samsung tablets appear could indicate that she feels Apple’s “design” patents have more validity than those related to “utility”."
Samsung just needs to fire all it's lawyers and legal department. They should have differentiated their products more and stand to lose billions if this injunction is issued. Gross incompetence. Ironically it's HTC not Apple that stands to benefit the most.
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by nextparadigms on Thursday October 13, 2011 @09:52PM
(#3109579)
I like how in the picture they open the app drawer for Galaxy Tab to make it look more like iPad. The app drawer is not the default view on Galaxy Tab.
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by jarek on Thursday October 13, 2011 @11:08PM
(#3109749)
For what it's worth, my Canadian/Bell 7" Tab packaging (bought April 2011, no idea when the packaging first came out) has the tablet face-on with a photograph fullscreened. None of Android UI is visible except for the four capacitive buttons.
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by zacharycohn on Thursday October 13, 2011 @08:46PM
(#3109443)
If Samsung is infringing on the iPad design, pretty much every Flatscreen TV/monitor manufacturer ever should probably start hiring lawyers, because I can't tell the difference between a Sony or a Panasonic monitor at a glance either.
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by wnight on Friday October 14, 2011 @12:40AM
(#3109982)
What a waste. We've got multiple unjust wars, we're bailing out wall-street yet again, and this is what our courts find time to do - waste the time and effort of a productive company like Samsung over "design patents".
We're innovation hostile. Even our "best" companies like Apple are trying desperately to build themselves a parasitic position on the industry instead of trying to build new, better, technology. It's no wonder all the money has flowed overseas, so has the prosperous mindset that made it.
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by shaggyfrog on Thursday October 13, 2011 @08:32PM
(#3109417)
"Apple and Samsung are engaged in a bruising legal battle that includes more than 20 cases in 10 countries as the two jostle for the top spot in the smartphone and tablet markets."
Apple isn't "jostling" with anyone in the "tablet market"; they outsell the rest if the industry combined by, what, 20-to-1? 30-to-1?
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by InclinedPlane on Thursday October 13, 2011 @08:34PM
(#3109418)
"Smartphone and tablet markets"
Android outsells iPhone in the smartphone market, apple outsells android in the tablet market. Jostling is a perfectly adequate descriptor for that situation.
P.S. It's probably no longer sufficiently accurate to describe the iPad as outselling the rest of the industry combined by 20:1 given what we know about Kindle Fire pre-order figures.
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by shaggyfrog on Thursday October 13, 2011 @10:19PM
(#3109647)
There is no tablet market, only an iPad market.
You can't just chain together as many markets as you wish with the word "and" to the smartphone market.
Why not say they are also "jostling" in the online services, advertising, flat screen, and whatever else market while you're at it?
It's a completely disingenuous statement.
P.S. A recent story put iPad at about 97% of tablet browsing share. I can't get to it right now on my iPhone. Preorders are nice but just about any objective measure (including those that include channel stuffing on behalf of the rest of the industry) we've seen so far has shown total iPad dominance of the tablet space.
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by cellis on Friday October 14, 2011 @05:05AM
(#3110523)
...Extrapolating the 50k if true...1.5million/mo * 3 = 4.5million fires/quarter. That's halfway to what Apple is selling and they've just gotten started.
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by nextparadigms on Thursday October 13, 2011 @07:57PM
(#3109317)
"A U.S. judge said Samsung's Galaxy tablets infringe Apple's iPad patents,"
"but also that Apple might have a problem establishing the validity of its patents."
So which is it? If they don't think the patents are valid, why they saying Samsung is infringing on them? Are they saying Samsung is infringing on "possibly non-valid patents" ? Because that's how it sounds like to me.
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by Steko on Thursday October 13, 2011 @08:01PM
(#3109330)
That seems to be exactly what she's saying: Samsung appears to infringe on the patent(s)* but the patent(s)* may appear obvious to her and unlikely to stand up to reexamination which would make the injunction less likely.
Keep in mind she's just ruling on the injunction so it's not the final determination of infringement/invalidity. The injunction requires her to make some preliminary indication of how strong Apple's case is.
* Also it's not clear if any of that applies to the design patents.
"At the hearing on Thursday in a San Jose, California federal court, Koh also said she would deny Apple's request for an injunction based on one of Apple's so-called "utility" patents.
She did not say whether she would grant the injunction based on three other Apple "design" patents.
Koh characterized her thoughts on the utility patent as "tentative" but said she would issue a formal order "fairly promptly."
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by ahlatimer on Thursday October 13, 2011 @08:09PM
(#3109352)
There are two primary questions: A) Did Samsung infringe on Apple's patents? and B) Are Apple's patents valid?
Both A and B must be true for Apple to win the case, and the court can rule on those two issues separately. For instance, the court could rule in favor of Samsung because they found Samsung was not infringing on Apple's patents, but leave the patents intact if B is satisfied. They could also rule in Samsung's favor because Apple's patents were invalid.
Re:U.S. judge says Samsung tablets infringe Apple patents
by jaypreneur on Thursday October 13, 2011 @08:11PM
(#3109356)
I don't see how Apple could win. A "utility" patent? On the design. Seriously... am I the only one who thinks those are ridiculous patents? It looks like I suppose Samsung is infringing on the patent, but I really hope the patents don't stand up.
"In a tweet from the proceedings, Reuters’ Dan Levine said that Koh “held both tablets above her head, one in each hand,” and “asked Samsung lawyers to identify which was which.” Levine said it took Samsung’s legal team “a while to do so.” This, and repeated references made by Koh about how “similar” the Apple and Samsung tablets appear could indicate that she feels Apple’s “design” patents have more validity than those related to “utility”."
Samsung just needs to fire all it's lawyers and legal department. They should have differentiated their products more and stand to lose billions if this injunction is issued. Gross incompetence. Ironically it's HTC not Apple that stands to benefit the most.
Ex:
http://www.photokina-show.com/news_images/00812_samsung-gala...
That's the older 7-inch Galaxy Tab. Which looks even less like the iPad; more like the Kindle Fire than anything else.
This is the packaging for the Galaxy Tab 10.1: http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51huPpEUIHL.jpg
I too have noticed that most all the images of the Galaxy Tab we've seen associated with these legal cases have the app drawer pulled up.
And the picture in the Reuters article is how Korea Tel is marketing the device? By opening the app drawer and showing how it's just like an ipad?
edit: April 2011, not 2010, correct, my apologies
We're innovation hostile. Even our "best" companies like Apple are trying desperately to build themselves a parasitic position on the industry instead of trying to build new, better, technology. It's no wonder all the money has flowed overseas, so has the prosperous mindset that made it.
Apple isn't "jostling" with anyone in the "tablet market"; they outsell the rest if the industry combined by, what, 20-to-1? 30-to-1?
http://www.engadget.com/2011/10/04/apples-lets-talk-iphone-k... 1:21PM iPad is the "undisputed" #1 tablet in the world. Tim says "everybody and their brother" is trying to compete, but three quarters of all tablets sold are iPads.
edit 15 minutes after posting: slow clap to the downvoter
Android outsells iPhone in the smartphone market, apple outsells android in the tablet market. Jostling is a perfectly adequate descriptor for that situation.
P.S. It's probably no longer sufficiently accurate to describe the iPad as outselling the rest of the industry combined by 20:1 given what we know about Kindle Fire pre-order figures.
You can't just chain together as many markets as you wish with the word "and" to the smartphone market.
Why not say they are also "jostling" in the online services, advertising, flat screen, and whatever else market while you're at it?
It's a completely disingenuous statement.
P.S. A recent story put iPad at about 97% of tablet browsing share. I can't get to it right now on my iPhone. Preorders are nice but just about any objective measure (including those that include channel stuffing on behalf of the rest of the industry) we've seen so far has shown total iPad dominance of the tablet space.
"but also that Apple might have a problem establishing the validity of its patents."
So which is it? If they don't think the patents are valid, why they saying Samsung is infringing on them? Are they saying Samsung is infringing on "possibly non-valid patents" ? Because that's how it sounds like to me.
Keep in mind she's just ruling on the injunction so it's not the final determination of infringement/invalidity. The injunction requires her to make some preliminary indication of how strong Apple's case is.
* Also it's not clear if any of that applies to the design patents.
"At the hearing on Thursday in a San Jose, California federal court, Koh also said she would deny Apple's request for an injunction based on one of Apple's so-called "utility" patents.
She did not say whether she would grant the injunction based on three other Apple "design" patents.
Koh characterized her thoughts on the utility patent as "tentative" but said she would issue a formal order "fairly promptly."
Both A and B must be true for Apple to win the case, and the court can rule on those two issues separately. For instance, the court could rule in favor of Samsung because they found Samsung was not infringing on Apple's patents, but leave the patents intact if B is satisfied. They could also rule in Samsung's favor because Apple's patents were invalid.