News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 'Batman Effect': How having an alter ego empowers you... by katzgrau on Saturday April 16, 2022 @06:13PM (#31056534)
> like how mindfulness increases selfishness in those who think that their existence is independent from the existence of others

... If one was really being mindful, they'd eventually see that the existence of their "self" is only possible in relation to others existing. So there's the self and the other, but in essence, one.

And that's one of the reasons the golden rule makes so much sense.

So I wouldn't blame mindfulness for any side effects. Negative side effects are the result of the ego/self creeping back into the picture.

Re:The 'Batman Effect': How having an alter ego empowers you... by nitrogen on Sunday April 17, 2022 @01:18PM (#31062449)
If one was really being mindful

There's a sort of No True Scotsman fallacy combined with confirmation bias that comes into play with other spiritual practices with which I am experienced. For example, "If your prayers aren't getting answered, you aren't fasting enough and praying hard enough, or you are praying for the wrong thing."

This is an easy trap to fall into with anything that generally works for some people but not others, and it's important to remember that there are other dimensions beside "really" or "enough", plus general randomness, that affect whether a practice/belief/etc is good for a person and successful.

Re:The 'Batman Effect': How having an alter ego empowers you... by Comevius on Saturday April 16, 2022 @06:57PM (#31056853)
The problem might not be with mindfulness, but with our self-centered culture, which causes this secularized mindfulness to be a snake oil with a few personal benefits at best. It's more of a self-discipline or concentration tool when you strip it from it's culture, which used to involve ethics as I understand.
Re:The 'Batman Effect': How having an alter ego empowers you... by astrange on Saturday April 16, 2022 @09:17PM (#31057569)
The original purpose of vipassana (mindfulness meditation) is to realize that selves don’t exist and disconnect you from your emotions, so you’re ready to leave the world behind and do monk stuff. The fact that it works for secular mindfulness is surprising and doesn’t really have any theory behind it.

It doesn’t involve ethics though. Buddhism didn’t come with those; they borrowed standard Western ones as part of a marketing campaign to make you think the Dalai Lama is just the most ethical guy ever.