>> If nobody else wants to pay you more, why would I?
Because I bring value to you, do a good job, and you don't want me to leave (which I can do, even if I don't currently have an open offer). You don't want to have me leave suddenly and have to spend time and money hiring someone new and training them. That's why you would pay me more even if I don't rub another offer in your face.
Most likely you'd be in denial or delusion if you are assuming any company of scale is not operating on this basis. Sure they may not operate solely on this basis (give minor adjustment to the target they have to reduce the "activation energy" of people interviewing) but fundamentally what GP says is the primary way they operate.
Yikes, who's got this much time? Sure when applying for a new roles, having a counter offer is great, but imagine applying for a series of job, doing a TPS, then 6 hour onsite or two to get 1 offer to take a salary review. All of this over a couple of months?
Leaving isn't always winning. Good jobs and tenure at them can be really good. If you're learning, growing, working with good engineers can be amazing. Just because somewhere else is willing to pay and extra few dollars doesn't always make it worth it.
All this to say, with charitable estimates, this seems very worth your time.
> unfortunately only a fraction of companies work like that
In my experience, a company's view of an employee's performance often wildly diverges from the employee's personal view of it.
But there's nothing wrong with making a case to your employer about how valuable your contributions are. They may not be aware of it. Maybe their view of your contributions is misinformed.
> Im sure there are companies out there giving raises out of the good of their heart but why would they do it?
When you buy a laptop, do you pay extra out of the good of your heart? Or do you look for the best deal?
I have used a better competing offer multiple times to negotiate with my employer of 13 years. My relationship with my superiors improved each time…
I believe how you go about this negotiation will determine if it damages the relationship, not if you do it or not.
I believe how you go about this negotiation will determine if it damages the relationship, not if you do it or not.
In your experience, what things are a must in that way to go about that negotiation to keep a healthy or improved relationship?Building relationships takes time. Restarting new relationships every couple years via job hopping can impede such a conversation and make it feel more transactional than mutually beneficial. Since short tenure is more common, this may be another reason Walter finds his colleagues’ experience common.
When negotiating, I knew I was solving the right problems for my superiors and I wanted to keep working to solve their problems but for wages which were more competitive. My bosses understood, wanted the same, and used the offers from other companies to make the case for a raise or promotion.
I would not advise going into a negotiation simply with the notion “I can get paid more over here.” That wasn’t the point of the negotiation. If you go about it that way I believe it would be damaging. A conversation only about pay feels transactional which is damaging to these kinds of long-term relationships. Instead, I was truly desiring to continue my good working relationship with my bosses, but for more pay, and the negotiation was the way for both of us to win.
Over a long time, relationship building snowballs and can be even more effective. The last time I did this after working at the same place for a decade, I got a call from the company’s CTO a few hours after my talk with my manager. He was traveling on business but made time for me to discuss my concern since he knew my work. The call was the start of a satisfying new career direction in a new department.
In larger companies at sufficiently deep levels in the hierarchy, often the person you are really negotiating against is not the line manager you have a tight relationship with (the other party is usually a Director/VP + their HRBP + some remote comp analytics team by proxy). In fact, assuming this is not a high frequency event, bringing a competing offer may make your boss's job easier and give them extra ammunition and help them justify your extra comp request outside the preallocated budget (which can often be too limited or too inflexible).
Of course they can't explicitly tell you this but always watch for the nudges and signals.
I disagree. This can happen but it isn’t some universal truth.
I made those statements from experience, from both sides of the table, and the experiences of colleagues. People don't like ultimatums. Even if they accede to them, their trust in the person will decline, and they'll be thinking twice about putting that person in a critical role.
I disagree again. It doesn’t have to be an ultimatum. If it’s delivered as one then what you describe will likely happen.
If a valued employee has an outside offer and brings it up tactfully with their manager it doesn’t have to be so binary as you position it to be.
You can accept a counter at your current employer, erode no trust and continue to do well there. Clearly yourself and none of your colleagues have experienced what I describe which is a shame.
To be clear, if you ever bring up an offer to your current boss you should always be willing to accept it in the event negotiations to stay are not fruitful
That said, at least in the US, there is huge demand for capable developers (see the salaries posted on levels.fyi) and I would encourage anyone who is at all able to take a few interviews to assess their market rate. There are plenty of companies who treat their developers well _and_ pay them well. There's no need to settle for just one of those.
My take was on something different - having an existing job and then using a competing job as leverage. I'm not sure how you'd frame it as not an ultimatum, because the employer almost certainly will regard it as an ultimatum.
Nor did I suggest "settling". I suggested if you get a better offer, take it.
If your manager takes offense to that, it probably isn't a great place to work in the first place.
But hey, it's your career, you get to do as you like! If I was right about everything, I'd be a billionaire.
Sure, and maybe my manager is sidelining me because I remind them of their ex. Anything is possible. As I said in the original comment, an objection is a sign of a place you probably don't want to be working at anyway. I would definitely jump at the first sign of trouble, but I would wait for that sign. I wouldn't assume there is trouble without any evidence or avoid trying to negotiate on the assumption that it will cause trouble.
I personally would never go the counteroffer route, regardless. If you want more money and you have a better offer just take that one.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Best_alternative_to_a_negoti...
Get the competing offer. Negotiate. Having a competing offer is a super strong signal for someone that is trying to hire you. It tells them you not only cleared their interviews but also cleared other interviews. It’s a hallmark of a competent person.
In fact, I think it is good practice to do interviews every once in a while to see what the market is willing to pay for you.
agree with not accepting a counteroffer. in fact, if it goes to that, you probably don’t want to work there anymore
Simple, because you want to make a profit. I can unironically and with all seriousness say I've chosen to become homeless on at least one occasion rather than work with people with your attitude.
If they want to keep you, they’ll pay and you win. If they don’t want to pay, you leave and still win.
Im sure there are companies out there giving raises out of the good of their heart but why would they do it?
If nobody else wants to pay you more, why would I?
I know this is frowned upon here at HN and we like to think people get rewarded for good performance but unfortunately only a fraction of companies work like that.
Good luck!