News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by TameAntelope on Friday April 15, 2022 @09:51PM (#31048402)
Society is expressing its collective free speech when it "cancels" someone, for whatever reason.

When you support "free speech", you support all of it or none of it.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by endominus on Friday April 15, 2022 @10:16PM (#31048612)
It's these types of absolutist statements that drive people away from activist causes. Even a staunch proponent of free speech might have some types of speech they object to;

- Advertising dangerous and addictive substances, particularly to children [0]

- Lying about the contents or efficacy of a commercial product, especially medicine or food [1]

- Publishing private details about someone in an effort to inflict real world harm [2]

- Publishing private work against the will of its creator, as might have happened with Sir Terry Pratchett's unfinished books after his death. [3] (I distinctly remember a commenter I had an argument with stating that after his death, his wishes in that regard were irrelevant compared to the living's desire to actually read said work. Fortunately, such callousness is not the norm)

Collective free speech is an interesting idea, in any case. I'm always wary of the term "collective." It brings to mind collective justice. It's not unthinkably terrible, after all, to throw a single stone at a sinner. And if my neighbor has the right to, so do I. And his neighbor, and her neighbor, and soon enough the sinner is stoned to death and none of us are responsible. All each of us did was throw a single stone, after all.

It's a strange dissonance to state that censorship is free speech. But that's what people seem to often mean when they talk about cancelling or deplatforming people.

[0]: https://www.fda.gov/tobacco-products/rules-regulations-and-g...

[1]: https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/nestle-baby...

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doxing

[3]: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2017/aug/30/terry-pratchet...

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by paulgb on Friday April 15, 2022 @10:24PM (#31048680)
You have good one-sentence summaries of things that are reasonable exceptions/limitations to free speech. I’m struggling to come up with one that would prevent cancel culture without sounding like an unreasonable exception. For example, “saying someone should be fired based on a bad joke they made on the internet” doesn’t sound like it should be illegal, even though that being spoken en masse is tantamount to cancel culture.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by TameAntelope on Friday April 15, 2022 @11:12PM (#31049046)
I didn't say, "All speech should be free or none of it should be free", I said, "Both the repugnant ideas and the rejection of the repugnant ideas are expressions of free speech, and you either support both or none."

Of course there's speech that should be limited. I'm just saying if you support repugnant speech, you either also support rejections of repugnant speech or you don't support free speech at all.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by stale2002 on Saturday April 16, 2022 @01:13PM (#31054075)
> I'm just saying if you support repugnant speech, you either also support rejections of repugnant speech or you don't support free speech at all.

No, thats stupid.

It is absolutely possible to both support free speech, and oppose "rejection" of repubnant speech, if by "rejection" we mean that I would oppose sending death threats to their friends and family, and oppose the "rejection" action of attempting to assault the repugnant free speech sayer.

It is very silly to say that a free speech supporter has somehow underminded their ability to support the concept of free speech significantly, because they opposed assaulting, or sending death threats to the friends and family of a person who makes repugnant speech.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by TameAntelope on Saturday April 16, 2022 @04:47PM (#31055954)
What's stupid is not realizing that both are forms of free speech. You can "oppose" it, but trying to prevent it is an attack on the freedom of speech. Either you support free speech, and the right of the "angry mob" to be angry, or you don't support free speech.

But the fact that you can't distinguish between the expression of an angry idea and a death threat disqualifies you from this conversation, though. Obviously that's different, and you know that isn't what anyone reasonable is suggesting.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by endominus on Saturday April 16, 2022 @05:51PM (#31056413)
You're equivocating between two different things, hence my comment on dissonantly categorizing censorship as free speech. A comment on this site a few days ago mentioned the difference between "pro-speech" and "anti-speech" dissent. Someone who disagrees with a repugnant idea but supports free speech might, for example, allow the speaker of the repugnant thought a platform and the opportunity to defend their idea, in the understanding that this affordance will be reciprocated and the truth and repugnance of that idea revealed. Someone who does not, fundamentally, believe in free speech can instead choose to bar the speaker from airing their opinions in any way. Sometimes this involves "speaking," defined broadly. For example, showing up to an event where the speaker is bearing airhorns or calling in bomb threats/pulling the fire alarm. Demanding that platforms remove the speaker. Publishing private information to intimidate others to silence.

The first path supports free speech. The second uses the high regard that free speech has in many minds to attack free speech. It is using "free speech" not as an ideal that allows many ideas to compete in honest search for the truth, but rather as a cudgel to censor heresy. A free speech advocate can absolutely oppose such speech without being inconsistent in their beliefs. One might say, "Free speech is that which allows me to hear anyone's point of view, regardless of how offended or hurt others might be by them." The mob shouting a speaker down deprives the rest of us that right.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by stale2002 on Saturday April 16, 2022 @05:34PM (#31056292)
> distinguish between the expression of an angry idea and a death threat

So then you agree that a free speech supporter opposing death threats and harassment of people's friends and family of those who make offensive speech does not undermine their pro free speech opinions.

Yeah that's my entire point.

> the right of the "angry mob" to be angry

What the free speech supporters oppose is this angry mob sending death threats and harassing the friends, family, and coworkers of people who have made offensive speech.

So yes, people can both support free speech, and oppose the angry mob when they harass, dox, and threaten to kill people who say offensive things

> that isn't what anyone reasonable is suggesting.

"Canceling" someone very often involves sending death threats, doxxing, and harassing people's friends, family and coworkers, when the angry mob is involved.

So yes, that happens, and is what the pro free speech supporters are opposing.

But yes, I agree that the angry mob that harasses, doxes, and threatens people when it "cancels" someone is unreasonable, and is what the pro free speech people oppose.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by chrismcb on Friday April 15, 2022 @11:52PM (#31049300)
You can support free speech and still ask people not to say things. I think cancel culture is bad. And people should stop trying to get people fired for saying something (especially if it was said ages ago) I'm not going to force you to stop. Just consider what you are doing. You are basically wishing the person would die (or before a ward of the state) is that the proper consequence of speech?

As a society we have agreed that somethings shouldn't be said. Like the n word. You aren't forced to not say it. By the same token we can agree that cancel culture is bad and chills speech. We, as a free society, should strive to keep speech free. Not look for ways to shut it down. I may not like what you say, but I'll fight for your right to say it, had become I don't like what you say so I will do everything in my power to prevent you from saying it

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by TameAntelope on Saturday April 16, 2022 @01:06AM (#31049655)
The problem you keep running into is that if we, as a society, value free speech, then we, as a society, also value the angry mob, because they are also exhibiting free speech! You can't just ignore the angry mob's rights, just because you don't like what they're saying.

If you like free speech and dislike cancel culture, the people to be angry at are the decision makers who kowtow to the mob's demands, not the mob itself (since they're just exercising their free speech, which you claim to support), but even then, aren't those decision makers just expressing themselves, too?

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ad404b8a372f2b9 on Saturday April 16, 2022 @06:37AM (#31051260)
I'm in complete agreement that workers' rights should be stronger and protect them from quisling employers. But there is also something to be said about the technological mechanisms that allow the mass-mob to form. For example in the case of people who have a few hundred followers and end up with hundreds of thousands of people talking about them, there is a hateful amplification that should not be enabled.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ModernMech on Saturday April 16, 2022 @09:18AM (#31052077)
> I'm in complete agreement that workers' rights should be stronger and protect them from quisling employers. But there is also something to be said about the technological mechanisms that allow the mass-mob to form.

Agreed entirely, but it’s interesting to note that 99% of the public discourse here on HN and also elsewhere focuses on the technical mechanisms and almost none of the discussion is about workers rights.

As the parent points out, the free speech position against cancel culture is internally inconsistent. That’s why these discussions have no solutions; because the paradox of increasing free speech by restricting free speech is never resolved.

Which is why I think we need to move past the idea of the mob. The mob has no power if your employer can’t fire you capriciously and ruin your life. That power exists irrespective of cancel culture, and needs to be curbed. Doing so would also serve to restrict corporate power considerably, which is why I believe this area of discussion goes unaddressed (it’s that there are a lot of people who are both anti cancel culture but pro corporate power.)

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by ad404b8a372f2b9 on Saturday April 16, 2022 @10:05AM (#31052412)
Yeah, I think that's the silicon valley effect. I often feel at odds with the majority viewpoint here when things like the free market, welfare, or regulations are being discussed.

Though in this case, I think the technological perspective makes the inconsistency you're speaking off disappear. It's arguable but I don't think free speech, left to its own devices, leads to these mass mobs as often as we're seeing it on Twitter & Cie. Our culture is being shaped by recommendation algorithms, that needs to be addressed along with workers' rights.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by tdehnel on Friday April 15, 2022 @10:54PM (#31048909)
Your wording is a bit of a sly semantic trick.

By attempting to equivocate stopping speech with free speech, it sort of dodges the whole purpose of free speech in the first place, which is to ensure that unpopular ideas are tolerated in a free society.

Free speech isn't just an abstract principle. It exists to ensure that tyranny of government or the masses is not able to stifle the creation of the new knowledge that progress depends on.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by SantalBlush on Friday April 15, 2022 @11:53PM (#31049306)
The improvement of knowledge is a useful side effect of free speech, but it's not the main justification. Free speech exists because it's wrong to harm someone because of what they say.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by tdehnel on Saturday April 16, 2022 @11:42AM (#31053200)
Firstly your belief is knowledge that was created at some point and it spread because people had the right to say it.

Second, a just society is dependent on there being a society at all. The only way humans will solve the problems that threaten our existence is by creating new knowledge.

In this way the progress created by free speech is foundational to all else.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by SantalBlush on Saturday April 16, 2022 @03:00PM (#31055077)
It appears that you're conflating the notion of free speech with any speech whatsoever, and implying that if free speech rights weren't enforced, then we would have no speech and thus would have no society and no knowledge. This is demonstrably false according to plenty of historical evidence. It's simply nonsense.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by tdehnel on Saturday April 16, 2022 @10:51PM (#31058043)
You got the wrong idea. I’m saying when we limit speech we risk limiting progress, not eliminating progress all together. The key is that we have no idea how we are limiting progress because the progress has yet to happen. But it will, as long as we tolerate new ideas and criticism (and not just the “right kind” of new ideas). We should always err on the side of more freedom rather than less, except in cases where there are imminent and likely illegal consequences.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by SantalBlush on Sunday April 17, 2022 @10:28AM (#31061065)
Again, this is absolutely not the main justification for free speech.

As a thought experiment, suppose we had a way of knowing which speech would advance knowledge and which speech would hinder our knowledge; by your reasoning, it would then be ethical to silence the speech that we knew would hinder our knowledge, since the point of free speech is to improve our collective knowledge.

This is wrong on its face. It's not what free speech is about. The concept exists because it's unethical to harm others over what they say.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by tdehnel on Sunday April 17, 2022 @10:55AM (#31061262)
The point is we don’t know. We will never know which new knowledge is created and which new problems will be caused. But only by allowing open and free trade of ideas will we be able to quickly solve them.

But to take your point and run with it…why is “because it’s ethical” a worthy goal? That seems to be circular reasoning, and also relies on one concept of “ethical”. How do we define what is ethical?

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by SantalBlush on Sunday April 17, 2022 @04:33PM (#31064206)
You already used your own notion of "ethical" in your original comment when you implied that stifling the creation of new knowledge is bad. Did you really think that just because you didn't use the word "ethical" in your comment, that it is devoid of ethical statements? That's not how it works. By suggesting that free speech has a "purpose", you are making an ethical statement.

>The point is we don’t know.

That's really not the point. Your whole thesis depends on your assumption that new knowledge is created. The contrapositive to your statement is that if no new knowledge is being created, then free speech doesn't matter; this is false.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by tdehnel on Monday April 18, 2022 @10:09AM (#31070807)
But new knowledge is always created as people solve problems which inevitably pop up. And the ethics of today are replaced with new ethics (knowledge) as people conjecture new ideas.

This process goes one way. Free speech leads to progress. Using a contrapositive is invalid because I’m not making an equivocacy, I’m making a causal statement. Man drives car doesn’t necessitate that car drives man.

And I’m not saying “ethics” are bad. Only that our current forms of them, like all forms of knowledge, will eventually be replaced by something better (see: all of history).

Anyway, you dodged the question so I’ll try answering it for you: Your sense of ethic in relation to speech was created because people had the freedom to criticize the fact that ethics come from God/priests/kings/tribal elders/et. al and develop new, better forms. In this way, your and my ethical forms will be replaced in the future by something better.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by SantalBlush on Monday April 18, 2022 @11:37AM (#31072141)
>Man drives car doesn’t necessitate that car drives man.

Fortunately that's not what I implied, and you fail to recognize the error in your own reasoning. I'll say this one final time, and I expect you'll intentionally misunderstand again.

Your point depends on the premise that free speech leads to the improvement of knowledge, which means that if a specific situation arose--even an isolated incident--where your premise of enhanced knowledge were untrue, then it follows that your conclusion that free speech is good would no longer be necessarily true. That is why your statement is false. The rest of what you've written is pseudo-intellectual fluff.

>But new knowledge is always created

This is not a given. You completely made it up. I wish you a pleasant day.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by tdehnel on Monday April 18, 2022 @02:46PM (#31074817)
>This is not a given.

Not with that attitude!

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by proc0 on Friday April 15, 2022 @10:21PM (#31048661)
So... silencing people is practicing free speech? I thought it was letting people talk.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by SantalBlush on Friday April 15, 2022 @11:40PM (#31049221)
Telling someone to shut up is not the same thing as telling someone to shut up while holding a gun. People need to stop conflating these two things.

People are free to express negative reactions to speech. That in itself is a pretty important part of free speech.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by chemmail on Saturday April 16, 2022 @05:30AM (#31050974)
Sounds good. Until it is used against you.
Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by sjg007 on Friday April 15, 2022 @10:14PM (#31048596)
>When you support "free speech", you support all of it or none of it.

Free speech is not tautological.

Re:My take on Elon's offer for Twitter by refurb on Saturday April 16, 2022 @06:15AM (#31051169)
“When I shout you into silence that’s just me expressing my support of free speech”

A fantastic hot take from HN