Re:Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol?
by chrisseaton on Thursday April 14, 2022 @04:39PM
(#31032976)
So the upload speed per song is real-time? Come-on - this conversation has turned silly.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol?
by necovek on Thursday April 14, 2022 @05:42PM
(#31033685)
BT 3.0 offered up to 24Mbps bandwidth, with other variants offering up to 3Mbps. CD quality music is 1.4Mbps. If you cannot come up with an error correcting scheme that will let you upload music in real time with those parameters, what parameters would you need? (And sure, these rates are hard to achieve with BT in real world because of varying distance and interference, and yes, CD quality music is not the highest quality encoding you can use, but you can achieve similar or better quality with less bandwidth too)
And let's not forget this was a discussion of buffering. A buffer of 5 minutes (50MiB) buys you 5 minutes of not having to be real-time, or to be slowly lagging behind — if that covers 3h of continuous listening time, you probably covered 99% of uses where latency is not a big deal anyway (like playing music — calls and movies are another game).
I already acknowledge practical UX problems with just relying on buffering, but it doesn't make much sense to say how it can't be done because of the protocol either.
Re:Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol?
by chrisseaton on Thursday April 14, 2022 @05:52PM
(#31033768)
But the protocol just doesn't support sending audio faster than it's supposed to be played. The sender doesn't know what to send to do what you want. There's no mechanism to do what you want for the headphones.
Re:Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol?
by Dylan16807 on Thursday April 14, 2022 @09:12PM
(#31035611)
Sure, the current protocol doesn't support it.
But wanting a better protocol isn't 'silly'.