Interestingly, the Wikipedia page you linked says that in some games, the player's chance does go up with each roll.
(Ctrl+F for 'pity')
> They key difference here is between people rationally knowing that those odds are independent, and them being able to bridge that to their irrational belief that they're special, or lucky, or that they're "owed" luck.
I think in part it's just greed as well, they think they can have that money that all those unlucky people have lost. This greed then gets rationalized as luck/skill/smarts in a way that's not dissimilar to how people rationalize joining pyramid schemes.
These pre-determined fixed odds make it such that the games support the opposite of your argument.
If outcomes were independent probability then it would be possible to for example win 100 games in a row (with astronomical probability, but it's still possible). In fact the machine owner neuters it so that the house won't lose in such a streak.
Similarly, the machines have a fixed payout %. If each outcome were truly independent, it would be possible for the machine to never pay out, just like it's possible to flip Heads any arbitrary number of times in a row.
Anyone sucked into these games thinking 'the next one will hit' is not committing to gambler's fallacy because these outcomes are not independent.
Slot machines are based on RNGs.
> If each outcome were truly independent, it would be possible for the machine to never pay out
It is possible for a machine to never pay out. That would probably trigger an audit to see if there's a bug, but there is no guarantee that th
So if £1000 is paid in during the day, the machine by law must pay out at least £700 in prizes. This is not allowed to be fully random, the odds of each game are not independent because they must by law ensure the minimum payout.
It's semi-common knowledge that the way to win at these machines is to watch them until you have seen someone else have a long losing streak, then take your turn when they leave as the machine is now 'behind' and overdue a payout.
Nevada has the opposite rule: machines must only incorporate chance when paying out and the theoretical payout is what the gaming commission analyzes. They can't dynamically adjust odds to favor a preferred payout. [1]
[0] https://www.gamblingcommission.gov.uk/authorities/guide/page...
[1] https://gaming.nv.gov/modules/showdocument.aspx?documentid=4...
> If outcomes were independent probability then it would be possible to for example win 100 games in a row (with astronomical probability, but it's still possible). In fact the machine owner neuters it so that the house won't lose in such a streak.
The possibilities you say cannot happen do happen. Let's look for example, at "Another Eden" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Another_Eden
I don't really know anything about it, but it was one of the first on wikipedia's list of gacha games that I googled "pity system" and got "no it doesn't have one".
Someone has made a simulator for it. If I go to https://ae-encounter-sim.github.io/ and click on "Weapon Discovery Manifestation", it shows me two characters on "rate up" (more common). The official probability of getting each of them is 0.8% chance for each "encounter".
I'll click until I get the first character (5star Melina apparently) and post my results:
1. First time, 360 encounters (36 10 bundles), cost of $959.88 USD.
2. Another try, 480 encounters, cost of $1,200 USD
3. Last try, 130 encounters, cost of $319.
It is very possible to get the desired outcome in 1 "encounter", or to run out of money first and never get it.
> the machines have a fixed payout % [that isn't independently random per trial]
There's no fixed payout if there's no pity system. Why would there be, they're just giving away jpeg images.
A lot of casino machines also don't necessarily have fixed payout. Over long enough time periods, the casino still wins, they don't really need to worry about incredibly improbable events. For those, they have insurance anyway.
> not committing to gambler's fallacy because these outcomes are not independent.
The simulator is supposedly accurate, and I expect the person who researched the probabilities to build it is likely to know what they're doing. Looks pretty independent to me: https://github.com/ae-encounter-sim/ae-encounter-sim.github....
I mean, in the introduction the author gives a standard definition of the Gambler's Fallacy, but then he immediately says "but it can't really mean that, because that's clearly irrational". It's not very hard to prove something is rational if you start by rejecting definitions that are irrational!
The bit where they present their main evidence against the gambler's fallacy:
> So back to gamblers. What is the gambler's fallacy? Many have suggested to me that it's the tendency to think that a heads is more likely after a string of tails, despite knowing that the tosses are statistically independent. But this can't be right––for no one commits that fallacy. After all, knowing that the tosses are independent is just knowing that a heads is not more (or less) likely after a string of tails
I think "no one commits that fallacy" is plainly untrue. There are various games (Gacha games, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gacha_game) where the outcome is random independent probability. In fact, due to gambling laws, these games have to publish exact probabilities.
Despite there being clear evidence, people will commit a combination of the sunk cost fallacy and gambler's fallacy and convince themselves to spend more money on more independent random trials because surely they're almost there.
We've seen similar things with lootboxes with published odds.
We see similar things with casinos that contain various games of true independent random probability.
They key difference here is between people rationally knowing that those odds are independent, and them being able to bridge that to their irrational belief that they're special, or lucky, or that they're "owed" luck. People are not rational, people can hold conflicting things in their head, and the gambler's fallacy is one of the common irrationalities a lot of people act on.