News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by numlocked on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:31AM (#30989277)
Wow, I have never heard this before:

“Few people remember it, but Gorbachev was negotiating with Saddam and had successfully convinced him to pull out of Kuwait. The agreement they came up with would give the Iraqis three weeks to pull out. At this point, it had become a major goal to eliminate the Republican Guard and we didn’t want them to pull their head out of the noose, so President Bush turned down the compromise and ordered the ground forces in.”

Is that true?

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by chubot on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:08PM (#30991801)
I wasn't aware of that history either -- this article gives more color:

https://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/20/world/middleeast/20archiv...

The Iraqi invasion happened in August 1990, and America's response was in January/February 1991.

It sounds like Saddam changed his tune because he saw the buildup of American forces over that time period. If there was no threat then he probably wouldn't have agreed to any settlement.

With the ground war just days away, Mr. Gorbachev mounted a peacemaking effort. Tariq Aziz, the Iraqi foreign minister, arrived in Moscow on Feb. 21. Later that day, Mr. Gorbachev told Mr. Bush in a phone call that he sensed a “serious shift” in Iraq’s position, according to a transcript in the Bush Library.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by chasd00 on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:54AM (#30989641)
> ordered the ground forces in

as i recall, the air war was so devastating there wasn't much of a purpose for ground troops and when it came time to "order the ground forces in" most of the work was just walking across Kuwait. They even made a movie about how much of a let down the ground war was to the Marines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jarhead_(film)

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by lmickh on Monday April 11, 2022 @04:31PM (#30994542)
I wouldn't go so far as to say there wasn't much purpose for the ground troops in the context of the goal of eliminating Iraqi military capabilities. It involved some of the largest tank battles in US history such as the Battle of Norfolk and the Battle of the 73 Easting. While we look back at some of these as a steam roll in hindsight, the truth is the engagements were larger than most of the armor battles in WW2 involving the US.

The marine advancement in to Kuwait that was part of a larger multi-national push that much of the Iraqi forces were running from. The push by 1st Inf Div, 2nd ACR, and others on the west was to cut off that retreat.

Combat theaters are large and it is never a good idea to take a narrow view of them and generalize it to the whole. The father of my childhood friend used to tell us how his deployment in Vietnam as an MP was some of the best time in his life. He spent his entire time on a post relatively far from the fighting largely killing his time trying to surf and eat BBQ.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by queuebert on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:21PM (#30991982)
Generation Kill is a great movie in a similar vein about the second invasion.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by cja on Monday April 11, 2022 @02:44PM (#30992916)
It's a mini series, and yes, it's brilliant
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by gumby on Monday April 11, 2022 @11:23AM (#30990074)
I think you mean Hollywood filmed a book written by one of those marines.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by libraryatnight on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:11PM (#30993309)
I think he said what he meant. But, I think you meant "I know you linked a wiki that explains the film is based on a memoir in the first line, but you've already exposed yourself to the 'It was a book first!' attack, and I don't want to have to turn in my 'Ackchyually Guy,' membership card." Since we're speculating.

A more charitable reading would be that you simply meant, "Yes, that movie is based on a book by one of those marines." Maybe with some added opinion on whether you enjoyed it or found it equally as enlightening.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by burnte on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:06PM (#30991777)
Well, he DID say "they made a movie" so yes, obviously that is exactly what he meant.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by robonerd on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:08PM (#30990785)
Have you heard of the 'Highway of Death'? Iraqi forces were retreating on that highway, on their way back to Iraq. Coalition forces did not want to permit that, and slaughtered them. Thousands of vehicles destroyed, hundreds+ soldiers killed, thousands more captured.

I can't say I feel much sympathy towards the Iraqis here, but it does seem a tad bit vindictive.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by nautilius on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:33PM (#30992123)
Human tragedy aside (and it absolutely is, no doubt about it, on all sides), it really depends on the context.

Striking the retreating army is the 'easiest' way to 'neutralize' it, Clausewitz writes about it, and I am sure it's been practiced for thousand(s?) of years before that.

For a timely comparison: would it be 'vindictive' when Ukraine strikes the retreating Russian army in the Kyiv area before they regroup and attack the Donbas? I don't think so. Seems like a good idea, actually.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by joshocar on Monday April 11, 2022 @02:01PM (#30992476)
It's how battles have been won for thousands of years. The two army's approach each other and take minor casualties until one sides moral collapses, they break, and route. 90% of the deaths happened after the route.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by twic on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:00PM (#30993154)
Reminds me of the sinking of the General Belgrano during the Falklands War. The story at the time was that the Belgrano, an Argentinian warship, was leaving the Falklands to return to Argentina, when a British submarine sunk her; there were many in the UK who considered this an outrage, on the grounds that she was no longer contributing the occupation of the Falklands, so should have been left alone.

That analysis never made much sense to me, and apparently it later came out that the Belgrano wasn't leaving the Falklands anyway, and much later on the captain of the Belgrano said he thought that the British were quite right to sink it [1]!

[1] https://ukdefencejournal.org.uk/britain-was-right-to-sink-th...

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by AtlasBarfed on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:01PM (#30993170)
Well, it probably saved Kurdish lives to some degree. Remember that Iraq is a British Empire construction of three opposing ethnic groups (Shia, Sunni, Kurd) and Saddam was a Sunni oppressing the other two.

Wiping out his best soldiers may have reduced his ability to suppress the other two ethnic groups.

Or it made Shia and Kurds more active and sowed MORE conflict. Who can predict such things.

But from realist international puppet string wannabes, it neutered Saddam's military and ability to threaten Kuwait or Saudi Arabia. The US was just a mercenary army for the Kuwait and Saudi royal families in this "war".

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by empiko on Monday April 11, 2022 @02:44PM (#30992927)
It is obviously a matter of context. Russian army in Kyiv is indeed able to regroup and attack again. Iraqi army was by all means a defeated force that was running for its life into Iraq where civil war just started. The risk of it attacking Kuwait again was zero.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by oh_sigh on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:03PM (#30993212)
A defeated force can still regroup in, say, Baghdad and make the city much harder to take.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by chipsa on Monday April 11, 2022 @02:31PM (#30992761)
They were retreating, not surrendering. They were bringing with them all their arms and armor (literally, bringing their tanks back). We stopped them because they very well could have regrouped to when they were back in Iraq. They were not 'hors de combat'.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by pmoriarty on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:20PM (#30991962)
"I can't say I feel much sympathy towards the Iraqis here"

Why wouldn't you feel sympathy for people who were killed or maimed, and their families?

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by robonerd on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:04AM (#31014777)
It's funny how I got some comments insinuating that I have too much sympathy, and yours which seems to say I have too little. I'll address both in this single comment.

What little sympathy I have, is because people died. I don't have more sympathy because 1) those Iraqis invaded another country. 2) They didn't surrender. I am well aware that retreating but not surrendering soldiers get shot in wars, and I'm not particularly upset about it when those soldiers are on the belligerent side. I have some shred of sympathy for them, only because they are still human.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by trhway on Monday April 11, 2022 @08:42PM (#30997172)
>I can't say I feel much sympathy towards the Iraqis here, but it does seem a tad bit vindictive.

they could have always surrender and become POW.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by zaphirplane on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @06:41AM (#31000833)
I have mo idea what your background is. How do you imagine a cog in an authoritarian country to surrender during a war. Mutiny, summary executions, retaliation against family, shamed as a coward.

Many did when command and control broke down

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by SubjectToChange on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:43PM (#30993762)
Do you think the Ukrainians were in the wrong when they killed Russians during their withdrawal? Or are rules different for the underdog?
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by xyzzy21 on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:33PM (#30991212)
Just google "gorbachev saddam 1991"

The answer is "pretty much true".

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by 88840-8855 on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:57PM (#30992423)
I took now half an hour to check sources on that and it seems to be pretty much the color.

Curious that nobody asked to sanction the US to destroy their economy and to isolate them for that war... or any of the other wars.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by chasd00 on Monday April 11, 2022 @02:18PM (#30992621)
the coalition built for gulf war 1 was extensive to say the least. I think that was one of Bush Sr's requirements, if anyone was going to liberate Kuwait it had to be everyone. You would have to sanction the entire coalition which was basically the entire western world.

Bush Sr. convinced everyone to stop at Iraq's border and wouldn't push further to knock out Hussain's regime. Wisely, IMO for all the reasons that are clear today. However, lots of people think this is what cost him a second term and left many people at the pentagon feeling like there was unfinished business in Iraq. This "unfinished business" is what eventually led to Bush Jr's invasion.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by cafard on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:22PM (#30993452)
What cost him the second term was the economy.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by nickdothutton on Monday April 11, 2022 @05:33PM (#30995386)
Actually in the end the US went soft on Iraq. Thatcher wanted to roll into Baghdad and clean it out properly (or, she argued we’d find ourselves there again in a decade or 2). Bush disagreed.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by audiometry on Tuesday April 12, 2022 @10:12AM (#31002994)
Imagine if it were true. Then maybe no Forever Wars in Iraq, Afghanistan, etc.

Or something else horrid and gross would have developed.

[dead]
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by sudosysgen on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:53AM (#30989628)
It would probably be better to do a simple fact check before going on a dubious grand narrative :

https://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/20/world/middleeast/20archiv...

> After prodding by Mr. Gorbachev, Mr. Hussein had offered to withdraw Iraqi troops from Kuwait in 21 days. But the United States appeared to be moving ahead with its land campaign.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by antattack on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:59AM (#30989728)
21 days seems like a delay tactics since it took Iraqi troops just two days to invade.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by teh_klev on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:08PM (#30990786)
Iraq was able to "complete" its invasion and decapitation of military command & control in two days because the Kuwaitis were massively under prepared. After that you then need to consolidate your position and that would be days if not weeks of deploying troops and their equipment deeper into the country.

So after seven months of occupation there's probably a heap of logistics required to extricate and decamp your forces & equipment that likely isn't going to happen even in 10-15 days.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by waffleiron on Monday April 11, 2022 @11:10AM (#30989885)
It probably took them longer to prepare than just 2 days.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by badRNG on Monday April 11, 2022 @11:00AM (#30989735)
BLUF: The fact that nuking Japan wasn't necessary isn't some Russian propaganda, it was a sentiment strong even among many of the top brass of the military and Truman administration.

Not to start a whole debate on the utility of nuking Japanese civilians, but that "narrative" of the bombing being unjustified is nearly as old as the event itself, certainly not something that just became "popular in the last decade."

- Gen Eisenhower famously stated "It wasn’t necessary to hit them with that awful thing."

- Fleet Admiral Nimitz, Commander and Chief of the Pacific Fleet, stated "The Japanese had, in fact, already sued for peace. The atomic bomb played no decisive part, from a purely military point of view, in the defeat of Japan." (Though Nimitz's perspective is slightly diminished from reports that he initially supported using atomic weapons.)

- Major General Curtis LeMay, XXI Bomber Command (a unit of the Twentieth Air Force in the Mariana Islands for strategic bombing during World War II.), stated "The atomic bomb had nothing to do with the end of the war at all."

- Fleet Admiral William Halsey Jr, "The first atomic bomb was an unnecessary experiment ... It was a mistake to ever drop it ... [the scientists] had this toy and they wanted to try it out, so they dropped it."

Other high ranking officials like Fleet Admiral Leahy (Truman Chief of Staff), are on the record stating that nuking Japan wasn't necessary. Now maybe even given these perspectives, perhaps they are all wrong. What I can say for certain is that this perspective isn't without "any real rooting in primary source materials and is pushed on a speculative basis by fringe academics looking to make a name with an out-there theory."

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by robonerd on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:18PM (#30990929)
After the second atomic bombing, Japanese army officers tried to overthrow the Emperor to prevent the surrender. They narrowly failed, after successfully placing the Emperor under house arrest, because the surrender message was smuggled out of the palace. And this happened in Tokyo, which surely knew the horrors of war already, having been extensively firebombed for months. Had things gone a little differently, it's possible that two bombs might not have been enough.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by badRNG on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:29PM (#30991136)
I think maybe either my comment was misinterpreted or I wasn't clear enough.

As I stated before, I'm not wanting to start a debate on whether nuking Japan was justified nor am I taking a position one way or the other. What my comment aims to do is to push back on specific claims made about this position (that the bombing was unjustified,) namely the claims that this position is recent, not rooted in primary sources, is a fringe out-there position to give academics a name for themselves, and originates in Russian propaganda.

It is not recent, it is rooted in primary sources, and it was a position held from the very beginning by the top brass of the US military at the time.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by Animats on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:43PM (#30992248)
This reads like an ad for the QJM model. The DePuy Institute had a proprietary model for figuring out who wins a battle. This was invented by General William DePuy, one of the leading planners of the US loss in Vietnam. He came up with a Quantitative Judgement Model for evaluating military strength. It's mostly adding up weapons values (sword = 1.0), although there are other features of the model. There are tables, now used mostly by war gamers. DePuy looked at a large number of historical battles, and came up with weights which seemed to work. The result was supposedly that the side with a 2:1 advantage almost always won. Within the 2:1 range, it was a tossup.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by mandevil on Monday April 11, 2022 @02:28PM (#30992725)
Two different people with differently spelled last names: General William DePuy (who was MACV C-o-S, BigRedOne-Six and then ran TRADOC after the war, and is considered the architect of the rebuilding of the Army after Vietnam) is unrelated to Col. Trevor Dupuy. Both of them fought in the US Army in WW2, and have confusingly similar names, but Dupuy is the one who founded the Dupuy Institute to do his numerical analysis of combat with all of his models and fudge factors.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by Animats on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:04PM (#30993224)
Oh! Thanks.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by jhgb on Monday April 11, 2022 @09:35AM (#30988455)
Quite interesting. I though this would be about DART (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_Analysis_and_Replannin...), but I take it that this is more about front line stuff.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by dayofthedaleks on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:18AM (#30989068)
Amateurs talk about killbots. Professionals train their AIs on logistics.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by imglorp on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:59PM (#30991657)
I think it depends, right?

If you have a small number of high cost, high impact UAVs, you will target infra and supply columns.

If you happen to have a cargo plane full of cheap, mass produced head-popper slaughterbots which you can dump over a town, they will remove all the humans and leave you with intact buildings, vehicles, and infra. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HipTO_7mUOw

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by rsecora on Monday April 11, 2022 @02:17PM (#30992608)
Parent comment was jokingly paraphrasing General Bradley words: “Amateurs talk strategy. Professionals talk logistics."
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by jamessb on Monday April 11, 2022 @09:51AM (#30988672)
"Introduced in 1991, DART had by 1995 offset the monetary equivalent of all funds DARPA had channeled into AI research for the previous 30 years combined"

Thanks for the link - someone at BBN had told me a similar story, but I didn't know the name of the program.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by buescher on Monday April 11, 2022 @01:46PM (#30992295)
I didn't know about DART. Developed and deployed in eight weeks [edit: less optimistic sources say 23 months]! Is there a good retrospective somehwere with some technical detail?
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by monkeybutton on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:10PM (#30993296)
Seconding. I'd be interested in reading more into it.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by Arainach on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:28PM (#30991108)
This seems to have flown entirely over my head:

QJM == Quantified Judgment Model. Other than what the acronym stands for, I'm still not sure what it is or why it's better, as this article never explains. The best short explanation I've found is "The QJM consists of two submodels whose interactions represent several battlefield intangibles such as leadership, morale, and training." [1]

WEI/WUV (that's one thing, not two, and if you try to search for just WEI you'll get nowhere) == Weapon effectiveness index/weighted unit value. [2]

It seems to me that this 2017 post from the same blog [3] is all but required prereading, with the problem that many of its linked sources (such as the one that might explain WEI/WUV) are dead and point to .mil domains that do not currently exist.

[1] https://calhoun.nps.edu/handle/10945/23101

[2] https://www.jstor.org/stable/26553096

[3] http://www.dupuyinstitute.org/blog/tag/wei-wuv/

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by wrp on Monday April 11, 2022 @08:40PM (#30997159)
PDF for [2] at https://info-gap.net.technion.ac.il/files/2018/05/mil-eff006...

Christopher Lawrence took over after Dupuy. He explains the current state of their project in War by Numbers (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/32824088-war-by-numbers). He brings this methodology to bear on some recent conflicts in America's Modern Wars (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/22224145-america-s-moder...). Reviews have been very skeptical.[1,2]

[1] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0968344517747141k

[2] https://www.miwsr.com/2016/downloads/2016-039.pdf [PDF]

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by techdmn on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:37AM (#30989365)
I'm shocked at the lack of humanity in this story. Every once in a while an "enemy" will start a war, and we'll get a bunch of coverage about orphans and mothers and fathers and horror, and I think maybe just maybe people will realize that all wars are terrible. Except when we start them, then I guess it's mostly kind of funny because our intelligence wasn't as great as it could have been?
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by bpodgursky on Monday April 11, 2022 @11:09AM (#30989859)
The US didn't start the war that Desert Storm ended.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraqi_invasion_of_Kuwait

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by deburo on Monday April 11, 2022 @11:42AM (#30990329)
All wars are bad and the US doesn't go to war because it thinks it's funny. Unrelated people may joke about it, as usual.
Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by AtlasBarfed on Monday April 11, 2022 @03:04PM (#30993216)
Why were we in Iraq the second time?

Why were we in Vietnam?

Why did we stay in Afghanistan for so long?

The military industrial complex does indeed find war funny. It's called laughing all the way to the bank.

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by xyzzy21 on Monday April 11, 2022 @12:40PM (#30991314)
This is what war is all about.

This is why many want cooler heads to prevail in the Russia-Ukraine war now!

Those who have lived through war know how horrific and uncontrollable it is and how sociopathic you need to become to wage it successfully.

Intelligence is the first problem. Then the model to fit it to. Then the conclusions to take from it. Each layer is HIGHLY prone to error.

Just an example: precision munitions largely eliminate the odds of NOT killing to zero but then it's the intelligence and interpretation that becomes the weak link: are you really hitting the right target for the larger purpose, or are you doing everything wrong hitting the wrong target because you are measuring success wrongly (e.g. body count - as we did in Vietnam and then returned to in Iraq and Afghanistan - simply because it was the only thing we could measure; classic "streetlight fallacy")

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McNamara_fallacy

Re:A story about planning for Desert Storm by kenneth on Monday April 11, 2022 @10:25PM (#30997876)
Sometimes, war is necessary and early action prevents a far worse outcome. You could argue that if Hitler had been dealt with earlier (e.g. when he invaded Poland), he would not have been able to get started causing such a rampage. But fear and inaction by other European powers at the time caused him to be emboldened by early success, and to pick off neighbors one by one.

I would argue Russia is in a very similar position today, and if we don't act decisively now, we're just enabling Putin to do far more damage in the long run. The risk of WWIII and a nuclear exchange does exist, but the risk of on inaction is just as high.