News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by FuzzyDunlop on Monday October 10, 2011 @07:16PM (#3096310)
The source is the Daily Mail. Anyone familiar with that rag will know never to take whatever they say as truth.

Surprised they didn't run with 'Google+ gives you cancer'.

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by sambeau on Monday October 10, 2011 @08:54PM (#3096584)
Funny. True in general. But in this case The Daily Mail aren't necessarily being deliberately disingenuous.*

What the original post is saying as that when the doors opened to the public, Google+ traffic went up nearly 5-fold in a month from a private Google-staff-and-their-freinds beta.

Even if we ignore the fact that it went up 1200% and then dropped back again, 5-fold seems a little disappointing.

Also, surely it is correct reporting to point out that there was a massive drop-off effect. People signed up in their droves, tried it and then left.

No matter how Google try to spin this, it can't be good. If Google+ continues to slowly build back over the next few months then maybe they will be fine. But, based on a small biased sample of my 'social graph' it doesn't look like it.

*—I can't believe I'm defending The Daily Mail.

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by redthrowaway on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @02:16AM (#3097383)
Whatever happens with G+, I hope it stays around. It's twitter with longer posts, and facebook without the idiots. Aside from the network effect not having kicked in yet, it really is an ideal service for me.
Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by bergie on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @02:45AM (#3097472)
We had a service like that in Finland, called Qaiku. Now quite a lot of the users seem to have migrated to Google+
Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by nknight on Monday October 10, 2011 @09:28PM (#3096666)
Um, no. It wasn't "from a private Google-staff-and-their-friends" beta, it was from the modestly-controlled semi-open beta that ran along the same lines as the earlier gmail "beta" with "invite codes" given fairly plentifully to everyone already using the service.

There were millions of people with no close connection to Google already using G+ by the time the floodgates were fully opened on September 20th, which is the magic day DM chooses for their laughable reporting.

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by sambeau on Monday October 10, 2011 @09:40PM (#3096685)
"Floodgates fully open"

But enough of a difference between the "modestly-controlled semi-open beta" and "fully opened" to see a a 1200% increase.

The floodgates opened, the tide rushed in, the tide ran out. How is this a success for Google+?

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by wnight on Monday October 10, 2011 @09:51PM (#3096715)
Five times more users, that stayed.
Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by potatolicious on Monday October 10, 2011 @10:20PM (#3096797)
And yet still a decidedly non-mainstream audience:

http://socialstatistics.com/top/people/followers/0

G+ has no hope unless they can somehow break into the mainstream. It's not looking good right now.

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by jarek on Monday October 10, 2011 @10:50PM (#3096858)
So 5 out of 10 most followed users are mainstream celebrities three and a half months after launch? Seems pretty good to me.
Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by wnight on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @12:18AM (#3097088)
Quit changing the topic. You asked "How is this a success for Google+?"

What's the bar now? Suddenly being #1?

Anyways, whatever. I'm not on G+ because I'm not a fan of their real-name policy and I certainly don't care if they win or lose. I was just pointing out that you were playing the same game the newspaper was - asking a crazy question given the nearly five-times increase in traffic over a single month.

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by potatolicious on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @01:05AM (#3097191)
No topic was ever changed - we all know Google is in this game to beat (or at least, take a significant minority share) of Facebook's traffic.

The number of users it gained need not be relevant to this goal - they need to gain the right users, and so far that's just not happening. They've won over the technorati, and puzzlingly enough, the photography community. But how many of your non-tech friends are actually on G+? Much less using it?

> ""How is this a success for Google+?""

For one thing, that wasn't me. But let's say it was. Your claim that traffic jumped by 5x is supposed to imply that this was a success for Google - but it's nothing of the sort. Without breaking into the mainstream, Google has no hope of capturing the type of market share, ever, that they are clearly after.

Google is not in this to build a niche social network for the techno-elite.

> "What's the bar now? Suddenly being #1"

What a ridiculous straw man. Nobody says G+ needs to be #1 overnight. But at least movement in the right direction (i.e., mainstream appeal) is necessary if one is to reasonably claim that G+ is succeeding. That's simply not happening.

> "I was just pointing out that you were playing the same game the newspaper was - asking a crazy question given the nearly five-times increase in traffic over a single month."

The newspaper asked a relevant question. Are we supposed to just blindly swallow any number and interpret it in the default manner? By your logic, Groupon is smashingly successful company with strong growth numbers - but we know it's not playing well into their end-game. Neither is this playing into G+'s desired endgame.

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by sambeau on Monday October 10, 2011 @10:19PM (#3096795)
No. 5x more traffic.
Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by wnight on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @12:21AM (#3097095)
Oh, thanks.
Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by simonsarris on Monday October 10, 2011 @09:04PM (#3096600)
I hate to post trite things on HN but if you haven't heard of the Daily Mail there is a good (and humorous) summary of the paper made into a song using only their headlines:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5eBT6OSr1TI

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by FuzzyDunlop on Wednesday October 12, 2011 @07:15PM (#3105124)
There's also this spectacular database of what causes and cures cancer (as reported by the DM):

http://kill-or-cure.heroku.com/

(also applies to reply below... and has been linked already! oops)

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by Tyrannosaurs on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @07:10AM (#3098101)
I assume that this is a reference to their excellent "Facebook gives you cancer" piece:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-1149207/How-using-...

Always worth another look if you want a reminder how far the press has fallen.

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by maushu on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @07:24AM (#3098119)
I thought this was a reference to Ted's "Node is Cancer":

http://teddziuba.com/2011/10/node-js-is-cancer.html

Seems that nowadays lots of things are cancer.

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday October 12, 2011 @08:39AM (#3102672)
The Daily Mail (the paper in question here) often seems to be on a quest to divide everything in the world into two groups - things that cause cancer and things that cure cancer.
Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by FuzzyDunlop on Wednesday October 12, 2011 @07:19PM (#3105143)
Non-UK readers are missing a hell of a lot when it comes to the Daily Mail and the Express. Not even Fox News could top it.

Give it a few weeks and Princess Diana will be found alive on G+.

Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by carlio on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @06:27AM (#3098004)
So far there isn't a definitive decision on whether Google+ gives you cancer or not - http://kill-or-cure.heroku.com/a-z/g
Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by mpclark on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @09:45AM (#3098496)
I was disappointed to see this story pop up in my Techmeme feed yesterday. IMHO getting tech stories from the Daily Mail is dangerously close to jumping the shark...
Re:Google+ traffic grew by 480% in one month so press report... by wgx on Tuesday October 11, 2011 @04:41AM (#3097760)
True, it's not known as "The Daily Fail" for nothing.