News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by exabrial on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:40PM (#30937757)
How about we just replace the IRS instead? 5% flat VAT tax. No exceptions. No tax breaks. No more tax incentives.

EDIT: Ope, my original point is a flat tax. I said VAT as I was trying to decide 'what' to tax in my head, and it seems thats what people are latching onto, instead of my three sentences following of "No exceptions".

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by tablespoon on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:53PM (#30937920)
> How about we just replace the IRS instead? 5% flat VAT tax. No exceptions. No tax breaks. No more tax incentives.

How about we not? And instead of a some VAT flat-tax nonsense, how about progressive income and wealth taxes with no tax breaks or incentives at the higher brackets?

Now that we've settled that, lets talk about the IRS's software.

Edit:

> EDIT: Ope, my original point is a flat tax. I said VAT as I was trying to decide 'what' to tax in my head, and it seems thats what people are latching onto, instead of my three sentences following of "No exceptions".

That doesn't improve your point as much as you think it does. It's still the kind of tax proposal that the wealthy put out because it's friendly to them (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Forbes#Campaigns_for_pre...).

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by deeptote on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:58PM (#30937963)
Agreed, consumption taxes overwhelmingly favor the rich.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by namelessoracle on Thursday April 07, 2022 @11:24AM (#30945682)
Im pretty sure existing tax laws favor the rich right now too
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by scrubs on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @09:20PM (#30939557)
I'm not seeing much action, but this is one area where Biden has the right talk. The rich (define north of $500k/yr) can play games. Here's two off hand I know in my circle:

- a family has non-trivial assets and income in three states but for federal and tax purposes they live in TN where's there's no state tax. The other two states are def not cheap compared to TN. This was setup by buying a house and having a part time job in TN for about 1 year to establish bonafide residency much of which stopped once gained

- business owner takes annual trip to Florida for business training with board/ management. That's a write off. But with some fancy accounting the owner smiles saying once they open the meeting with lunch, they left and spent the rest of week playing golf.

Whether the company or individual the rich guys are taxed less than me.

The bottom 40% (??) don't pay much either.

That leaves the upper middle class to foot a lot of the hill. Well I'm calling BS on that.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by zionic on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:24PM (#30938219)
Progressive (numerically) taxes are socially regressive and profoundly unjust.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by tablespoon on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:44PM (#30938393)
> Progressive (numerically) taxes are socially regressive and profoundly unjust.

What do you mean, exactly? My intuition tells me the definitions you're assigning to "socially" and "unjust" would prove to be peculiar after being unpacked.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by zionic on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:34PM (#30960835)
The elite don't pay taxes the same as everyone else, this is largely true throughout history.

(Numerically) progressive taxes are a tool by the elite to enact unjust regressive tax structures on the middle and upper-middle class to prevent them from rising to their level.

The goal is to make sure that doctor making $300k never gets all uppity so that his grandkids start challenging the status quo.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by kodah on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:22PM (#30938212)
What are "the higher brackets"?
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by ghaff on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:54PM (#30937932)
Wealthier people would love it. This was a pretty popular conservative tax proposal back in the 1980s or so. (Actually a flat VAT tax is even more regressive than a flat tax generally.)
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by helloooooooo on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:54PM (#30937929)
So you want to cause the greatest impact to those who spend the largest portion of income, rather than invest? This is frankly a terrible policy proposal and would only serve to harm the least well off. Leave it to Silicon Valley types who make a large enough fortune to retire by 40 to not understand the needs of those less well off.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by pooper on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:18PM (#30938176)
> No tax breaks. No more tax incentives.

While I strongly disagree with the rest of the comment, I also am furiously in support of getting rid of all credits, deductions, exemptions, incentives, and so on.

I think we need a VAT at the federal government level but we also need to increase the federal income tax on everyone. I would like this tax hike to pay for Medicare for all.

Problem is that over sixty percent of the people seem satisfied with the current status of healthcare. Also I imagine they tend to vote in higher proportion than people like me. I have no idea how to fix this situation. Anyone have any thoughts?

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by arghnoname on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:25PM (#30938239)
I used to be vehemently in favor of medicare for all. I still see all the many problems in the American healthcare system I ever did, but I don't want medicare for all anymore. My faith in our political system and its authoritarian impulses makes the thought of our government having a monopoly on healthcare unacceptable to me.

As someone who has been on both sides of this issue, I think this is common. It isn't about loving the private insurance companies--everyone knows they suck--it's about trusting that the government solution will be better. With our government, can you honestly and with full confidence say it would be? My confidence totally flipped. I'm more confident it would be a disaster than not and then would be weaponized politically.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:48PM (#30937858)
In general, I like the idea. Couple it with a UBI to protect the poor, and I like it a lot. (The poor pay very little income tax. They would have to pay the VAT. That would hurt them compared to the current system.)

But that won't get you where you say you want to go. Who's going to collect that VAT, and make sure that everybody pays it? The IRS. Your approach would get rid of the tax code, but not the IRS. (In getting rid of the tax code, it would let you get rid of the computer code in question, though.)

The other problem is, you can't implement a "soak the rich" approach with a VAT. And currently, there's a lot of angst around wealth inequality, and most plans to do something about it involve taxing the rich more than everyone else. So your idea is fighting an enormous political headwind.

You could propose something like VAT + income tax for those who make over $1 million/year or something...

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by exabrial on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:56PM (#30937954)
> You could propose something like VAT + income tax for those who make over $1 million/year or something...

What did a person making $1m/year do wrong they are penalized unfairly against another person that doesn't? I have a feeling, much like now, all this accomplishes in reality is the rich hire good enough accounts to hide their largest sums from the IRS. That leaves the middle class and poor once again bearing everything... and we're back to where we started. Carving out 0 exceptions and sticking to it ensures that that literally nobody can say they are being treated unfairly.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:02PM (#30938015)
Well, spin it how you will, but we've had this idea of a "progressive" tax system for quite a while now. ("Progressive" in the sense that those who make more, pay more, presumably because they can afford it more.) Our tax system has been that way for more than a century. So, you can call that "penalized unfairly", and others can call it "paying their fair share", but the reality is that it is the current default option. If you want a different system, you're going to need a lot better argument than "penalized unfairly". You're going to need an argument that can move the majority of voters, most of whom do not make more than $1 million/year.

My previous point wasn't anything about "should", by the way. I was merely saying that, in the current political climate, not hitting the rich harder was something that would make it harder for a VAT-only scheme to become reality.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by jfengel on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:15PM (#30938143)
You're going to need an argument that can move the majority of voters, most of whom do not make more than $1 million/year.

Note that a lot of voters are convinced that they will make $1 million/year some day. Perhaps not today, but some day, and they seem happy to pay more today to ensure that they are not "penalized unfairly" when it's their turn.

This is not necessarily a rational approach, since very few of them will ever earn that much money. But if your goal is to get votes, you can go a very, very long way with "penalized unfairly". Note how many oppose an inheritance tax that they'll never pay, simply by the expedient of dubbing it a "death tax".

The "penalized unfairly" argument wouldn't wash with most economists, but there's not all that many of them. And nobody really listens to them anyway.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by jonnycomputer on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:58PM (#30937965)
Its not that I disagree, I think the VAT is much better than an income tax; but that has nothing to do with the IRS. The IRS would still have to administer the collection of tax revenue.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by TAForObvReasons on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:53PM (#30937918)
VAT is generally considered to be regressive (lower and middle class people tend to spend a larger percentage of their income and therefore are disproportionally affected).

The taxation system reflects our societal values to an extent: tax breaks incentivize some activities and excess taxes disincentivize. Pure VAT disincentivizes spending and rewards wealth hoarding.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by jonnycomputer on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:00PM (#30937988)
A tax system can be regressive and more efficient. The regressivity of a tax system can be offset by benefits, such as UBI, etc. Why is it that Europe has less income inequality and VAT? Because it is offset with a generous welfare state.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by TAForObvReasons on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:13PM (#30938122)
European countries also have significantly higher income and other taxes. For example, in Germany, the marginal personal tax rate above 57K euros per year is 42% and the top rate is 45%. In the US, at $100K the marginal rate is 24% and the top marginal rate (above $540K) is 37%. That 8% difference at the top probably explains the income inequality situation moreso than any other difference
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by noodlesUK on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:47PM (#30938406)
I hear this from a lot of Europeans (I am also European), but it’s not really an apples to apples comparison. In the UK for instance we have a higher income tax rate of 40%. The US 37% rate is lower (but also comes in at a way higher threshold). However, in the US you also have state income taxes which range from 0-12ish percent, so your overall tax rate can end up higher
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by jonnycomputer on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @08:43PM (#30939292)
My main experience with taxes in Europe is in Poland, and that second hand from my mother-in-law, mostly.

In the US, a typical tax payer will pay federal income tax, federal medicare and social security payroll taxes, state income tax (which varies a lot by state, but can be much more regressive than the federal income tax), and municipal or county property taxes (usually real-estate, but may also include things like vehicles), and a state+municipal sales tax on purchases. Not to mention various other taxes specific to things like gasoline, alcohol, tobacco, etc, and various usage fees for toll roads, etc.

I'm sure things are similar in Europe in many ways, and different in others, but it can be a little hard to figure out how much I pay in tax total in a year, and I'm hardly an unusual case. All of this to really underline your point that just talking about US income tax is too incomplete a picture for the purpose of comparison.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by nathanvanfleet on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:48PM (#30937857)
Making a really strong argument here.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by hindsightbias on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @08:33PM (#30939210)
Tax law exists codify the exemptions for the rich. Gates, Bezos, billionaires/etc don’t pay taxes, you do.

You can get rid of the IRS the day after you get rid of the rich.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by WalterBright on Thursday April 07, 2022 @12:29AM (#30940618)
The vast bulk of Federal income tax revenue still comes from the rich. Getting rid of them isn't going to help the rest.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by jakearmitage on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:53PM (#30937919)
VAT hurts the poor and the middle class. Seems like a bad move when we have billionaires playing around with rockets in space.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by WalterBright on Thursday April 07, 2022 @12:32AM (#30940630)
Rich people playing with airplanes is how we wound up with cheap global air travel.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by csb6 on Thursday April 07, 2022 @03:02AM (#30941504)
That is misleading and misses most of the story. A large reason we have cheap global air travel is due to government intervention, research, and military development since the first World War. The U.S. (and other) governments have massively subsidized the development of the aerospace industry for decades and built/funded key infrastructure such as airports. "Rich guys playing with airplanes" is not how the complex system of air travel was created. Hell, the guys who invented airplanes weren't even rich.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by WalterBright on Thursday April 07, 2022 @02:20PM (#30948381)
> Hell, the guys who invented airplanes weren't even rich.

Sure, the Wrights were not rich. But Bill Boeing was. And Howard Hughes. Donald Douglas got financing to start Douglas. Allan Lockheed pretty much started from scratch. McDonnell developed its passenger jets from scratch.

Airliner travel was a paying concerned because of rich passengers. Flying for ordinary people did not come about until the 1960s.

BTW, jet engines were conceived and developed by private industry, because the government saw no value in them. Until the government saw flying jet aircraft.

P.S. The government airplane project, the Langley Aerodrome, cost something like twenty times what the Wright Flyer did, and simply fell into the Potomac like a sack of wet cement.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by glerk on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:57PM (#30937955)
If we can dream of reforming the whole system, how about a voluntary tax in exchange for a governance stake? Like, the more tax I pay, the more say I have in the decisions my government makes?
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by Johnny555 on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:19PM (#30938185)
Isn't that kind of where we are now? Wealthy people and large corporations have an outsized say in decisions by elected officials?
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by gleenn on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:18PM (#30938170)
Sure if you want an even more contorted version of corporate America and to disenfranchise even more poor voters. I'm all for changing up the rules because there are plenty of problems but handing the government to the highest bidder sounds like a big step in the wrong direction
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by night862 on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:11PM (#30938105)
What about instead, make voting rights a promisory note which can be traded and sold?

Eg, "My share of the House Rep vote from this Friday until next Tuesday" can be traded until "This Friday" for a "Burger" at Double Burger, or maybe some cash.

Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by meetups323 on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:01PM (#30938001)
We already do, those taxes just go directly to the salaries of elected officials.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by exabrial on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:04PM (#30938031)
In my opinion, I think a completely voluntary tax system is what we have to achieve as a race to get to the next level as a civilization. I think a flat tax is a step in the right direction because it eliminates an entire swath of corruption.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by colejohnson66 on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:07PM (#30938063)
The US tried a voluntary tax system with the Articles of Confederation. It didn’t work.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by jlawson on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:59PM (#30937976)
Plutocracy.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by glerk on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:03PM (#30938018)
Yep, plutocracy in the open without loopholes, lobbying and corruption. Just directly weigh the votes by the amount of participation to the common pot.
Re:IRS details strategy for replacing its most ancient compu... by czbond on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @06:21PM (#30938197)
"I will replace you with a small shell script". We only need taxes because of government. How about a law that shrinks the size of all governmental budgets and personnel by 3% every year until we decide to stop? We'll make do, I promise. Then our taxes naturally go down.