News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by alokedesai on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @01:25PM (#30921946)
I definitely understand the concerns. For our public beta, we do send telemetry and associate it with the logged in user because it makes it much easier to reach out and get feedback when something goes wrong. But we only track metadata, never console output. For an exhaustive list of events that we track, see here: https://docs.warp.dev/getting-started/privacy#exhaustive-tel.... Once we hit general availability, our plan is to make telemetry completely opt-in and anonymous.
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by tedivm on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @04:02PM (#30924230)
Wow, this is just unbelievable. You don't say anywhere on your privacy page that you are associating this data with specific users.

Everything your company says regarding privacy seems to be a complete lie. You contradict yourselves everywhere. As a security officer I would never allow any company whose security I run to use your product- even if you fix this issues now who knows if you're going to lie again in the future.

Trust is hard to regain once lost, and your company definitely blew it here.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by progbits on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @01:38PM (#30922189)
Maybe don't put this lie in the middle of the homepage?

> Private & Secure

> All cloud features are opt-in. Data is encrypted at rest.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by jbverschoor on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @02:51PM (#30923256)
Encryption at rest is fun until the keys are leaked.
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by ASalazarMX on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @02:04PM (#30922599)
Or prefix it with a "Final product will be ..."
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by cameldrv on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @01:59PM (#30922526)
This looks very interesting to me, but some of this telemetry is a deal breaker. On your privacy page, it says "Our general philosophy is complete transparency and control of any data leaving your machine." If I have complete control of any data leaving my machine, can I opt to turn off the telemetry entirely?
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by broknbottle on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @02:13PM (#30922724)
of course not. how else will they be able to make you the product without their trojan rabbit sending back all kinds of telemetry goodness.
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by runako on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @01:38PM (#30922200)
> we only track metadata, never console output

It would be meaningful to indicate whether you track console input as well.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by alokedesai on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @02:06PM (#30922619)
That's an important callout! By console output, we really mean output from the pseudoterminal, which includes command input and output printed to the terminal.

We don't store any content of _any_ part of a command that's executed in Warp.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by sorokod on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @02:15PM (#30922747)
... and never will?
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by NateEag on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @11:18PM (#30928110)
Why even ask?

Founders don't really have much control over what the tools they create wind up being used for.

Assume that some people will use any tool you encounter for the worst thing it can possibly do.

If the tool has significant potential to do things that bother you, don't use it.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by sorokod on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @12:55AM (#30928635)
Why do you say "wind up being used for" as if it is act of god rather than a business decision?
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by NateEag on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @08:11AM (#30931146)
Because I'm talking about founders and how much control they have over the tools they bring into being.

Acts of God are a better model for that than business decisions.

Some users will abuse the snot out of it, and a small start up may not even realize that's happening for months.

The founder may not retain the authority to control decisions about what changes to make to the tools or how to monetize them.

Hackers may break into the servers and use the tool for their own ends.

And, yes, often enough the founder themselves will throw the users under the bus when push comes to shove.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by JoBrad on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @01:58PM (#30922518)
From their link, it seems they don’t. Agree that positive confirmation would be good, for beta.

> We do not store any data from the command input or output itself as part of our telemetry.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by zachlloyd on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @04:11PM (#30924337)
This is correct. We do not send or store any terminal contents (input or outputs) to our server.

The only case in which that is not true is if a user elects to use Warp to share the output of a command using our Block Sharing feature.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by RL_Quine on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @05:15PM (#30925135)
With the rest of your responses I'm left looking for weasel words in here.
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by aaomidi on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @01:26PM (#30921966)
You should do that now and just ask on startup.

Honestly opting in by default is, at least in my opinion, not acceptable.

People who would say no to that popup would not appreciate you randomly reaching out to them anyway.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by OutsmartDan on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @01:40PM (#30922220)
That's a ton of data being collected. I would rather much have this submitted during a crash, rather than opt-in/opt-out. I'd not want to use a terminal that has data collection that crosses the internet every time I use it.
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by zhengt on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @04:31PM (#30924606)
Totally understand if you don't feel comfortable using it!

The reason we don't submit this only during a crash, is because there are a lot of other things we want to know about users like: Which features are they using? Are they sticking to warp as their daily driver? How much time do they spend in the app?

We do want to make the telemetry opt-in after Warp is out of beta.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by OutsmartDan on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @09:26PM (#30927351)
There are better ways to gather feedback, even if your application is in beta. Most loyal customers will let you know what’s wrong and what features they’re most excited about- that honest feedback is far superior than telemetry data. You can even add a survey form after the application exits to try and maximize the feedback loop.

Totally understand you’re a new venture backed business, however, you most likely are targeting the wrong group of users by automatically sending data over the internet for “no reason”.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by sofixa on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @05:17AM (#30930071)
> Most loyal customers will let you know what’s wrong and what features they’re most excited about- that honest feedback is far superior than telemetry data

That's just wrong. Very few users, regardless of loyalty, would bother sending feedback. That's why many companies have drives with gift cards or whatever as reward for participating in giving feedback. And even then, you'd get a limited subset of users ( loyal, loud, with time available to waste) instead of everyone like with telemetry.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by kmonsen on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @09:00PM (#30927141)
How are you checking if they stick to warp as daily driver? Are you checking for other shells open?
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by zhengt on Wednesday April 06, 2022 @11:37AM (#30933348)
We are seeing if people are using Warp regularly.

We don’t know about any shells outside of Warp so technically, they could also using other terminals - but that’s enough info for our product development.

We never track the contents of commands. A full telemetry table is included in our user docs.

Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by blktiger on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @01:33PM (#30922104)
I definitely will not try it if the analytics part are not optional, though I am glad to see you're documenting exactly what gets sent. I might consider trying it and even opt-in to the analytics once you make it optional.
Re:Show HN: Warp, a Rust-based terminal by GordonS on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @05:16PM (#30925153)
At least for EU users, you cannot collect information like this without the explicit consent of those users.

It's 2022 FFS, and still companies are over-stepping the mark - companies behaving like yours are exactly the reason GDPR and ePrivacy etc exist in the first place :/