News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Puppet vs Chef, Fight by pwelch on Sunday October 09, 2011 @04:07PM (#3091193)
I'm curious about this as well. Does anyone have any experience with this? It would be interesting to hear someone's opinion since CFEngine seems to have been around for awhile.
Re:Puppet vs Chef, Fight by Goladus on Sunday October 09, 2011 @06:30PM (#3091506)
I have used cfengine2 extensively, but not cfengine3. I've only read about cfengine3.

cfengine2 is a simple and effective mechanism for managing systems. However, cfengine2 has some issues. It has limited facilities for abstraction, resulting in a lot of code duplication. It has no built-in template engine, meaning that if you need to assemble a file based on various conditions you have to cobble it together with pattern matching and line-insertion. It's pretty easy to screw this up and lose idempotency. There's a 30-package-install limit per cfagent run, which fails silently. This is very annoying and requires some hacks to circumvent.

Also, in cfengine2 you have a configuration file that's basically <classname> : <list of hosts...>. If you approach more in terms of <hostname>: <list of classes>, it's a minor inconvenience.

Cfengine3 addresses some of these issues, but I haven't used it much so can't really give it a fair review.

Re:Puppet vs Chef, Fight by lusis on Sunday October 09, 2011 @04:35PM (#3091255)
CFEngine is the "granddaddy" of configuration management. It's been around something like 17 years at this point.

CFEngine spawned Puppet spawned Chef (rougly speaking)

I never got involved with BCfg2 or lcfg so I don't remember the history behind.