News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by ganzuul on Monday April 04, 2022 @01:29PM (#30909449)
The unfortunate truth is that humans derive status from belittling others. Being highly educated is apparently no defense against this common weakness.
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by Delk on Monday April 04, 2022 @02:22PM (#30910187)
To be fair, it might not be about the desire to belittle or to derive status. I can understand the frustration of those who are educated in a demanding field that also happens to attract people proposing uneducated and usually unsound theories. The wildest of theories -- especially the wildest of them -- would often take a lot of work to untangle and make sense of to the point where it's even possible to discuss and think about them critically. The vast, vast majority of those kinds of theories are wrong yet they take a lot of work to disprove. That probably has little to offer to the expert other than perhaps exercise in the Socratic method with an uncooperative partner.

I'm not in the academia myself but I can totally see how the nth time someone offers their "insights" into something they almost certainly don't understand could make you think of them as crackpots.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by robocat on Monday April 04, 2022 @02:34PM (#30910395)
I mean, one has to wonder how many real physicists are chasing crackpot theories in exactly the same sense. The drive that results in self-delusion is probably the same mentally/emotionally.

Also it isn’t just physicists on the receiving end. As a software engineer I get people wanting me to help them with their “crackpot” business ideas (although they sometimes don’t want to tell me their secret, and I heartily encourage them not to!). I have seen an acquaintance explore a crackpot electrical mechanism for perpetual energy. Mathematicians surely get their fair share of crackpots too!

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by Fomite on Monday April 04, 2022 @03:32PM (#30911020)
I mean, physicists are notorious for chasing crackpot theories in other fields for the exact same reason - they assume their background is sufficient to understand the current progress of a field, when it's not.
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by pfdietz on Monday April 04, 2022 @04:00PM (#30911332)
Yeah, like that crackpot Alvarez and his nutty "an asteroid killed the dinosaurs" theory!

It turned out to be right, of course.

Sometimes entire fields get stuck in bad equilibria and need to be disrupted.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by robocat on Monday April 04, 2022 @03:47PM (#30911180)
Yet Physicists sometimes hit the jackpot too: “Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity” - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by _3u10 on Monday April 04, 2022 @04:37PM (#30911664)
Classic.
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by Delk on Monday April 04, 2022 @07:55PM (#30913526)
A theoretical computer science analog to the physics crackpots might be semi-knowledgeable people who purport to prove P vs. NP one way or the other or solve some other open mathematical question or disprove a known existing result. Quantum computing probably attracts some as well but that's a bit of an overlap with physics.

Theoretical CS is of course niche enough that it probably doesn't attract mainstream people from outside of the field, so I suppose the field has its own crackpots. I suspect mathematics would be similar except somewhat more mainstream.

Of course some day someone will probably come along and actually prove something about those open questions but claims of proofs are much more common than actual proofs.

As for crackpot things within the academia itself, computer science also has areas such as AGI that are so hard to get actual scientific results from that it might be easy to deem it as just handwaving rather than actual research. Trying to build general AI with automated reasoning and knowledge bases back in the early days may not have been exactly a crackpot idea -- if anything, it was overly optimistic about hard logic -- but it certainly wasn't realistically going to succeed either, at least in hindsight.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by ganzuul on Monday April 04, 2022 @02:53PM (#30910605)
Personally I think most of these problems could be easily resolved if we were taught the basics of how to manage emotions and ego in school. Unfortunately, that essential need is still controlled by certain institutional wills that I in turn label crackpot. - Not that I should be throwing stones, living in a house of glass...
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by fourthark on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @09:06AM (#30918450)
Still haunted by interactions ten years ago with someone who claimed to have invented an impossibly efficient garbage collector supported by revolutionary data structures.

You would think this would be empirically verifiable but I nor others could make heads or tails of his argument.

When I saw the guy also had a theory of unified physics, I gave up.

Still don't know, he might have been onto something.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by CuriouslyC on Monday April 04, 2022 @05:07PM (#30911930)
String theory is crackpot AF. It's not based on Occam's razor or empirical observation, just on the fact that if you accept a few really giant unfounded assumptions, then you end up with some neat math.

We'd be better off with a theory of everything designed by a neural network, at least people wouldn't belabor under the mistaken assumption that "theory of everything" actually corresponds to anything real.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by doetoe on Monday April 04, 2022 @07:07PM (#30913155)
Occam's razor is a very useful guiding principle, but it still is a philosophical principle, not a requirement for a theory to be scientific. Observation of course is, and in fact string theory (potentially) is consistent with observed phenomena. Its main problem is that it is too difficult, if possible at all, to determine if it actually is, and in which form. Actually the same Sabine Hossenfelder wrote a book about that as you probably know
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by ncmncm on Monday April 04, 2022 @08:47PM (#30913920)
There isn't anything for it to compete with.

Anyway, a string theorist on the faculty doesn't cost any more than a mathematician. For the others you are continually having to pay for LHCs, nanokelvin freezers, and optical tables.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by tsimionescu on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @03:41AM (#30916307)
> There isn't anything for it to compete with.

That's exactly the problem - instead of trying to produce new theories, people keep researching string theory, in massive numbers (relatively to the size of the field of theoretical foundations of physics, of course).

Also, there are a few other interesting avenues to explore - coming up with a relativistic version of de Broglie-Bohm pilot wave mechanics (or as close as possible to get, given Bell's inequalities), for example.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by ncmncm on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @01:11PM (#30921746)
It's hard to imagine how you could test any alternative, either.

If the string people were putting all their effort into coming up with a testable prediction, we might be better off. But they are mostly trying to show their untestable thing is better than the next one over, instead.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by mcguire on Monday April 04, 2022 @02:40PM (#30910467)
Further, there's the other half of the psychological stew: them as regard education in general and the attempt to untangle and think critically about wild theories as at best a waste of time and at worst a personal attack. I personally don't think of anyone as a "crackpot" unless they've demonstrated that they are impervious to the basic knowledge they need: "One or two seemed miffed that I didn’t immediately exclaim: ‘Genius!’,..."
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by ganzuul on Monday April 04, 2022 @03:05PM (#30910729)
I would like to avoid to paint in detail the ugly picture behind the issue I'm talking about, since that feels like a self-fulfilling prophecy. - You are obviously right to assume the best about people but it is also prudent to remain vigilant whenever there is hierarchy and competition for resources.

I don't have a solution... I do have a problem in that this drive-by dismissal of mine is getting attention when what I was excited about in another comment goes ignored. =\

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by kbenson on Monday April 04, 2022 @03:19PM (#30910875)
> I do have a problem in that this drive-by dismissal of mine is getting attention when what I was excited about in another comment goes ignored. =\

Isn't that explained by the GP's point? Some things are much easier to engage with than others, regardless of whether it's for or against. Your statement above is two sentences, and while it undoubtedly accurately describes some occurrences, it also likely doesn't describe others. Without statements to clarify how absolutely you intend it to apply, people are free to make their own assumptions and if that assumption casts your statement as absolutist, it's easy to refute.

Communication can be hard, asynchronous communication even more so.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by ganzuul on Monday April 04, 2022 @03:34PM (#30911033)
Sometimes I wonder if our school teachers' demand to read their minds was justified, and how we can sometimes immediately be aware of context in a way that machine learning consistently fails at.

The article touches on this in how the author quickly deduces who is one of them and who is not. Perhaps therein lies the entire issue at hand.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by wolverine876 on Monday April 04, 2022 @06:36PM (#30912877)
> The unfortunate truth is that humans derive status from belittling others.

It's not a truth any more than 'humans murder others when they're angry'. Sometimes humans belittle others and sometimes they gain status from it. Sometimes they lose status, and I suspect they almost always lose a little self-respect and feel more intensely the shame that was so strong, they just tried to project it onto someone else.

> Being highly educated is apparently no defense against this common weakness.

I think it depends on the fields of study. If you study humanity, you may understand this behavior. If you study quarks, I agree it is little defense.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by jjoonathan on Monday April 04, 2022 @02:08PM (#30909997)
I don't get a status boost from letting google label 80% of my incoming email as spam, but I am quite glad that it does.
Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by bee_rider on Monday April 04, 2022 @02:33PM (#30910384)
That's true, but also there exists a population that's unfortunately been misinformed by Quantum Pseudoscience Grifters. Physics (and medicine) seem to suffer particularly from this sort of thing. Enough misinformed people asking for real engagement will eventually wear even a patient person down (of course the ire should be more accurately targeted toward the grifters, not their victims).

I mean -- as a programmer, my significant other thinks that my presence soothes the Machine Spirits and makes the computer magically cooperate. Imagine if this was a superstition! The random requests for IT support would be really annoying.

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by cogman10 on Monday April 04, 2022 @04:12PM (#30911438)
> ...misinformed by Quantum Pseudoscience Grifters. Physics (and medicine) seem to suffer particularly from this sort of thing.

Quiet a few of the misinformed are HN commenters.

Generally, the pattern appears to be "Foo is complex. Conspiracy theorist asserts there is a conspiracy making Foo complex. We cannot trust the mainstream experts because they are lying. Gishgallop with endless bad faith questions which take an enormous amount of time to answer properly but ultimately do not convince the question asker".

The general takeaway, for me at least, is that even the most intelligent person can be sucked into crackpot conspiracy. The problem is "I'm an expert in this field, this means I'm smarter than most" and then thinking that intelligence in one area grants you insights into others.

The worst part is conspiracies like to hide under the motto of "I'm just being a good skeptic". However, a good skeptic needs to actually dig deeper than just surface level assertions. A good skeptic needs to look into the counter claims to their conspiracy. What are the sources? Do the actually point to data or are they just naked assertions? Do the sources reference only other conspiracy websites? Do they have references? If this claim is actually true, why is it rejected by the mainstream? Who is actually benefiting from hiding the truth?

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by fn-mote on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @11:29AM (#30920274)
> my significant other thinks that my presence soothes the Machine Spirits and makes the computer magically cooperate

I love this. Also hilarious.

In my experience, also true in certain cases.

You observe something that is being done a way you would not do it. There is no reason to suspect this is the source of the problem, but you do it the way you think it should be done. Lo and behold, the process works and the problem is gone. In retrospect you can see why, maybe the filename ':/%20' was bad luck, or whatever. Looking at the process, though, it's hard to claim success was achieved by a rational scientific process...

Re:What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physic... by circlefavshape on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @06:33AM (#30917306)
It's hard to understand what this is aimed at. The original article is rather sweet, and you're replying to a comment that's saying that "crackpots" are mostly just normal people who've misunderstood something. I don't see any belittling going on here