Re:“Can it run Doom” will never be the same, thanks to new r...
by pcwalton on Monday April 04, 2022 @01:20AM
(#30903531)
I prefer not to tell people what they can and can't do with their spare time. This hack was probably a blast to write. Let people make fun things.
Ironically, your advice is essentially "make an indie game", but it's way easier to get noticed by writing impressive hacks that excite people than by developing yet another indie title that's overwhelmingly likely to just get buried on Steam. The vast majority of indie titles will never attract articles on Ars Technica. So this is poor advice even if your goal is to optimize for maximum audience.
Re:“Can it run Doom” will never be the same, thanks to new r...
by danielheath on Monday April 04, 2022 @02:16AM
(#30903761)
You are replying to an satirical comment (obvious to those familiar with the kind of car show it is referencing but perhaps not to anyone else)
Re:“Can it run Doom” will never be the same, thanks to new r...
by hoseja on Monday April 04, 2022 @07:44AM
(#30905507)
The original copypasta is about doing 100 pushups.
Re:“Can it run Doom” will never be the same, thanks to new r...
by zamadatix on Monday April 04, 2022 @02:55PM
(#30910637)
This is a very off take and not what I was talking about at all. It can be _fun_ to do ridiculous things without purpose (and a great stress reliever) which is reason enough for a project to exist but the article paints it as being a _visual upgrade_ and an improvement to the game. It's not, for the reasons stated, but that has absolutely nothing to do with the project or development needing to be done in a way that it would be.
Separate the purpose of the project from its presentation in the article to reapply these thoughts towards the presentation in the article and I think we'd be on the same page though.
If you only develop one part of your renderer (and that's all a single exercise like raytracing is going to do for you), you're setting yourself up for artefacts down the road. I've seen it a hundred times.
It's like putting a powerful engine in a stock Toyota Tercel. What will you accomplish? You'll blow out the drive train, the clutch, the transmission, etc., because those factory parts aren't designed to handle the power of an engine much more powerful than the factory installed engine.
Raytracing basically only renders the shadows and to some extent, transparency. What you really want to do is redevelop your entire graphical pipeline, all the major visual assets (models, textures, uv maps, particles, rigging and animation) at the same time, over the course of a release. And don't forget your level design!
I'm proud of you guys wanting to do this. Three cheers! Falling in love with raytracing, rendering, etc., is one of the greatest things you can do for yourself. And you WILL fall in love with it if you can just force yourself to stick with it a year or two and experience the amazing progress you'll make.
But do it right, okay?
My advice, find a good project, with qualified developers who will assign issues to you (especially in the beginning, until you get the hang of it yourself) and guide you in your quest for sick graphics. Thirty to 45 hours a week, eleven months a year, is all you'll ever need to do (I refuse to believe anyone is so busy that he or she cannot make time for that, especially considering how important it is).
And don't worry about being embarrassed or not having dependencies installed the first time you clone the repo. You have to start somewhere and almost every one of us were there ourselves at one time. So no one will say anything to you and very, very slowly after lots of trial and error you will finally just look it up on youtube.
Now get out there and do it!