News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by scarmig on Sunday April 03, 2022 @01:55PM (#30898958)
Another option would be to respect and valorize men who want to focus on things like home life over career success.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by nopenopenopeno on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:21PM (#30899307)
Maybe that would make sense if that was the trend, but it isn’t.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by scarmig on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:09PM (#30899701)
Trends have to start somewhere. But I'm convinced that as long as a male teacher's aide is considered a less desirable prospect than a male CEO, we're going to see shitty gender roles that limit and oppress us.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by s1artibartfast on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:41PM (#30899920)
One question is why try to start a trend if that isn't what men want? It seems like trying to manipulate desires to meet some other goal. If men want to care for children, then good! We should respect their wishes, but why try to change desires?
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by scarmig on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:52PM (#30900014)
Men do not collectively want things, as collective entities don't have psychological experiences like desire.

Individuals of whatever gender exist within incentive landscapes, and they act within those landscapes to result in the best life for them. Many men and women wish they had different incentive landscapes to navigate through. My argument would be that creating a world where men and women can choose their paths according to their individual dispositions without penalty would result in one where more men and women are happy, which is why I'd like to nudge our existing world in that direction.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by JamesBarney on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:28PM (#30900340)
Almost all women I know who have kids prefer being the primary care taker to the primary bread winner.

About half the men I know with kids would prefer to be primary care taker.

If we somehow convince more men to want to be the primary caretaker, and feel more strongly about does that necessarily make the world a better place? It means both more men and more women don't get what they want.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by scarmig on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:47PM (#30900489)
I'm not proposing engineering people's desires. I'm proposing eliminating the social structures that penalize men who want to be the primary caregiver (and penalize women who want to be the primary bread winner).

Couples with compatible desires in line with the status quo would be unaffected. Couples with compatible desires opposite the status quo would purely benefit. Couples with discordant desires would negotiate the allocation of responsibilities more freely without social expectations biasing the outcome, which would lead to one partner benefiting and the other losing, but in a way that's either neutral or leads to a net benefit across the two individuals.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by nopenopenopeno on Sunday April 03, 2022 @05:31PM (#30900884)
What social structures penalize men who want to be the primary care giver?
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by fennecfoxy on Monday April 04, 2022 @05:02AM (#30904588)
Lol, stay at home Dads get told they're "baby-sitting". They aren't as "manly" in the eyes of their male peers (though this is changing a little).

Hell, until recently it was only women who had access to maternity leave, paternity leave in most countries seems to be quite a new concept.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by s1artibartfast on Sunday April 03, 2022 @06:48PM (#30901531)
Companies with different different policies for non medical birth leave would be one example of a social expectation codified as corporate policy. It is a pretty fringe issue in the United States because many companies that do give non-medical bonding time, give the same to both genders.

There is also the hypothetical idea that stay at home dads get a called pussies, but I've never seen it come up.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by s1artibartfast on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:04PM (#30900117)
If you want freedom and equality of choice, we should focus on breaking down barriers that stop people from doing what they want, not pushing them to do something different.

Adding incentives, nudging, and valorizing specific actions puts equality of outcome over equality of choice.

We shouldn't push a trend to respect and valorize men who stay home more than those who work. We should push a trend to respect them equally

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by scarmig on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:20PM (#30900264)
> We shouldn't push a trend to respect and valorize men who stay home more than those who work. We should push a trend to respect them equally.

We are in violent agreement.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by s1artibartfast on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:34PM (#30900380)
I think we are in violent agreement this point.

Where I thought we differed is providing preferential incentives to men who stay home over those who work.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by bavell on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:31PM (#30900355)
You don't think they should be respected equally?
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by scarmig on Sunday April 03, 2022 @05:03PM (#30900622)
"Violent agreement" is a phrasing often used to indicate two people were discussing something and appeared to be on opposite sides but eventually realized they want the same thing =)
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by notriddle on Sunday April 03, 2022 @07:37PM (#30901874)
> Adding incentives, nudging, and valorizing specific actions puts equality of outcome over equality of choice.

I'll buy the part about adding incentives.

Nudging and valorizing, however, are inevitable aspects of human life. Abolishing heroism is not realistic (and, honestly, it's a pretty mild incentive anyway).

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by trees101 on Sunday April 03, 2022 @05:06PM (#30900657)
segue from the topic at hand, but perhaps collective entities do have desires. There are many different people converging on this idea. This link has a concise analogy for how it works: https://youtu.be/4IjW16FCpkA?t=766
[dead]
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by scarmig on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:48PM (#30899530)
Men and women both make sacrifices when it comes to building a household: working more isn't a privilege. If we're interested in liberating people from gender roles, we have to look at both sides of the equation.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by misslibby on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:36PM (#30900393)
Feminists claim going to work is the privilege, and staying home with children is the chore. The opposite is true.

People are being "liberated from gender roles" merely by technological progress: washing machines and the likes making household chores not a fulltime job, office jobs being doable even while pregnant, that sort of thing. The claim that people choose jobs just because of societal expectations is unproven.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by bobthechef on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:40PM (#30899915)
The presumption here is that there is something to be liberated from. That men and women are generally better suited toward different aspects of parenting is not an artificial construction. Ideological commitments have taken the place of reason.

The result will be that those who do live in a way more aligned with human nature and the specializations each sex entails will out breed those who don't.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by scarmig on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:59PM (#30900064)
The existence of gendered statistical tendencies (some of which, I agree, are rooted in biological realities) doesn't mean that there aren't social structures that penalize people for deviating from those tendencies.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by misslibby on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:38PM (#30900409)
How is anybody penalized for "deviating from those tendencies" these days?
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by scarmig on Sunday April 03, 2022 @05:08PM (#30900679)
E.g. on the woman's side of things, a woman who is messy is judged worse than a man who's equivalently messy would be, which is society actively pushing women toward taking up more household responsibilities.

On the man's side of things, a man who is a part time teacher's aid for the sake of work-life flexibility is judged as lazier than a woman doing the same thing would be, which is society actively pushing men toward taking up more work responsibilities.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by misslibby on Sunday April 03, 2022 @07:30PM (#30901833)
Really doubtful about these claims. I know gender studies has generated tons of studies like that, but the quality is low.

And in these examples, what would be the repercussions for being perceived as lazy? If he wants a family, the problem for the part time working man would presumably still to be able to provide for a family, which would not be an issue of perception, but of actual shortage of money. If he doesn't want a family, it doesn't matter. The difference is that a woman would never need to earn enough to provide for a family, so the judgement "too lazy to provide for a family" would not apply.

And a messy woman's household will be seen and judged by whom, exactly?

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by simulate-me on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:54PM (#30899586)
I'm not even sure many women want someone else to take care of their kids after giving birth. I'm a man. I took many months of paternity leave after our child was born so my wife could return to work. My wife enjoys her work, but definitely less so after giving birth. She was totally fine to work until midnight before giving birth. Now, she wants to clock out as early as possible to maximize the amount of time she has to spend with our daughter. I've since returned to work and feel the same way. Hanging out with your child is fun and special, and it's not something you can buy with more money or status. The bond between a mother and child is also very powerful on a hormonal level. One thing I found surprising was how direct and physical the hormonal bond is shortly after birth. For instance, the uterus enlarges to hold the baby, and is still large right after birth. When a mother breast feeds, her body releases oxytocin (aka the love hormone). Oxytocin causes the uterus to contract. Literally within seconds of breastfeeding, a mother can feel physical changes occurring in her body. Pretty wild.

Of course, the above is just my anecdotal experience and doesn't apply to everyone.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by chillwaves on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:56PM (#30899602)
The tone of this comment is disturbing. Can you keep that kind of FDS/incel ideology off this forum, please?
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by misslibby on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:35PM (#30900391)
What about it is disturbing? And it is not ideology, but biology.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by s1artibartfast on Sunday April 03, 2022 @07:44PM (#30901909)
It is disturbing because it makes a number of assumptions, which seem skewed from reality.

I don't think the transactional and combative assumption of gender relations is really applicable, or a constructive framework for this kind of analysis.

Specifically, I dont agree with the premise that the man is "convincing" the woman to have "their" child, and shouldn't "get it for free" . It also seems to imply the father is freeloading if they are the primary caretaker and the mother works.

In my reality, women usually want to have children, even more so than men. In a healthy relationship, it is a jointly owned undertaking, not coercion by one partner. Additionally, the role of childrearing is not seen as a cushy reward and payback for going through the hard work of pregnancy.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by misslibby on Monday April 04, 2022 @04:07PM (#30911394)
"It is disturbing because it makes a number of assumptions, which seem skewed from reality."

The underlying biological reality is that making children is more costly for women than for men. The rest follows from that.

I think therefore that you have the skewed view.

"I don't think the transactional and combative assumption of gender relations is really applicable"

It is the low level consideration of evolution - other things are layered on top, like the construct of "love" enabling people to stick together.

"the man is "convincing" the woman to have "their" child, and shouldn't "get it for free""

So you don't think a man fathering a child should take care of the mother and child? You wouldn't think it bad style to father a child and then leave mother and child to their own devices?

In any case, as I explained, the mother invests more into bringing the child to life than the father, so doesn't it seem fair if the father tries to even the scales by providing other things?

"In my reality, women usually want to have children, even more so than men."

Sure, but they need food and shelter to succeed in raising those children.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by s1artibartfast on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @02:54AM (#30916052)
>In any case, as I explained, the mother invests more into bringing the child to life than the father, so doesn't it seem fair if the father tries to even the scales by providing other things?

>Sure, but they need food and shelter to succeed in raising those children.

So it is work when a woman raises the children, but when the man raises the children, they are providing nothing? This premise seems to be the cornerstone of your argument that men who take care of children are freeloaders. You think that women deserve payback, and these men are not providing it.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by misslibby on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @05:47PM (#30925460)
Pregnancy and birth are work, and most importantly, only women can do it, and they can only do it once every 9 months. It is a skill that is highly in demand (male sperm not so much), so a woman could potentially get a lot more in exchange for it than "nothing".

One thing women usually get in exchange is the privilege to choose to stay home with their children.

Now how hard it is to stay home and provide for the children every couple has to decide for themselves. But yeah, I personally will claim that it is not as hard as most jobs, putting a roof above the families head and so on.

You can also check the cost of household services (cleaning, cooking, washing) to estimate the value a male housekeeper brings to the table. I think a husband as housekeeper is usually more expensive.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by s1artibartfast on Tuesday April 05, 2022 @08:25PM (#30926898)
Not everything is about financial value. What happens to this calculus when the man enjoys staying home, and the woman values that the man enjoys it?

If it were, you can also check the cost of hiring a surrogate. It looks like pregnancy and birth are worth $20-45k, at least in Canada, and far cheaper if you are willing to travel.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/health/surrogacy-agencies-expenses-c...