News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by daenz on Sunday April 03, 2022 @01:26PM (#30898652)
I've seen the argument that women having and raising children should result in no interruptions of their career growth or earnings.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by jldugger on Sunday April 03, 2022 @01:34PM (#30898724)
Probably the better faith argument is that it should impact both genders equally, but it's a lot harder problem to solve, with multiple layers of interaction in a dynamic system.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by epicureanideal on Sunday April 03, 2022 @01:41PM (#30898808)
Well, if the parents are married all the earnings typically accumulate as common assets. In the event of a divorce those common assets are divided, and usually for a period of several years or more the higher earner is required to transfer further income from their paycheck to the lower earner. This doesn’t show up in the statistics I assume.

It’s possible this doesn’t create a 100% balance, but it’s also not 100% balanced that one partner was able to spend far more time with the children (and usually both parents want to despite what some debate participants will say), and other non financial costs and benefits.

One way to solve this would be to require all marriages to have a pre negotiated divorce agreement with experienced advisors on both sides to discuss what would be fair compensation in case of divorce.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by lotsofpulp on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:04PM (#30899166)
> but it’s also not 100% balanced that one partner was able to spend far more time with the children

That can easily be balanced via legislation. What cannot be balanced is one partner having to take on all the health risks and lifelong consequences of childbirth and breastfeeding, etc.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by scarmig on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:43PM (#30899483)
In general, men get the short end of the stick with the current setup of household gender roles. They work more hours, at jobs they like less and are more stressed at, and experience far more on the job fatalities and permanent disabilities than women do.

The net result of this is that men are more likely to die any given year during their careers and have a life span shorter by several years than women do.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by epicureanideal on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:01PM (#30900087)
> one partner having to take on all the health risks

Sure, but let’s be careful not to cherry pick the statistics. It’s still true that the average life expectancy for men is about 5 years shorter than women.

I notice that there are attempts in our society to balance some areas of risk but not others. Breast cancer funding is much greater than prostate cancer funding despite the latter killing more people, etc.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by klipt on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:38PM (#30900414)
Yeah if we really cared about equality of outcome we'd be funding men's health to the tune of trillions to reduce the life expectancy gap.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by odshoifsdhfs on Sunday April 03, 2022 @06:02PM (#30901157)
So you are ok that Ukranian women atm to also not be able to leave the country and have to fight? Because there are also a lot of consequences for being a man that just keep being ignored (famous Hillary Clinton's quote that the real victims of war are the widows of the fallen soldiers springs to mind)
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by lelanthran on Sunday April 03, 2022 @05:04PM (#30900632)
> What cannot be balanced is one partner having to take on all the health risks and lifelong consequences of childbirth and breastfeeding, etc.

Good thing it's opt-in. Why would you want to legislate opt-in behaviour?

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by s1artibartfast on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:50PM (#30900000)
Even, you would need to define a specific problem.

If you are talking about overall career impact post birth, you would only expect equal outcomes if men and women are making the same choices and have the same preferences.

If the "problem" is simply different numeric outcomes between men and women, it ignores any differences between the wants of men and women.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by godelski on Sunday April 03, 2022 @01:39PM (#30898781)
If it affects both equally that's equivalent to no effect when comparing the difference. I think if we're discussing in good faith then you and the parent agree but are using different perspectives.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by DFHippie on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:35PM (#30899882)
> women having and raising children should result in no interruptions of their career growth or earnings

is different from

> affects both equally

Perhaps the first should have been "women having and raising children should result in no interruptions of their career growth or earnings greater than those experienced by men".

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by s1artibartfast on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:52PM (#30900012)
>women having and raising children should result in no interruptions of their career growth or earnings greater than those experienced by men".

Greater than men in general, or men who make the the same choices as the impacted women?

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by JamesBarney on Sunday April 03, 2022 @01:53PM (#30898934)
How do we fix this when the underlying cause is workers who prioritize their job more and have more years of experience get paid more?
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by UncleMeat on Sunday April 03, 2022 @05:17PM (#30900751)
What does it mean to prioritize a career?

There are a lot of career obligations that aren't fundamental to productivity. For example, people are largely expected to go to an office and be physically present for eight consecutive hours. This makes certain kinds of childcare activities impossible. But if instead flexible hours or work-from-home were the norm, this choice would no longer be necessary and it no longer becomes a "one or the other" situation.

Consider something like the idea that pumping at work is unprofessional. This is a 100% cultural thing. Pumping does not make somebody less productive. But if we don't consider this cultural influence we might just say "well women just choose to stay at home when they have infants and there is nothing we can do about that."

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by daenz on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:28PM (#30899363)
This is what "equity" refers to. It means that the playing field must be deliberately tilted to "counteract" any natural tilting. If that feels unfair, that's because it is, intentionally. But the counter argument is that it was already unfair from the start.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by tomp on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:28PM (#30899838)
Paying more productive people the same as less productive people is a great way to ensure there are no productive people.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by sokoloff on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:11PM (#30899715)
Is it unfair if choosing to prioritize career, working longer/harder at it, and becoming more skilled/productive at it is rewarded in the market?
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by missedthecue on Sunday April 03, 2022 @07:48PM (#30901946)
If and individual makes the personal decision that some priority is more important to them than money, society should tell them they're wrong and give them the money anyway?
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by smugma on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:37PM (#30899439)
It shouldn’t. If you have 10 Years experience and take a year off to birth and raise a child, you should be able to come back and be paid similarly to a man or woman who has 10 years of experience and not be penalized 2-3 years of experience for it.

People may have different commitments to work after having kids, and compensation can and should be adjusted based on that.

I definitely work much less than I did pre-kids, but my compensation has gone up significantly. I think this is typical for men. My wife also works less for more money post kids (but she had kids while doing postdoctoral work, and then moved to private industry).

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by legostormtroopr on Sunday April 03, 2022 @06:01PM (#30901153)
> If you have 10 Years experience and take a year off to birth and raise a child, you should be able to come back and be paid similarly to a man or woman who has 10 years of experience and not be penalized 2-3 years of experience for it.

Except that 1 year off has put them 1 year behind their peers who now have 11 years experience. Their skills have also decayed by a year, and they missed 1 year of developments in the industry.

People shouldn’t be penalised for having kids, but likewise it should be recognised that having children does impact career trajectory in a non-discriminatory way.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by nightski on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:49PM (#30899541)
I'd take this a step further and argue that any gaps in employment history should not be looked on nearly as negatively as they are today. It really invokes a wage slave mentality.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by freedomben on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:06PM (#30899680)
At least in tech, I think we're mostly there already, particularly if the applicant has some explanation for it (and even then it's getting rarer to ask about it). With the large amount of no-child/one-child families and waiting until mid 30s to start having kids, it's very common for people to have enough income/savings that they can take a few months or even a couple years off to travel the world or try a startup, or something else.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by BlargMcLarg on Sunday April 03, 2022 @06:18PM (#30901288)
I'd be careful stating this, as the reason why this isn't happening might be as simple as "there aren't enough experienced tech workers to make such a demand". Considering tech recruitment is still willing to do many other things which aren't empirically proven or even have empirical evidence suggesting against the act, there is room for skepticism here.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by missedthecue on Sunday April 03, 2022 @07:50PM (#30901964)
Following this to its logical conclusion, would you say that devs with 10 years experience shouldn't earn any more than someone fresh from college?
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by account42 on Monday April 04, 2022 @04:48AM (#30904525)
That conclusion does not follow logically at all.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by missedthecue on Monday April 04, 2022 @10:39AM (#30907156)
if accumulated experience should not contribute to pay, it follows perfectly.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by nightski on Monday April 04, 2022 @02:33PM (#30910371)
That's not really what I said at all. How does allowing someone to have gaps in their employment history mean accumulated experience should not contribute to pay?

In my opinion general "years of experience" is not a large contributing factor in regards to pay anyways. Relevant experience on specific projects using certain technologies and expertise in specific domains matters a lot more. It's supply and demand.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by missedthecue on Monday April 04, 2022 @05:39PM (#30912294)
Someone has 10 years of continuous experience, knowledge, and work. They makes $100k.

Someone else is the same age, graduated the same year, from the same school, but took two years off of work and therefore has 8 years of experience. They make $80k, which is less than their colleague.

See the difference?

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by LorenPechtel on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:54PM (#30900544)
Yeah, I've encountered multiple feminist types who feel this way.

Sorry, the market pays based on experience, not on age! You're asking for a subsidy.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by hackerfromthefu on Monday April 04, 2022 @11:48PM (#30915109)
At what point are we as a society going to call out this self interested promotion and self entitled freeloading for what it is. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by david38 on Sunday April 03, 2022 @06:48PM (#30901528)
This is laughable. For this to be true,

* raising children would require zero time and overhead

* or people who don’t have children should be barred from working more hours than a working mother can reasonably work.

Of course this entire discussion is mostly classist to such a degree many people literally don’t see it. For a mother to work full time with young children requires a lower paid (usually a woman) person to take on the child rearing role. So it’s sexist for a woman to take a few years prioritizing her children, but it’s equality for another woman to raise those children?

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by AdrianB1 on Sunday April 03, 2022 @01:56PM (#30898965)
I have seen companies where having and raising children result in no interruptions of their career growth or earnings: I personally know 2 women in my office that were promoted while in maternity leave and one after she left the company: some companies bend backwards to promote women. I also have a colleague in the team in US that took a 15 year break to be a stay at home mom, the kids are now teenagers so she came back to work; she was automatically promoted to a position similar with having the past 15 years working. My point: it depends on the company, country, field of work etc.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by smugma on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:45PM (#30899505)
Claiming someone got promoted after they left the company doesn’t really make sense. Just thinking about HR systems, I don’t believe the claim.

I do know someone who was promoted while on maternity leave (@FANG). She absolutely deserved the promotion and has done a great job leading her (analytics, engineering adjacent) team. She subsequently went on leave for a second child (no second promotion that I’m aware of).

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by AdrianB1 on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:05PM (#30900122)
That lady (a close friend of mine at that time) resigned because she moved to another country where we did not have offices. A few days before she left, she was promoted because the management had promotion targets for women, so they scored one for the target. Everyone knew she is moving out of the country, so the promotion was just a dumb KPI hack - when the target is to have 70% women in an IT organization of thousands, people do crazy things to manipulate numbers.

In my country during maternity leave the work contract is legally frozen, no change is allowed of any kind (due to a history of frauds with salaries, the government pays a big part of it so there were cases where they increased the salary 10 times for the duration of the leave). Still, nobody said anything because that target beats the law. The only thing they did not touch was the salary because this is the only thing the government is checking.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by bertjk on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:31PM (#30899385)
> ...and one after she left the company

This honestly sounds pretty fishy-- like they wanted to goose their diversity stats for free while not actually changing any part of their org chart.

Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by AdrianB1 on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:07PM (#30900135)
Exactly. A manager reported one more female promotion for that year. Because the office in my country is relatively small, one promotion still makes a measurable impact.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by sokoloff on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:19PM (#30899288)
What does someone getting promoted after they left the company mean, in practice?
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by AdrianB1 on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:11PM (#30900173)
An announcement was posted the person is leaving the company (she gave notice). 2 weeks later, another announcement was posted that the person was promoted. The person did leave the company as planned.
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by rdtwo on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:15PM (#30899261)
Do your male coworker get promoted while on bonding leave? Is that typical?
Re:Young women earn more than young men in several U.S. cities by AdrianB1 on Sunday April 03, 2022 @04:12PM (#30900186)
Males are rarely, if ever promoted, in the past 10 years the ratio was 10 to 1 female to male.