News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by Gnarl on Friday April 01, 2022 @12:36PM (#30880124)
Study highlights: device usage 1 - 20 minutes per WEEK. Study population born 1935-1950, less likely as users of tech. No actual exposure data. Can't take this seriously.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by nuvious on Friday April 01, 2022 @04:02PM (#30882683)
The population born in 1935-1950 is walking around the population of the people that did grow up with tech though. Their exposure is almost a certainty because cell towers didn't exist before 1979 in Japan. Now they're basically ubiquitous and unlike cell phones of the 80s which only transmitted when you were making a call, modern cell phones are constantly transmitting to maintain internet connection.

Rates of brain cancer before and after the 80s and 90s should've shown some sort of statistically significant spike in brain tumors if cell phones were an issue but it didn't because they're not. 800-2000MHz seems like a lot but radiation doesn't cause ionization until you get to the 2400 terahertz range. There's literally no mechanism known to PHYSICS that would result in cell phone radiation causing brain tumors.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by Gnarl on Saturday April 02, 2022 @08:03AM (#30887584)
@nuvious Apparently, it ain't that simple. If you lump together all brain tumour types, you won't see much happening, but once you split the stats into tumour types an interesting picture emerges. The incidence of glioblastoma's increases at pretty much the same rate as more benign types decrease in incidence. What to make of that? Well, something ubiquitous in the environment seems to be "upgrading" benign tumours into aggressive malign tumours. UK scientists did some work on this, here: https://www.hindawi.com/journals/jeph/2018/7910754/
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by nuvious on Saturday April 02, 2022 @02:23PM (#30890429)
I don't have an argument against that observation, but it's agnostic to my concern in people discussing RF as a risk to brain cancer. The rise in rates is an observation and probably a good one but they intentionally do not try to ascribe a cause in that study.

The potential causal mechanisms have been studied for a long time to contrast:

"Overall, the epidemiological studies on RF EMF exposure do not show an increased risk of brain tumours. Furthermore, they do not indicate an increased risk for other cancers of the head and neck region." - European Commission Scientific Committee on Emerging and Newly Identified Health Risks, 2015

http://ec.europa.eu/health/scientific_committees/emerging/do...

What I care about is people ascribing a casual effect by conjecture alone, especially when the research has actually been done to assess the probability/impact of a proposed mechanism. In all flavors and frequencies in the RF spectrum, this has turned up basically zero probability, uncertain impact (because how do you measure rhe impact on something that never happens), yielding zero risk out the other end.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by tasubotadas on Friday April 01, 2022 @04:15PM (#30882827)
But I've read on a Facebook group that it does.

/sarcasm off

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Friday April 01, 2022 @05:40PM (#30883599)
> There's literally no mechanism known to PHYSICS that would result in cell phone radiation causing brain tumors.

False. We don't know that any form of microwave radiation can induce brain tumors, but we certainly don't now that they can't. It needs experiments, which are being performed (on the public) as I write this.

What we do know is that microwave radiation induces nanoampere currents where absorbed. The exact details of the currents, and where and how absorbed determines their effects. Insisting PHYSICS is a legitimate substitute for experimention is a failing that has become increasingly common, lately.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by nuvious on Saturday April 02, 2022 @02:27PM (#30890456)
You didn't actually propose a mechanism that describes how this proposed effect causes damage to DNA and causes cancer and I'm not your Google-scholar to search for that for you. Provide evidence, here's mine:

"Overall, the epidemiological studies on RF EMF exposure do not show an increased risk of brain tumours. Furthermore, they do not indicate an increased risk for other cancers of the head and neck region." - European Commission Scientific Committee on Emerging and Newly Identified Health Risks, 2015

http://ec.europa.eu/health/scientific_committees/emerging/do...

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Saturday April 02, 2022 @03:22PM (#30890936)
There has never before been any substantial exposure to the wavelengths used for 5G, so there is exactly zero epidemiological data to consult.

We don't know what will happen, but we will find out, in time. Previous generations seem to have turned out OK. All we can be certain of is that, if anyone is harmed, no one will go to jail for it. Like the people putting lead in gasoline and paint, no one involved will have their retirement even slightly inconvenienced. (Unless, of course, they are personally harmed by it.)

Do I think harm is likely? I have no information to form an opinion from, so I would be guessing, just like everybody who insists it is all just fine. What I do know is that everyone who insists they know is lying.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by nuvious on Sunday April 03, 2022 @02:52AM (#30895001)
We actually do in radar systems which range between 400 Mhz and 36 Ghz. We've also had 2.4 and 5 ghz wifi and other rf protocols ubiquitously deployed for years. Did you even look at my reference? It's a systematic review of 100s of studys several of which cover frequencies between 2.4gz to as high as 300 ghz. There's tons of them in there and the conclusion still came to no known mechanism for harm or observed harm. You are literally making assertions that research hasn't been done when it absolutely has and you're just being stubbornly assertive about something that's factually incorrect.

And this is the opposite of leaded gasoline because the first study that suggested a harmful mechanism was verifiable and produced reproducible results with a mechanism that was reasonable and testable.

The many hypothetical harms from RFR have been tested extensively and found no observable harm or mechanism for harm below the ionizing range of EM radiation.

You're just expressing doubt with arguments that are vague and untestable which is reasonable because all the testable hypothesis have been investigated.

Propose a mechanism for harm and provide evidence that it's actually happening. If we held off on advancing technology over fear, uncertainty, and doubt arguments like this we'd get no where.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Sunday April 03, 2022 @06:22AM (#30895856)
You assume that work on 0.9 and 2.4GHz with 3G modulation generalizes to 20GHz and 5G modulation. But there is absolutely no reason to imagine so.

Every single modulation scheme has a completely different risk profile than every other. But almost every study starts out assuming that only heating can have any effect at all, and modulation never any, pre-loading failure.

It is equivalent to saying, "We tried some plants that turned out safe to eat. Therefore, all plants are safe to eat." No. Details matter. Wishing is opposite of facts. Facts are often inconvenient.

We conducted the analog, 2G, 3G, and 4G experiments on the general public, and they appear to have turned out OK--to the extent anybody has checked. Cancer is far from the only public health problem. Is anybody even looking at others? Auto-immune illnesses are way up, and could be caused by any of thousands of untested chemicals, or non-ionizing radiation, or hygiene, or some unholy combination. Who is even checking?

We will now run the 5G experiment on the public, and see again. Or, fail to see, for not looking even after the fact.

Does anybody even have a use for 5G, besides the telecomm companies hustling equipment? 4G barely works for me, most of the time. But I will certainly end up being made to pay for 5G, useful or not, because what I need is the very last consideration.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by arcticbull on Friday April 01, 2022 @01:05PM (#30880558)
Luckily there are boatloads of other studies that show the exact same outcome.

Here's one from 2016 [1]

  Overall evaluations show that the current evidence for a causal association between cancer and exposure to mobile radiation is weak and unconvincing. Some of the studies establishing association had significant limitations and weaknesses and, therefore, remain unreliable. Studies have highlighted that using these phones for about 10 years is unlikely to cause cancer.
I agree.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4922278

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by xwdv on Friday April 01, 2022 @01:12PM (#30880633)
20 minutes per week is probably accurate for how much a person keeps a phone right next to their head these days. It’s not for device usage.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by SilasX on Friday April 01, 2022 @01:28PM (#30880824)
Plus, didn't phones in that time period have to emit much higher-power signals to work with the contemporary EM infra?
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by SigmundA on Friday April 01, 2022 @01:14PM (#30880655)
Careful you might have to explain inverse-square law.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by dragontamer on Friday April 01, 2022 @02:35PM (#30881735)
Radio is emitted in 3-dimensions, right? So its inverse-cube law?
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ajb on Friday April 01, 2022 @06:01PM (#30883779)
The dilution factor is the surface of sphere centered at the emitter, not the volume of the sphere. EM radiation is not like gas diffusion.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by dragontamer on Friday April 01, 2022 @06:27PM (#30883958)
Appreciated.

That explanation makes a lot of sense.

EDIT: I also know we aren't dealing with "spheres", but... I get the gist. Dipole antenna emits in this weird doughnut shape, but as a 3-dimensional object, we can estimate it to be kinda-sorta like a sphere :-)

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ajb on Friday April 01, 2022 @07:02PM (#30884197)
Certainly their surface areas are both O(r^2) :-)

Actually though, I think a sphere is still in a way the right object. The weird donut is a representation of the amount that is emitted in different directions - I guess it's a contour of equal intensity. But the radiation is still emitted at the speed of light in every direction. So the wavefront at any given time is a sphere (until it is defracted or reflected).

(Edited to add) unless you're thinking of a really big dipole, so you can't treat it as a point source? Or close to it.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by dragontamer on Friday April 01, 2022 @07:21PM (#30884317)
Hmmm.

> But the radiation is still emitted at the speed of light in every direction.

I think that makes sense.

> (Edited to add) unless you're thinking of a really big dipole, so you can't treat it as a point source?

Honestly, didn't think of that issue either. You're right though, some antennas (especially AM antennas) are the size of Godzilla, and its absurd to even think of them as point-sources.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by SigmundA on Friday April 01, 2022 @07:42PM (#30884462)
No antenna is a perfect point omni emitter, the weird non spherical shapes like doughnuts is the antennas gain, almost are antennas are somewhat directional, the shape is a plot of the measured radiation around the antenna. You take advantage of the fact that it radiates more to the sides than up and down and orient that so it putting more power to the horizon rather than up into space (for terrestrial transmission).

The term gain is just referring to the antennas directionality relative to a perfect spherical omni radiator that doesn't exist.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Friday April 01, 2022 @03:02PM (#30882053)
No.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Friday April 01, 2022 @02:26PM (#30881630)
How much time does your cell phone spend in your shirt pocket? Or, your relatives' shirt pockets?
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by SigmundA on Friday April 01, 2022 @02:38PM (#30881776)
Your phone isn't typically on full transmit power in your shirt, this can been by the difference between talk time and standby time on any phone.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Friday April 01, 2022 @03:02PM (#30882046)
Your phone emits full transmit power, while in your pocket, in very short bursts.

Experiments with E-M effects on biology show that changes in current matter more than steady current. So, the effect of pulses could be larger than if it actually were transmitting full-time. We just don't know.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by SigmundA on Friday April 01, 2022 @03:34PM (#30882366)
Radiowaves are AC by nature they are not "Steady current". You need to provide at least something backing up this extraordinary claim.

Are you claiming a heating effect or something else?

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Friday April 01, 2022 @04:01PM (#30882667)
If you believe AC cannot be, at the same time, steady current, you are in for many more surprises. If you think your cell phone antenna picks up signals by some sort of "heating effect", you are in for many more surprises.

In fact all varying E-M fields induce electrical currents where they are absorbed. The effects of those electrical currents vary in myriad ways, depending both on the currents and on where they are absorbed. In living matter the currents are carried by motion of ions in solution. Not coincidentally, life is conducted largely by motion of ions in solution.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by SigmundA on Friday April 01, 2022 @04:31PM (#30882992)
How is alternating current steady when varies in magnitude? There is no current flowing on a zero crossing, there is a reason AC and radio use RMS current, are you sure you know what your talking about?

Incidentally the ADC's that sample the input dissipate the electrical energy captured by the antenna as heat however little it may be as is the case with all electrical circuits that sink electrical energy. So yes your cellphone does use a "heating effect" because where else does the energy go? Do you think it charges the battery or emits light with the captured energy?

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Friday April 01, 2022 @05:33PM (#30883533)
All energy, no matter where absorbed, ends up as heat. So, the heat is meaningless to talk about unless you are making popcorn.

It is not the heat, at the end, that makes your phone work. You may read up on how antennas work, if you care to have any actual, you know, facts. I promise it won't say one word about heat.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by SigmundA on Friday April 01, 2022 @05:48PM (#30883678)
No the ADC use resistors to measure voltage, resistors turn electric energy into thermal energy, they literally use how much time it takes to dissipate electricity as heat to measure voltage.

I know someone who needs to read up on antennas and digital receivers and its not me.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by gus_massa on Friday April 01, 2022 @08:15PM (#30884681)
> they literally use how much time it takes to dissipate electricity as heat to measure voltage.

I never heard that, and looking at the list in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analog-to-digital_converter#Ty... I can't find any that work this way.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by SigmundA on Saturday April 02, 2022 @09:45AM (#30888243)
> The Wilkinson ADC is based on the comparison of an input voltage with that produced by a charging capacitor. The capacitor is allowed to charge until a comparator determines it matches the input voltage. Then, the capacitor is discharged linearly. The time required to discharge the capacitor is proportional to the amplitude of the input voltage. While the capacitor is discharging, pulses from a high-frequency oscillator clock are counted by a register. The number of clock pulses recorded in the register is also proportional to the input voltage.

The capacitor is discharged using a resistor of known value.

Also take it down to the comparator level which basically all ADC use the op-amps use transistors and resistors and are themselves dissipating the input power in order to measure voltage.

The word transistor is a contraction of transfer resistance, they are electronically variable resistors and as everyone knows dissipate power as heat during function.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by gus_massa on Saturday April 02, 2022 @01:21PM (#30889913)
After reading your comment a few times, I think now I understand the misunderstanding. There are two interpretations:

A) The main method that use a ADC to work is heating a resistance and then measuring the temperature or the time to cool down or something like that. [1]

B) As a side effect of the internal working, the ADC produce heat. The heat is not important for the operation, but it's an inevitable side effect.

My opinion: A) No, B) Yes

Can you both please answer A) and B) with "Yes" or "No"?

[1] Note that something similar is used to measure pressure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirani_gauge .

[dead]
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by dang on Saturday April 02, 2022 @02:15PM (#30890352)
Yikes—your posts in this thread ended up going way outside what's acceptable here. We ban accounts that do that, regardless of how wrong someone else is or you feel they are. I don't want to ban you, so if you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html, stick to the rules from now on, and never stoop to this kind of thing again, we'd be grateful. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Saturday April 02, 2022 @03:45PM (#30891104)
OK.
[dead]
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by dang on Saturday April 02, 2022 @02:16PM (#30890373)
You also posted an astonishing number of these off-topic, nasty comments in this thread. That is one of the worst things you can do on HN. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for.

Please don't stoop to this again, regardless of how wrong someone else is or you feel they are, and regardless of how provocative another comment was. Instead, please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and take the intended spirit of the site more to heart.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Saturday April 02, 2022 @12:53PM (#30889662)
I guess my degree in electrical engineering was a waste of time.

In no reference to electronics of radio reception, anywhere in the world, will you find even a single formula or equation with a reference to a change in temperature of a component being involved in detecting a signal. Period. None anywhere. No exceptions.

Also, nowhere in any reference on the operation of a cell phone will you find so much as a single analog-to-digital converter attached to its microwave antenna. Nowhere. Not one. No exceptions.

Your profound and aggressive ignorance is on display for all to see, and recorded for posterity.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by jeffbee on Saturday April 02, 2022 @02:00PM (#30890233)
> I guess my degree in electrical engineering was a waste of time.

That much is abundantly clear.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by dang on Saturday April 02, 2022 @02:15PM (#30890360)
Come on Jeff. Please don't make things even worse like this. We've had to warn you about this kind of thing many times in the past as well.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by jeffbee on Saturday April 02, 2022 @02:39PM (#30890566)
Sorry. I always feel like a person opens themselves to this type of feedback after they attempt to assert their own subject matter authority, as has been done here.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by dang on Saturday April 02, 2022 @04:59PM (#30891627)
I hear you! But these feelings are so common that if they justify breaking the guidelines, we might as well have no guidelines. Everyone always feels like the other person started it and did worse, and that their own contribution is always defensive and not-as-bad. Acting on that is a recipe for a downward spiral: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=downward%20spiral%20by:dang&da....

It follows that everyone needs to stick to the intended spirit of the site no matter how badly others are behaving or you feel they are. That's not easy of course. But it's the only way for this place not to destroy itself.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Friday April 01, 2022 @09:01PM (#30884926)
Right, none has ever worked that way.

Radio receivers do not depend on an analog to digital converter, or even a resistor, to extract a signal from an antenna. The essential component is a diode.

(That is not to say that, having detected, amplified, and demodulated an antenna signal, the result won't finally drive an A/D converter; you can drive anything you want to after all that. Even a speaker. But operation of the speaker, too, does not depend in any way on heat.)

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by SigmundA on Saturday April 02, 2022 @09:48AM (#30888261)
Digital receivers which are in cellphones are most certainly based on A/D convertors which is what you originally referenced. All captured antenna energy is dissipated as heat through resistance in order to extract useful information and convert it into the digital domain.

Even in a analog receiver the power amplifiers used to drive a speaker or whatever are going to dissipate the signals power as heat in order to modulate the amplifiers output power (out power will always be less than power supply power).

If you are talking about a crystal radio, then yes the input power drives a speaker and is turned into sound instead (along with some power lost heat in the circuits resistance).

[dead]
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by SigmundA on Saturday April 02, 2022 @12:00PM (#30889177)
Such aggressive ad hominem attacks are not warranted, you want to dispute my position then have some class, its ok if you don't know how radio receivers work.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by wtetzner on Friday April 01, 2022 @03:20PM (#30882226)
Or in your pants pocket, next to your testicles.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by dragontamer on Friday April 01, 2022 @02:36PM (#30881751)
Cell phones aren't "emitting" signals while in your pocket. They're largely receiving signals and sleeping.

We have many devices that emit 10Watts of EM radiation at us every day: we call them light bulbs or LEDs. Cell phones are only allowed to emit 3W IIRC.

It wouldn't surprise me if the screen has more EM than the radio.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Friday April 01, 2022 @03:55PM (#30882592)
False. Cell phones are emitting signals throughout the day, in bursts.

LEDs and light bulbs do not emit modulated microwaves. If the screen emitted substantial RF radiation, the FCC (and related agencies in other countries) would have something to say about it.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by dragontamer on Friday April 01, 2022 @04:53PM (#30883199)
Light is further up the energy-line of electromagnetic radiation.

Least-dangerous -- Radio / Infrared / Visible Light / Ultraviolet / XRays / Gamma Rays -- Most energy/dangerous

All light-bulbs, screens, LEDs (etc. etc.) emit visible light. There's a couple of bands in there that might be more dangerous than others (ex: Microwaves specifically resonate with water), but for the most part, Gamma Rays are the most dangerous, and Radiowaves have the least effect on our body.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by Gnarl on Saturday April 02, 2022 @08:13AM (#30887631)
@dragontamer: "Radiowaves have the least effect on our body" - but what happens when you modulate them at a secondary, low frequency, that disturbs voltage-gated cell-membrane ion-channels?

Just hoping to pique your curiosity into the field of biology and away from hyper-reductionistic physics models.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by dragontamer on Sunday April 03, 2022 @11:44AM (#30897765)
> that disturbs voltage-gated cell-membrane ion-channels?

You're begging the question.

You could have more easily stated your opinion as "low frequency radio waves disturb cells". Which is fundamentally false. There are lots of radio-waves being used around the world: RADAR systems, Radio-headquarter units... as well as people who live nearby radio-towers (TV, AM Radio, FM Radio), and cell phones.

Do you think WW2 units fielded with SCR-300 (World War 2 backpack radio) had increased amounts of cell membrane damage associated with them?

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/ca/Scr300.p...

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by ncmncm on Friday April 01, 2022 @05:53PM (#30883717)
False. Again.
Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by chemeng on Friday April 01, 2022 @02:34PM (#30881731)
The categorization is 0 minutes, 1-20, >20 minutes per week. The latter with an IQR of 10-45mins per week.

I’m not saying it’s a great study, but please at least skim the study before being so dismissive and slightly misleading in the comments.

Re:No increased risk of brain tumours for mobile phone users... by forum_ghost on Friday April 01, 2022 @04:09PM (#30882762)
This study is the most peer-reviewed April Fools joke.