News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Dear 'open source' people (on defending rms) by emilsedgh on Saturday October 08, 2011 @08:14AM (#3087750)
If you dont follow fsf's definition of 'Free Software', then 1) Why would you care if FSF is ideological or practical? 2) Why dont you define your meaning of 'free software' and give it a name? Thats what esr did and named it open source.

If you dont care about free software (with rms'es definition), why do you want FSF to function differet? Why would you care? Why would FSF and rms chage their direction towards what you value as 'software freedom'?

Re:Tell HN: Dear 'open source' people (on defending rms) by stonemetal on Saturday October 08, 2011 @09:24AM (#3087855)
Why dont you define your meaning of 'free software' and give it a name?

I already have it is called free software. Look at the founding of any movement from Alan Kay and Object Oriented programming to Christ and Christianity, founding a movement allows you to push the world in a given direction. It doesn't make you king who gets to lord over every last thought of members of the movement.

Why do I care if the FSF is practical or ideological? Simple I believe in free software and think it could be so much more. However when FSF goes off on its ideological jaunts, it hurts free software. When ESR and RMS had their little spat that lead to the creation of OSI it hurt the movement. When the president of the FSF leaves little notes about how the world is better place because someone is dead it hurts the movement. I don't care what the FSF does so long as it quits trying to kill free software.

Re:Tell HN: Dear 'open source' people (on defending rms) by Maro on Saturday October 08, 2011 @09:13AM (#3087836)
I wouldn't care, if people would stop posting braindumps like this and RMS's here...