News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by cato_the_elder on Thursday March 31, 2022 @12:51PM (#30869431)
This is dystopian. Apparently they are trying to send a teenager to jail because of a single tweet:

> Price previously admitted one count of sending a grossly offensive message by a public communication network at a hearing at Worcester magistrates court on 17 March.

Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by breakyerself on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:09PM (#30869687)
Its outside of what we would expect in the United States, but dystopian is hyperbolic. They don't want to tolerate racism there. Racism is bad so I can understand. The US is an outlier in how extreme our speech protections go. Even with this England tolerates far more transgressive speech than many other parts of the world. I can't even list the number of places where it's dangerous or illegal to criticize the political class. That's dystopian. This is just different from what you're used to.
Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by cato_the_elder on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:23PM (#30869878)
I'm not from the US. I am originally from one of those places where it's more dangerous to offend the political class. I guess that's part of the reason I find this dystopian.
Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by clarge1120 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:22PM (#30869857)
This is definitely dystopian, in the US and elsewhere. It's not just that it was a single tweet, but that the police arrested someone for a racial slur (an insult). It advances equally dystopian ideas such as "silence is violence" into real-world consequences, and establishes the dual justice system that dystopian books have warned us about for two generations.
Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by bitwize on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:17PM (#30869780)
Most of the world does not have a First Amendment.

There are freer countries than the USA — countries which provide access to health care and education that goes beyond "wage slavery" training — that criminalize hate speech. One incident of expressed racial hatred is enough to warrant criminal prosecution. These countries have not yet descended into dystopia. Some of them criminalized hate speech in response to dystopia in their recent past.

It's time to rethink whether an absolutist, "First Amendment-like"[0] approach to free speech is really the best approach.

[0] The absolutist interpretation of the First Amendment has only actually prevailed since 1967, when a conservative Supreme Court ruled that Klan marches were protected speech in Brandenburg v. Ohio.

Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by version_five on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:36PM (#30870040)
> There are freer countries than the USA — countries which provide access to health care and education

So you just made up a different definition of freedom and them claimed there are freer countries? Free education and healthcare are not related to freedom. They can be present e.g. in the USSR or in a freer country like Canada (formerly). But they are not an essential ingredient nor do they imply anything about freedom in the usual constitutional sense. You're talking about the merits of a welfare state and calling it freedom

Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by boeingUH60 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:22PM (#30870565)
> There are freer countries than the USA — countries which provide access to health care and education that goes beyond "wage slavery" training — that criminalize hate speech.

Free education and healthcare are definitely good, but that isn’t what constitutes a “free” state.

For example, Saudi Arabia has free education and healthcare but is an absolute monarchy that comes down hard on critics.

Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by vmception on Thursday March 31, 2022 @03:11PM (#30871139)
> Most of the world does not have a First Amendment.

Almost most of the world lives under a constitution that guarantees freedom of speech, they just also live under a constitution that contradicts in another way

and I'm not talking about an ambiguous place like the UK where they is no one specific document outlining rights, clear modern constitutions

I'm thinking 3.5 billion out of 7.9 billion live in a place governed by a document that contains the same text as the First Amendment

I'm sure we can get it to over half. I just added the populations of China and India to the US, as I'm only familiar with their constitutions.

So just helping you strengthen your argument in the future, by maybe saying it differently.

Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by inkblotuniverse on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:31PM (#30870683)
Even with a first amendment, free education is indoctrination. Without it, it's indoctrination you get jailed for disagreeing with.
Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by BeefWellington on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:09PM (#30869689)
> This is dystopian. Apparently they are trying to send a teenager to jail because of a single tweet:

In most (all?) places 19 year olds are viewed as adults.

Being jailed for a single tweet on its own is dystopian, there's no need to appeal to feelings about this being done to children.

Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by cato_the_elder on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:16PM (#30869763)
> In most (all?) places 19 year olds are viewed as adults.

Well, you are correct one sense. But the guy is quite young, and the article itself refers to him as a teenager.

Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by welcome_dragon on Thursday March 31, 2022 @01:48PM (#30870172)
I mean a nineteen year old _is_ a teenager by definition
Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by selbyk on Thursday March 31, 2022 @03:57PM (#30871583)
And also an adult in most places, by legal definition. The two aren't mutually exclusive

(to the parent comment, but responding here since my point is an extension of yours)

Re:Man, 19, jailed for racially abusing Marcus Rashford on T... by system2 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @02:48PM (#30870878)
I have a 19 year old nephew. He still acts like he is 10 in some cases. I can't see him as adult nor his decisions in life looks like an adult. 19 is so young and still mentally child in many cases.