News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: I just open-sourced the e-mail client I spent 2 ... by biot on Friday October 07, 2011 @11:49AM (#3084468)
From the blog:

  > For the last one week, a considerable number of people who
  > have downloaded the Inbox2 app have had issues.
  >
  > The main reason for this was that our infrastructure was not
  > scaling fast enough at the rate the app was being downloaded. 
Why does an email client depend on your infrastructure?
Re:Tell HN: I just open-sourced the e-mail client I spent 2 ... by waseemsadiq on Friday October 07, 2011 @12:08PM (#3084580)
Actually the client doesn't but we also have another version which runs in the cloud. Old versions of the ipad app were hooked up to that, newer versions are completely stand alone so that has also changed in the mean while... hey what can I say, we move fast :-)
Re:Tell HN: I just open-sourced the e-mail client I spent 2 ... by biot on Friday October 07, 2011 @12:34PM (#3084738)
What was the benefit of such an arrangement? My email server is already "in the cloud" so to speak. As it's a downloaded app, what value was added from a man in the middle, as it were?
Re:Tell HN: I just open-sourced the e-mail client I spent 2 ... by waseemsadiq on Friday October 07, 2011 @12:50PM (#3084794)
Well the cloud is always on and online. Additionally we want to work with metadata which we want to store in the cloud and is not supported by for ex. the IMAP protocol. I can't go into to much details regarding our product roadmap but having a cloud backend really helps.

Another concrete case is new email notifications. When our ipad is not the active app we simply are not able to inform you when new mail arrives (due to apple background app restrictions). With a client/cloud hybrid we can do the heavy lifting on the client and use the cloud for example to send notifications when new mail arrives.

Re:Tell HN: I just open-sourced the e-mail client I spent 2 ... by biot on Friday October 07, 2011 @01:10PM (#3084883)
The cloud is always on and online? I don't mean to be argumentative, but your cloud apparently couldn't handle the load. Downloading an email client shouldn't require a "hit by a bus" analysis of the app's creators.

An app can store metadata locally; no need to have that on your servers. No doubt you can do some interesting things by having a server-side infrastructure, but I'm concerned about the security implications. If your server gets hacked, an attacker would have access to all of my email. Not to mention that you would have access to all of my email and why should I trust you?

Re:Tell HN: I just open-sourced the e-mail client I spent 2 ... by brown9-2 on Friday October 07, 2011 @01:32PM (#3084966)
Pure speculation but it kind of sounds like they want to be able to mine some of that data.
Re:Tell HN: I just open-sourced the e-mail client I spent 2 ... by illumen on Saturday October 08, 2011 @01:16AM (#3087199)
It also gives them an extra way to lock users in.
Re:Tell HN: I just open-sourced the e-mail client I spent 2 ... by waseems on Sunday October 09, 2011 @06:40AM (#3090211)
Well thats why we are a 'start'-up, we have the start part down just need to get at he up part :-0
Re:Tell HN: I just open-sourced the e-mail client I spent 2 ... by sliverstorm on Friday October 07, 2011 @03:39PM (#3085528)
Stop offering the cloud version while you work on the client version. Re-offer the cloud version later once you've got your feet under you.