News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by trumpablehump on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:32AM (#30843034)
This is a thought of science denial. Using mice as proxies for human biology has been a tool in medical science for decades and has led to many great discoveries.

Is there a specific issue you see where the usage of a mouse model is devastating to this study?

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by timr on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:50AM (#30843284)
No, it isn't. There's a saying in medical research: "mice lie, and monkeys exaggerate". This is because most findings in mice don't translate to humans.

Representing an experimental result as directly relevant to humans when it wasn't done in humans is misleading.

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by Barrin92 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @11:27AM (#30843876)
> as directly relevant to humans when it wasn't done in humans is misleading

The authors point out that the same observation was made in human brain tissue of covid patients as well, it is literally in the paper.

"We had the opportunity to examine human cortex and subcortical white matter samples from a cohort of nine individuals[...]"

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by timr on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @12:54PM (#30845160)
The results shown in Figure 3 are essentially unrelated to the rest of the paper. It's an experiment that they've included to claim some relevance to humans, and head off the criticism that this is a paper about mice.

At best, you can argue that they show a different inflammatory marker in a group of people who were already unwell. Here's the paper describing the people from whom the 9 samples were chosen:

https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2033369

> We performed conventional histopathological examination of the brains of 18 patients. Fourteen patients had chronic illnesses, including diabetes and hypertension, and 11 had been found dead or had died suddenly and unexpectedly. Of the 16 patients with available medical histories, 1 had delirium, 5 had mild respiratory symptoms, 4 had acute respiratory distress syndrome, 2 had pulmonary embolism, and the symptoms were not known in 3

I can't tell which of these patients were used in this study, but...there's a lot going on with these samples. One of the patients was a meth addict, and another was a heroin addict, yet another was an alcoholic, and two others had recurrent seizures from prior head injuries!

https://www.nejm.org/doi/suppl/10.1056/NEJMc2033369/suppl_fi...

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by trumpablehump on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @11:14AM (#30856293)
I wasn't talking about the results and relevance of this particular paper but I was replying to a cheap, offhand generalisation.

No doubt that one needs to be cautious about animal tests but they do work and are highly effective in many cases, especially for finding indications of possible effects on humans. Or is that not true?

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by majormjr on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @09:51AM (#30842514)
It's mentioned in the abstract that similar findings were noted in humans as well.

"Humans experiencing long-COVID with cognitive symptoms (48 subjects) similarly demonstrate elevated CCL11 levels compared to those with long-COVID who lack cognitive symptoms (15 subjects)."

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by omginternets on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:21AM (#30842880)
Bluntly: your opinion on this will only be interesting when you can correctly explain (a) why mouse models are used (b) why mice and not some other mammal (c) what mouse models can and cannot tell us about humans, and lastly (d) why this mouse model isn’t consistent with (a)-(c).
Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by JabavuAdams on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:11PM (#30845454)
That's not as bad as you might think, depending on your specific concern. We're basically worms with extra doodads glommed on. Cake hole connected to poop hole, with gonads. Also, sometimes brains, but mostly gonads.

Sorry, I don't know your level of knowledge of things cell-biology and genomics. If your concern is mouse != human, than that's not really a good argument by itself. If your concern is that many diseases / therapies that seem to work in mice don't readily translate to humans, then yeah, I agree.

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by anarticle on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:17AM (#30842827)
Biochemist here, this reply is pretty stale and also lazy. Many studies are done in mice. A better criticism would be that this is a preprint. In fact, there's a giant yellow box right above it that says:

"bioRxiv posts many COVID19-related papers. A reminder: they have not been formally peer-reviewed and should not guide health-related behavior or be reported in the press as conclusive."

You're free to check out the credentials of the people in the paper, which look great. A bunch of different people that have worked in COVID, virology, and vaccines.

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by ifyoubuildit on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @11:22AM (#30843792)
> A better criticism would be that this is a preprint.

Does this mean that of the two characteristics ("study in mice" and "is a preprint"), "is a preprint" is more predictive of the result failing to pan out in humans?

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by anarticle on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @10:38AM (#30855806)
Preprint means that it has not been peer reviewed. It is likely in submission to various journals, where a few people in the field (hopefully peers in the field!) will discuss the edge cases of the study. In my experience this ranges from a rival lab you get along with giving you shit for not checking something out, to a lab that has no idea what genes are in a zebrafish accusing you that the gene you are studying does not exist in zebrafish.

Note: this happened to me, and there is google maps for zebrafish genes, this is easy: https://zfin.org/search?category=&q=SHC

You never know what kind of questions they might ask! Papers do in fact get rejected for shoddy work, or get sent to revision. Often it's not a huge problem, maybe fix a figure, double check some other work, or refer you to someone else's study that contradicts your claim. If you're not a fraud, you generally bring your strongest case, so the only tuning needed is details.

That being said, peer review doesn't always work, as there are cases of publishing fraud.

However, for labs that get exceptional scoops you can bet people are going to try to replicate it and if it turns out it doesn't work you've got some explaining to do. (Your academic reputation is now on the line.)

Here's a short list of notes on retractions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retractions_in_academic_publis...

In my career (10y), I personally witnessed two people immolate their careers over publishing papers that didn't work or stole results from someone else.

Fun retraction watch site here: https://retractionwatch.com

To directly answer your questions:

Mice (and to a greater extent, animal models) are the current standard for advancing studies in biology. Are there problems with mouse models? Sure. Is there currently a better alternative? No.

Are preprints bad? No. It used to be there was no such thing as a preprint, you submitted your work to a journal and that was that. Accept or reject. You might have sent the preprint version to people in your field you were collaborating with, or some deconstructed version to verify parts of your work. Now with arxiv style publishing, it's up to the community at large to figure out what's what. I'm not saying one or the other is better. Us biodorks are catching up to physics people. However, anyone can publish to arxiv, including kooks.

Can preprints be bad? Yes. This work has no scrutiny to its claims by anyone outside of the authors, so for laypeople not in the field we don't have a good insight as to make heads or tails of these claims. Could you look it all up? Of course! Contrast that to someone in the field that might say on sight: "Yeah, Nichols' work has been pretty out there" or "That gene doesn't work the same way in zebrafish." :D

Mice are uncontroversial. Preprints are uncontroversial. I don't think I'd put money on either. I would be more interested to see follow up work than change the animal model.

PS: Wow, I had good coffee this morning!

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by taneq on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:58AM (#30843416)
Not a biochemist but: "Many studies are done in mice." Isn't this kind of the issue? Are mouse models really that good of a proxy for humans? How do you validate this?
Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by wins32767 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @11:24AM (#30843820)
They certainly aren't perfect proxies for humans, but they have a lot of advantages: 1) They reproduce quickly. 2) We have inbred several different strains so that every member is genetically identical to all the others of the same sex. 3) There is a huge amount of scientific knowledge already accumulated on mice, and the inbred strains specifically. Different developmental checkpoints, what healthy looks like across basically every dimension.

These first two make it possible to do repeatable studies at relatively low costs. The latter allows you to do things like knock out or replace a gene and see see what impacts it has biologically and you can find out in weeks instead of years. Research mice the way biologists reduce their build times.

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by anarticle on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @11:23AM (#30843812)
The process in drug discovery is: invitro work, animal models (zebrafish, mice, rats), clinical trials, release to public. It is completely standard for work to be done in mice, and to dismiss it in this way is a nothing burger.

There is a piece of truth in that "animals models don't always pan out", but that's the state of the art whether we like it or not.

My point is, if you start the criticism at "mice model, opinion rejected", you are rejecting nearly all basic bioscience.

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by MrMan on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @06:16PM (#30849075)
call it transfer learning
Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by superkuh on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:00AM (#30842610)
Yeah, at least one of the things they report is irrelevant.

>Impaired hippocampal neurogenesis, decreased oligodendrocytes and myelin loss in subcortical white matter were evident at 1 week

I can forgive them for not knowing that the great "Do adults humans have neurogenesis in the dentate gyrus of the hippocampus (or EC)" debate has been pretty much ended. We don't. Adult humans don't make new neurons. Humans aren't like other mammals. So... I'm not sure how much the "impared hippocampal neurogenesis" bit applies. Our hippocampal neurogenesis is already impaired. Unless you're pre-pubescent.

ref: "Transcriptomic taxonomy and neurogenic trajectories of adult human, macaque, and pig hippocampal and entorhinal cells" Franjic et al., 2022 https://www.cell.com/neuron/pdf/S0896-6273(21)00866-7.pdf

laymen ref: https://neurocritic.blogspot.com/2022/02/the-ongoing-debate-...

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by sterlind on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:20PM (#30846436)
wow, I remember learning the opposite in my neurobiology class several years ago, but your source checks out.

one question though: what about that study that measured carbon-14 levels in the brains of people born before atomic bomb testing? [0]

I don't doubt you're correct re: neurogenesis, I'm just confused how different studies saw different things.

0. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4394608/

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by tux3 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:57AM (#30843398)
Does this mean BDNF in adult humans does not actually promote neurogenesis?
Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by superkuh on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @03:38PM (#30847361)
Yes. It's really upset a giant amount of papers and proposed mechanisms of actions all across human neuroscience.
Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by The_rationalist on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @02:20PM (#30846441)
adults humans can have neurogenesis in specific regions https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fncel.2018.0044... but the most salient thing, which is very potent is synaptogenesis, e.g magnesium l-threonate giving multiple IQ points.
Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by superkuh on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @03:51PM (#30847513)
Your linked paper talks about how the "adult mammalian brain can produce new neurons". That isn't controversial. What used to be controversial, but isn't anymore, is that adult humans brains don't produce new neurons. Not in the dentate gyrus, not in the entorhinal cortex between the hippocampus and cortex, not even in the olfactory bulb. Your linked paper does not have any human studies of neurogenesis, only BDNF serum levels and assumptions about what that means from mouse models. But mouse, even ape models, don't translate re: neurogenesis.

Like everyone else, yourself included, I used to think that THC's main anti-depressant effect was mediated through increasing survival of new neurons during their granual cell to neuron journey in the dentate. But nope. Adult humans don't have new neurons.

Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by The_rationalist on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:58PM (#30849896)
https://www.jneurosci.org/content/41/12/2541 Looks like there is evidence. Also are you claiming there are no stem-cells/MSCs in the brain? I have read multiples papers about drugs that specialize unspecialized cells into olygoendrocytes (a microglia) in the human brain. I don't see why epigenetics wouldn't allow unspecialized cells to become neurons vs glial cells. Finally if I recall correctly, some glial cells might not act like neurons but still release neurotransmitters. More importantly, humans should preserve their neurons by actively fighting apoptosis, e.g. by taking skq1. And as said previously, synaptothrophics exists and are very potent. Finally, hypermnesics are a thing. BTW children are generally happiers/more emotional than adults. One might wonder wether this is related to neuron/synapse density
Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by superkuh on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:52PM (#30860007)
I'll give that paper it's claim, that "DCX+ dentate granule cells are a dynamic cell population that undergoes progressive maturation" but I don't see new evidence from that paper suggesting they actually make it through the complex, multi-step, evolution of granule cells to neurons. There are a lot of stops and pitfalls on the way. The evidence from the 2022 paper I linked at the start of this thread shows the gene expression profiles of adult human dentate granule cells are very different from other mammals.
Re:Mild respiratory SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause myelin lo... by taneq on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @10:56AM (#30843386)
Recent research using a mouse model proves that my car is way too big and that cats are terrible pets.