Sure, we can't be "sure" but the probability is so low it isn't worth considering and entertaining that possibility.
His intentions though are irrelevant. It's a pretty spot on observation.
Mine is that he hates assholes who use any belief as a cudgel against other people. Atheists using our lack of faith to attack the faithful are also assholes. I agree with that. Stephens intent is always comedy first and foremost.
Regardless. Agnostics do indeed lack a spine and try to wiggle their way out using philosophical minutia. Case in point this discussion. You're trying to project thoughts into a comedians intent. Instead of admitting that the words themselves have truth to them.
Certainly, everyone is free to draw their own interpretation, but only Colbert's interpretation is accurate. Your argument will remain unconvincing so long as it is unsupported by any valid reasoning or provably true statements. By employing a false narrative to insist what any other is doing, you are committing ad hominem and straw man fallacies simultaneously. By insisting it is as you say it is without backing up claims with evidence supporting the claims, you are committing an argument from authority, which is also fallacy. Invalid argument remains unconvincing.
False. This is precisely what you have done, and the evidence is plainly seen in your comments.
> You're the one busy with that strawman.
This statement is in fact an example of ad hominem fallacy and straw man fallacy.
> You're the one doing the whole "what he thinks" shtick.
Again, this is both ad hominem and straw man. I have supported my position with Colbert's known disposition and his very own words.
> Which I repeatedly said is redundant.
This is a new and separate claim, which, because of the content of the claim and the lack of actually previously claiming such, the statement is currently false.
Yet you persist to cherry pick...
> The vast majority of atheists are agnostic atheists
Facts not in evidence.
There are many things that I can't know with the same absolute certainty with which I can know that the real numbers are uncountable or that I exist given the fact that I am aware (I think therefore I am), but that's not the standard required in order to "know" something. I am as confident that the God of the bible doesn't exist as I am that there is no elephant floating in the Boötes void. Quite a lot more so, actually.
This isn't an arbitrary belief, of equal weight to all possible beliefs. It's based on evidence and reason.
> Facts not in evidence.
Well, I can't speak for most atheists but it's the only version of atheism that makes sense given the obvious fact that you can't absolutely prove a negative existential (outside of maths at any rate).
Agnostics can not be wrong. This elevates their position over any that could be wrong.
You are simply and obviously mistaken. I get to do whatever the hell I want, because you are not the boss of me, have as yet been unable to assail my bulletproof logic, while yours is riddled with fallacy, such as ad hominem (personal attack), straw man (false attribution of statements), and argument from authority (your confidence in your belief), unapologetically employed unconvincingly as impotent and faulty reasoning bereft of any support beyond your say so.
Agnosticism is the view or belief that the existence of God, of the divine or the supernatural is unknown or unknowable. [1]
"You don't get to" is a figure of speech, pointing out that to make the claim is nonsensical. You are of course at liberty to make the claim and, since it makes no sense, I am free to ignore it (which I wouldn't be if it were actually a compelling argument).
It's very simple. It's well known that "X does not exist" is never provable in the same way as "X exists" is. In the latter case we can present X itself and say "look, it exists", end of story. In the former, there's always the possibility that we didn't look in all the places X could be, that we failed to properly define X or were looking for it the wrong way, etc. You attempted to use this to say that atheists are claiming to "know the unknowable". I'll quote your original comment:
> Atheists make precisely the same mistake as deists, claiming to know the unknowable. Agnostics have the most compelling argument.
What I have been pointing out is the fallacy of thinking that the fact that "X does not exist" is not provable with the same finality as "X does exist" somehow means that "X does not exist" is not a question that is open to analysis on the basis of evidence and reason. Questions of that nature are very much open to such analysis, so that argument falls flat.
Note that you haven't asked at all what evidence and reasoning my conviction that the God of the bible does not exist is based on. Rather, you have continued to assert that this belief of mine cannot have any basis, using the same flawed reasoning. I'd be happy to discuss that evidence and weigh it against any evidence you're aware of for the contrary view. That isn't argument from authority, it's argument from evidence. You just haven't shown any interest in engaging with it.
As to the definition of agnosticism, it can be defined either way and makes no difference to the refutation of your flawed reasoning above. I simply think that the definition I gave (a mainstream one, but not the only one) is useful if you're concerned with the "unknowability" of nonexistence as you appear to be. It allows you to make it clear that theism is a belief of the form "X exists" and can therefore in theory be proven absolutely by displaying the object (there's God right there, say hello, clearly he exists, you're looking right at Him) although nobody has done so, while atheism cannot in principle be demonstrated true in that way. With my definition of agnosticism that comes out as "theists can be agnostic or gnostic, whereas atheists can only be agnostic". With your definition of agnosticism you lose the ability to make that point so succinctly. However it remains just as true.
Now, if you have anything to say that actually addresses any of the points I've made, or you would like to present any evidence or reasoning that might cause me to reevaluate my atheism, I'd be happy to continue. But if all you can produce at this stage is further rants I won't reply.
Edit: It occurs to me that you haven't explicitly stated that the negative existential is the reason you consider the atheist position a claim to "know the unknowable". I've assumed that because it's the only argument I'm aware of anyone having made for this claim, and it's a commonly presented one. Also, you haven't presented any alternative justification. There is, however, the possibility that you have some other reason for thinking atheists are claiming to "know the unknowable", and if so I'm keen to hear it.
Not possible.
> fallacy of thinking that the fact that "X does not exist" is not provable with the same finality as "X does exist" somehow means that "X does not exist" is not a question that is open to analysis on the basis of evidence and reason.
What fallacy are you referring to? Please name it. In fact, this entire post, nearly every sentence, there is a lack of any actual identifiable reference to what you are referring. When you are trying to explain something, it helps immensely to be specific, as opposed to vaguely referring to some previous statement.
> Note that you haven't asked at all what evidence and reasoning my conviction that the God of the bible does not exist is based on.
Noted. But when someone or anyone makes a claim, the onus is upon them to support their claim. I am not responsible for your claims or your lack of support for your claims.
> I'd be happy to discuss that evidence and weigh it against any evidence you're aware of for the contrary view.
What was stopping you before? Look, I think you have it all figured out, and that's really all that matters.
> your flawed reasoning above.
I'd appreciate it if you would be specific.
> Edit: It occurs to me that you haven't explicitly stated that the negative existential is the reason you consider the atheist position a claim to "know the unknowable".
My claim, as always, is that atheists make the same exact mistake that deists make, which is that they both claim to know something, like knowing 2 + 3 = 5, that, in fact, they do not know that something, they merely believe it. It is belief, and belief is not knowledge, no matter how strong that belief is. Certainly, they have knowledge of their belief, and may think their belief is knowledge, but it is clearly not. You forgot your keys and you believe you left them on the coffee table, but that belief could be wrong. You may have left them on the counter. What is that "belief" when it is proven incorrect? One can not prove that 2 + 3 != 5, no matter how much it is believed. The best that could happen is to personally accept responsibility for the error, relinquish belief, which can be wrong and probably is wrong more often than not, and gain in its place actual genuine bone fide knowledge and awareness of the truth of the matter. And if the truth can not be revealed, then relinquish the possibility of knowledge, which is exactly what agnostics do, and they do know something. They know that they don't know, which is the most honest and most supportable position to have among the choices of atheism, deism, and agnosticism. If one is not aware of what one does not know, there are some serious problems.
As I keep saying, I specifically do not claim to know it "like knowing 2+3=5". I am "agnostic" in that respect (by my definition).
Your mistake is thinking that that is the only form of knowledge that warrants the word "knowing". The vast majority of the things I know I do not know in that way. I know that when I go downstairs and open the door there will not be an aggresive, 12 foot spider waiting for me. On the basis of this knowledge I do not consider arming myself with a baseball bat or using another exit. I do however have to admit that I cannot absolutely exclude the possibility in the way I can exclude the possibility of 2+3 being 6.
If I restricted myself to the form of knowledge you are requiring I would only know some maths, that I exist and certain specifics of the world I can see right at this moment. Fortunately I don't need to. Humans have powerful ways of deriving knowledge that is not of that nature, but is nonetheless knowledge. All of natural science, for example.
I hope this makes it clear. I explicitly do not claim the specific kind of knowledge you are saying I claim (that is a straw man). I do however claim knowledge of the same sort as most of the things I know, such as that all massive bodies attract one another. The kind of knowledge that admits the logical possibility of being demonstrated wrong at some point, but which is nonetheless strong, evidentially supported knowledge.
The vast majority of atheists are agnostic atheists as they acknowledge the point you make about the unknowability of the nonexistence of an entity. Many theists are gnostic and some claim direct, personal knowledge of god.
However, the fact that I am an agnostic atheist shouldn't be taken to mean that I am in any way weak in my atheism - my belief that there is no god - or that I don't think there are extremely strong, rational, evidence-based reasons for that belief.
The best way it can be put is to take an absurd example of something that cannot be known to be false but which everyone will agree is surely false. For example, that somewhere in the Boötes void there is an elephant floating through space.
This cannot be proven to be false, but there are many strong, rational, evidence-based reasons for believing it not to be true. These reasons aren't just about the absurdity of the notion but about the theories we have formed to understand how things like elephants come to exist, and the evidence we have gathered for such theories.
I'm not much of a fan of Richard Dawkins' all-out assault on religion (while I'm an atheist I'm far from anti-religion, and I spend more time in church than most christian believers), but this is one thing he explained very clearly in The God Delusion, and it's a point that I think is worth making clear.