Re:Roman Catholic Priest: 30 Yrs in 17c France, Published Po...
by invalidname on Friday March 25, 2022 @12:54PM
(#30804500)
I'm not the one constructing evidence or claiming to know what's in his mind. You're the one busy with that strawman. I pasted his quote and mentioned my interpretation of it. You're the one doing the whole "what he thinks" shtick. Which I repeatedly said is redundant.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Roman Catholic Priest: 30 Yrs in 17c France, Published Po...
by Maursault on Friday March 25, 2022 @01:21PM
(#30804836)
> I'm not the one constructing evidence or claiming to know what's in his mind.
False. This is precisely what you have done, and the evidence is plainly seen in your comments.
> You're the one busy with that strawman.
This statement is in fact an example of ad hominem fallacy and straw man fallacy.
> You're the one doing the whole "what he thinks" shtick.
Again, this is both ad hominem and straw man. I have supported my position with Colbert's known disposition and his very own words.
> Which I repeatedly said is redundant.
This is a new and separate claim, which, because of the content of the claim and the lack of actually previously claiming such, the statement is currently false.
Re:Roman Catholic Priest: 30 Yrs in 17c France, Published Po...
by invalidname on Friday March 25, 2022 @01:25PM
(#30804895)
First reply to you: "His intentions though are irrelevant."
Yet you persist to cherry pick...
Re:Roman Catholic Priest: 30 Yrs in 17c France, Published Po...
by Maursault on Friday March 25, 2022 @05:01PM
(#30807015)
I think I see, when you say you "repeatedly said was redundant," what you meant was you mentioned something once. Thanks, I was a little confused there because the words you use actually mean something else... but your intent matters more than the semantics.