News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by auslegung on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:48PM (#30794533)
I’m not being a jerk, but are you aware of XXY syndrome? How does that fit into your statement?
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by Ourgon on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:30PM (#30794984)
People have 2 arms and 2 legs with 5 fingers/toes at the end of each. This is a fact, not changed by the fact that indeed there are some people with more than 5 fingers/toes, some with fewer or even none at all. Those people are the exception to the rule.

In the same vein a woman is an adult human female, characterised by having double-X chromosomes, producing large gametes and generally being capable of conceiving and nursing children. The presence of people with a double-X + Y chromosome (who are, in fact, men, not women, search for 'Klinefelter syndrome' [1]) does not change this fact, nor does the fact that some women - yes, of course they are still women - can not conceive or nurse children.

[1] https://www.webmd.com/men/klinefelter-syndrome

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by greyface- on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:33PM (#30795016)
That's not a rule. That's a heuristic.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by Ourgon on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:40PM (#30795082)
That is word play and does not achieve anything other than to muddle the discussion.

What, in your words, is a woman?

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by greyface- on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:59PM (#30795268)
Humans often -- but not always -- have 2 arms and 2 legs and 5 digits on each limb.

Women and men often -- but not always -- are cisgender/cissexual.

You are allowing for an exception to the heuristic in the first case, but not the second.

[dead]
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by greyface- on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:26PM (#30795539)
If my choice of language offends you, you may substitute 'are not transgender/transsexual' where I said 'are cisgender/cissexual'.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by dekhn on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:58PM (#30795243)
Its a heuristic which is consistent with biological evidence and our best understanding of human biology and evolution.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by kadoban on Friday March 25, 2022 @01:19AM (#30798874)
Heuristics are by definition approximations. If all you're claiming is that it's a heuristic, I suspect you're not making the argument you probably think you are.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by da39a3ee on Friday March 25, 2022 @08:26AM (#30801271)
That's what biology is like. The binariness of human sex is much clearer than many distinctions in biology.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by akomtu on Friday March 25, 2022 @04:32AM (#30799772)
It's a physical law, which is a heuristic so accurate that exceptions are almost unheard of. We don't say "the 3rd Newton heuristic" just because in some weird curcumstances it's not accurate.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by a_shovel on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:16PM (#30795434)
> People have 2 arms and 2 legs with 5 fingers/toes at the end of each. This is a fact, not changed by the fact that indeed there are some people with more than 5 fingers/toes, some with fewer or even none at all. Those people are the exception to the rule.

> Those people are the exception

If there are exceptions, then it's not a fact. At best, it's an approximation that works well in most situations, and is subject to exceptions where it is simply false.

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by Ourgon on Thursday March 24, 2022 @06:51PM (#30796438)
That's just sophistry which doesn't add anything to the discussion. Given that the vast majority (99.98%) of humans do end up either male or female [1] it is a fact that humans are sexually dimorphic with male and female phenotypes with the exceptions being just that: exceptions.

[1] the prevalence of intersex is seen to be about 0.018%: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0022449020955213...

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by vba616 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:44PM (#30798435)
>with the exceptions being just that: exceptions

This is a parochial viewpoint.

Are you aware that other species have a wide variety of mechanisms for determining sex? Which means that evolution can and does result in the modification of fundamentals, at least if you take common descent for granted.

This can only happen if a mostly bimodal distribution is not entirely bimodal - what would provide the material for evolution to something different otherwise?

Hence, the outliers are not insignificant at all, except according to some arbitrary value system.

I don't have a reference, but I vaguely recall reading that the asymmetry between the X and Y chromosome has developed under evolutionary pressure and eventually the Y chromosome may disappear entirely.

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by vba616 on Friday March 25, 2022 @05:02PM (#30807024)
Eppur si muove.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by dekhn on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:57PM (#30795237)
Note, very importantly, XXY syndrome implies infertility; the people who have this do not reproduce or contribute to the evolution of the germline at all. I would not place such a person in either a "biological sex" category of male or female, but I wouldn't have any problem with them identifying with either of those, in terms of naming and pronouns.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by a_shovel on Thursday March 24, 2022 @07:10PM (#30796653)
That's an entirely reasonable position. It acknowledges that "male" and "female", while useful concepts, are ultimately just a classification system that not everyone will fit into neatly; and if they don't, it's probably best to say so instead of trying to force them into one or the other.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by kadoban on Friday March 25, 2022 @01:21AM (#30798889)
Are all infertile people without bioligical sex then? What about those past (or before) their reproductive years? What about those that only choose not to reproduce, or had surgery to prevent it?
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by Ourgon on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:59PM (#30795866)
They are men with one or more extra X chromosomes. Men. Some men who suffer from this syndrome can be treated so as to be able to impregnate women with their own sperm. I assume that this only works for men who have partial/mosaic Klinefelter, otherwise their sperm could also contain double-X chromosomes - but maybe it also works for them, leading to an increase in children being born with this condition?
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by dekhn on Thursday March 24, 2022 @07:25PM (#30796801)
XXY is not a heritable trait.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by water8 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:49PM (#30794554)
They have a Y chromosome. They are a male. It’s the lack of the Y not the presence of two Xs that make a woman a woman
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by epgui on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:55PM (#30794622)
Unfortunately, it just is not that simple.

It's up to you, but you have a choice between either letting go of this idea, or continuing to hold slightly wrong beliefs. (I am a scientist, but this is not my specific area of expertise)

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/sex-redefined-the...

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by tablespoon on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:35PM (#30795610)
>> They have a Y chromosome. They are a male. It’s the lack of the Y not the presence of two Xs that make a woman a woman

> Unfortunately, it just is not that simple.

Unfortunately, it probably is that simple:

https://www.webmd.com/men/klinefelter-syndrome:

> Klinefelter syndrome is a genetic condition in which a boy is born with an extra X chromosome. Instead of the typical XY chromosomes in men, they have XXY, so this condition is sometimes called XXY syndrome.

> Men with Klinefelter usually don’t know they have it until they run into problems trying to have a child.

When people say things like "males have XY chromosomes," it's a somewhat fuzzy shorthand for the idea that "maleness" is determined by the natural progression of certain biological processes. That those processes can rarely take a few unusual twists and turns to get to that phenotype doesn't invalidate the core idea.

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by epgui on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:41PM (#30795665)
It is not that simple, and I am not merely referring to Klinefelter syndrome. There are a myriad nuances.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by tablespoon on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:54PM (#30795799)
> ...and I am not merely referring to Klinefelter syndrome. There are a myriad nuances.

And I wasn't exclusively referring to it either. My point there's a legitimate idea there that isn't undermined by slight fuzziness or technical imprecision in layman definitions.

This isn't a perfect analogy, but Wikipedia has red as light with a wavelength of 625–750nm [1]. A lot of these discussions are a lot like trying to undermine the concept of red itself by noting that 624nm light exists.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visible_spectrum#Spectral_colo...

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by Ourgon on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:39PM (#30795063)
It is "that simple", those who suffer from Klinefelter syndrome are men. With modern fertility therapy some of them can impregnate women. You can try to complicate matters but this does not add veracity to such statements, it just shows that 'gender ideologues' will latch on to medical conditions in a search for legitimacy to the detriment of those who suffer from such conditions.

https://www.webmd.com/men/klinefelter-syndrome

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by eesmith on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:33PM (#30795587)
Quoting the linked-to SciAm article:

> According to the simple scenario, the presence or absence of a Y chromosome is what counts: with it, you are male, and without it, you are female. But doctors have long known that some people straddle the boundary—their sex chromosomes say one thing, but their gonads (ovaries or testes) or sexual anatomy say another. Parents of children with these kinds of conditions—known as intersex conditions, or differences or disorders of sex development (DSDs)—often face difficult decisions about whether to bring up their child as a boy or a girl. Some researchers now say that as many as 1 person in 100 has some form of DSD.

Nor is it only XXY which is the issue:

> For many years, scientists believed that female development was the default programme, and that male development was actively switched on by the presence of a particular gene on the Y chromosome. In 1990, researchers made headlines when they uncovered the identity of this gene, which they called SRY. Just by itself, this gene can switch the gonad from ovarian to testicular development. For example, XX individuals who carry a fragment of the Y chromosome that contains SRY develop as males. ...

> The gonad is not the only source of diversity in sex. A number of DSDs are caused by changes in the machinery that responds to hormonal signals from the gonads and other glands. Complete androgen insensitivity syndrome, or CAIS, for example, arises when a person's cells are deaf to male sex hormones, usually because the receptors that respond to the hormones are not working. People with CAIS have Y chromosomes and internal testes, but their external genitalia are female, and they develop as females at puberty.

Noting "But they are rare—affecting about 1 in 4,500 people." (The "some form of" is for a wide range of issues, like "surgeons reported that they had been operating on a hernia in a man, when they discovered that he had a womb. The man was 70, and had fathered four children.")

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by epgui on Thursday March 24, 2022 @05:43PM (#30795674)
I would encourage you to read the article I posted, because it barely has anything to do with Klinefelter syndrome. There are a myriad other nuances.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by Ourgon on Thursday March 24, 2022 @06:22PM (#30796118)
I see your one article by one activist and raise you the whole body of literature on sexually reproducing species, to be more specific of mammals - of which we are one - as written by non-activist biologists. I would encourage you to read some of it and enlighten yourself. Do you want some pointers?
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by epgui on Friday March 25, 2022 @02:07AM (#30799127)
Dunning-Kruger, exhibit A.

Respectfully, you're talking to a scientist, and as such I do have some passing familiarity with "the whole body of literature" or, perhaps more pertinently, the scientific consensus roughly speaking.

The article I shared, while an editorial, is representative of the scientific consensus. Not only that, but it is a reprint of an editorial (a well-referenced, well-cited, well-received and not particularly scientifically controversial one, mind you) which was first published in Nature [1], basically one of the most respected scientific journals: I just don't think it's reasonable for you, without doubt a non-expert, to dismiss it as an "activist" piece of rhetoric. The author is a perfectly respectable science journalist with a PhD in developmental biology, and no particular "activist" agenda. [2]

I don't have any skin in this game: I am a cisgendered heterosexual male, and I honestly don't care either way. I'm just a super curious guy who cares about edge cases, and how society accommodates (or possibly fails to accommodate) these edge cases. I don't know who you are, but you've taken your layman's "common sense" and gone on a mini comment crusade to try to persuade the world that things are simpler than they really are, and I also find that interesting.

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/518288a

[2] http://claireainsworth.com/about

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by Ourgon on Thursday March 24, 2022 @06:27PM (#30796172)
As a biologist, it is hard to understand how anyone could believe something so outlandish. It’s a belief on a par with the belief in a flat Earth. I first saw this claim being made this year by anthropology graduate students on Facebook. At first I thought they mistyped and were simply referring to gender. But as I began to pay closer attention, it was clear that they were indeed talking about biological sex. Over the next several months it became apparent that this view was not isolated to this small friend circle, as it began cropping up all over the Internet. In support of this view, recent editorials from Scientific American—an ostensibly trustworthy, scientific, and apolitical online magazine—are often referenced. The titles read, “Sex Redefined: The Idea of 2 Sexes Is Overly Simplistic,” and “Visualizing Sex as a Spectrum.”

Even more recently, the most prestigious scientific journal in the world, Nature, published an editorial claiming that classifying people’s sex “on the basis of anatomy or genetics should be abandoned” and “has no basis in science” and that “the research and medical community now sees sex as more complex than male and female.” In the Nature article, the motive is stated clearly enough: acknowledging the reality of biological sex will “undermine efforts to reduce discrimination against transgender people and those who do not fall into the binary categories of male or female.” But while there is evidence for the fluidity of sex in many organisms, this is simply not the case in humans. We can acknowledge the existence of very rare cases in humans where sex is ambiguous, but this does not negate the reality that sex in humans is functionally binary. These editorials are nothing more than a form of politically motivated, scientific sophistry.

The formula for each of these articles is straightforward. First, they list a multitude of intersex conditions. Second, they detail the genes, hormones, and complex developmental processes leading to these conditions. And, third and finally, they throw their hands up and insist this complexity means scientists have no clue what sex really is. This is all highly misleading and deceiving (self-deceiving?), since the developmental processes involved in creating any organ are enormously complex, yet almost always produce fully functional end products. Making a hand is complicated too, but the vast majority of us end up with the functional, five-fingered variety.

What these articles leave out is the fact that the final result of sex development in humans are unambiguously male or female over 99.98 percent of the time. Thus, the claim that “2 sexes is overly simplistic” is misleading, because intersex conditions correspond to less than 0.02 percent of all births, and intersex people are not a third sex. Intersex is simply a catch-all category for sex ambiguity and/or a mismatch between sex genotype and phenotype, regardless of its etiology. Furthermore, the claim that “sex is a spectrum” is also misleading, as a spectrum implies a continuous distribution, and maybe even an amodal one (one in which no specific outcome is more likely than others). Biological sex in humans, however, is clear-cut over 99.98 percent of the time. Lastly, the claim that classifying people’s sex based on anatomy and genetics “has no basis in science” has itself no basis in reality, as any method exhibiting a predictive accuracy of over 99.98 percent would place it among the most precise methods in all the life sciences. We revise medical care practices and change world economic plans on far lower confidence than that.

https://quillette.com/2018/11/30/the-new-evolution-deniers/

Written by an evolutionary biologist - one of the many who speak up in reaction to gender ideology.

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by netizen-936824 on Saturday March 26, 2022 @06:26AM (#30810662)
Sex and gender are different concepts. Full stop.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by emilyst on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:50PM (#30794564)
Do you know you don't have a Y chromosome? Did you check?
[dead]
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by emilyst on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:40PM (#30795075)
I think your comment was directed to the wrong person.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by lowmagnet on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:44PM (#30795109)
XXY XXXY XYY XO

ffs

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by dwaltrip on Thursday March 24, 2022 @06:04PM (#30795928)
What's your basis for claiming expertise on what makes someone a woman?

Do you possess full knowledge of how sex and sex-specific behaviors evolved over millions of years and all of the resulting complexity?

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by xdennis on Thursday March 24, 2022 @08:21PM (#30797309)
In 99.9 % of the cases you can tell women and men apart in a fraction of a second. We can identify sex from the bones of million-year-old humanoids. For the burka-dressed robbers we could identify they were men just by their gait.

You're trying to make it seem like the 0.1 % means we can't know anything about anything.

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by dwaltrip on Thursday March 24, 2022 @08:30PM (#30797388)
Perhaps I can summarize my position more clearly:

1) We've fucked up in this area before (e.g. being gay was considered a medical disorder), so let's be really careful to not fuck it up again.

2) Humans are vastly complicated systems and our understanding has grown immensely in recent centuries. So arguments like "aspect X of the human experience has always been understood this way" should be taken with a huge grain of salt, especially when people are making scientific claims (e.g. in this case, about biology / psychology).

3) Unless if I have a good reason not too, take people at face value. Treat them with respect. Make small concessions even if I don't fully understand why they want it. It doesn't cost me much, and it makes them happy.

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by water8 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @10:44PM (#30798130)
The problem is that we’re treating personal discoveries like they are universally applicable. Always treat people with respect, but don’t allow pseudoscience to propagate just because you dont want to hurt their feelings. I’ve been through enough coding interviews to know that y’all don’t care that much about hurting peoples feelings =P
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by zen_1 on Friday March 25, 2022 @12:22AM (#30798629)
"Unless if I have a good reason not too, take people at face value."

I disagree with this. Or rather, I think there are always a plethora of good reasons not to take people (that you don't already know well and trust) at face value.

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by gaganyaan on Thursday March 24, 2022 @09:55PM (#30797881)
Saying "people have made mistakes before" and "it's complicated" is just... not a convincing argument. You can literally do that with any topic anywhere.
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by hitpointdrew on Thursday March 24, 2022 @06:54PM (#30796487)
No one needs to be an “expert” to understand basic English and biology. It’s very clear that until, very recently, male and female have always been biological terms. Even today a scientist studying a frog would call the frog “female” or “male”, and everyone would know what they mean by that. No educated, sane, person would protest “Did you ask the frog what gender they felt they were!”
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by dwaltrip on Thursday March 24, 2022 @07:45PM (#30796993)
Historical precedent is not a very strong argument when it comes to scientific questions.

What's the model? How can that model explain the observed phenomena? "XY = male and XX = female" is a very simplistic model and it doesn't seem to adequately explain everything that we see in the world. Perhaps it works for 97% of the cases (just guessing).

We can do better than 97%. Let's work on finding a model that explains the world more accurately.

P.S. Frogs can't talk :P So yeah, it would be rather silly to try asking it a question.

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by hitpointdrew on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:33PM (#30798372)
What is the model you ask? It’s very simple XX chromosome is female, XY is male.

Is that 100% of all cases ever. No, but hardly anything at all in science, or life, is. How do you classify a hermaphrodite? Does it matter? It’s a rare biological anomaly. Life is weird and strange things happen sometimes, that doesn’t mean that you throw the baby out with the bath water. It’s useful in life, science, and medicine to classify things biologically by their sex. If there are a few outliers that just go in “other” then so be it.

> Frogs can’t talk

That’s the whole point. How a frog feels, or perceives itself, is entirely irrelevant as to weather it is classified as a male or female. So why is it any different with humans? When we talk about male or female with other species there is no notion of a “social construct”, but somehow when talk about humans it’s supposed be different and not follow the rules we use with every other species on the planet? Why? Because some people feel bad? Sorry, not a good argument.

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by netizen-936824 on Saturday March 26, 2022 @06:29AM (#30810680)
>with other species there is no notion of a “social construct”

That's only coming from our limited human perspectives. We can't communicate with another species at this point in time. We can't ask them about nuance in their social structures. We also can't assume that it doesn't exist because it's hard to observe.

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by hitpointdrew on Saturday March 26, 2022 @09:22PM (#30816884)
Nothing you said refutes the fact that biological sex classification is 1) useful 2) has and continues to use the terms “male” and “female” for all species 3) such classification are scientific descriptions, not social constructs at all.

Are there traditional gender roles that are social constructs? Sure. Is gender itself a social construct, not even remotely. Reproduction is quite well documented and known, it isn’t some abstract thing that society made up.

Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by netizen-936824 on Saturday March 26, 2022 @11:31PM (#30817483)
I'm sorry I don't quite follow. Which part of my comment are you replying to?
Re:The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism (... by pcmoney on Thursday March 24, 2022 @11:40PM (#30798406)
If we are claiming that biological sex and gender are different than what makes someone a woman goes beyond biology/evolution. If we are claiming that gender is socially constructed then gender dysphoria is a spectrum which we are all probably on as nobody aligns perfectly with all the gender norms in their society.

But if it is constructed and everything is on a spectrum then what are we even arguing about?