News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Developers of small modular reactors hope their time has ... by robertlagrant on Thursday March 24, 2022 @12:03PM (#30791757)
Did you understand what I was saying?
Re:Developers of small modular reactors hope their time has ... by hutzlibu on Thursday March 24, 2022 @12:43PM (#30792324)
Not sure. First I thought you did sarcasm, but it seems, you are actually serious.

Well then, when you have lots of solar and wind fields, then it doesn't matter too much, if one gets destroyed. But even those you can defend, even with your own troops, by making adequate contracts.

On the other hand, if you have to rely on nuclear - then a potentiell enemy only needs to target those and you are screwed in many ways. It would be not too hard, for a dedicated commando to blow up, or at least render useless, a nuclear reactor with enough preparation.

But when you are only thinking in military terms: the hard parts to defend with dessert power are the power cabels. But they are also an essential part of nuclear plants and you cannot defend the whole grid.

Re:Developers of small modular reactors hope their time has ... by robertlagrant on Thursday March 24, 2022 @02:26PM (#30793608)
Er no, wasn't being sarcastic. My point was that importing solar power from North Africa means you're less in control in the event of a conflict.

Your point about cabling is equally valid.

Your point about nuclear less so. I'm more comparing locally generated power, where your power generation can be covered by your own defences, with remotely generated power, which can't.

Re:Developers of small modular reactors hope their time has ... by hutzlibu on Thursday March 24, 2022 @06:36PM (#30796291)
" But even those you can defend, even with your own troops, by making adequate contracts."

Making a deal with the moroccean government, would include their troops defending the investment, or could be modified to include own troops.

But like I also said above, the south of europe has plenty of sun, too.

Re:Developers of small modular reactors hope their time has ... by robertlagrant on Friday March 25, 2022 @08:14AM (#30801169)
If this is priced into the cost of the solar, then fair enough, although to bring this particular risk down to what it would be if the generation were in one's own borders would I think be prohibitively expensive, or impossible.