News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by tptacek on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @05:50PM (#3077782)
I use Rdio all day, 50/50 web and desktop (and desktop is just an Air wrapper around web), and I like it better than iTunes (which I like a lot). It's very responsive. The browser actually contributes the experience (history, back button). What am I missing here? I'm not convinced that the web isn't already the best place to build a music streaming application.
Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by pxlpshr on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @07:09PM (#3078024)
In all fairness, that was written in August of 2009... 2 years is quite a long time for browsers to improve their script engines. I'm certain you're also running the latest Safari/Chrome/FF whereas many of my friends and family still are not.
Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by dotBen on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @07:36PM (#3078098)
Parker's point you missed with native apps is "grey" music files existing locally on the user's computer.

They could be completely pirated/illegal but as a player that isn't your liability - yet you can provide functionality (playing), gleam usage information, meta data and of course still monetize/advertise over the top of the user playing their own songs.

You can't do that with web-apps (EDIT: unless you run a locker service, which is beyond scope of this)

Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by tptacek on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @07:42PM (#3078133)
I'm narrowly interested in Parker's observations about responsiveness and UX, which I think are unfounded; I think a web app is a better user interface than most desktop players.

I subscribe to Rdio for the value proposition of "I'm not going to buy more music, I'm just going to use this thingy to get it", so the notion of what files are on my hard disk is moot. I'm sure there's some independent dubstep artist who is Very Important to you that exists on no subscription service, but I assure you that my use case represents the mainstream: the fact that I even care about how much of Pitchfork's "Best New Music" is on Rdio already sets me far apart from the Lil Wayne fans that make up most of the market.

Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by pbreit on Thursday October 06, 2011 @02:30AM (#3079272)
I hear you. The Rdio and Mog web interfaces are stunning...in many ways better than iTunes and Spotify. But I still feel there is an impermanence or fleeting feel to a web site when it comes to a music player.

And I do think incorporation of the unclouded content is a bona fide advantage.

Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by jmtulloss on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @06:10PM (#3077842)
Minor nitpick: the Air app has been deprecated, the desktop app is a native app wrapped around the web site. It also allows downloading purchases and matching your iTunes collection.
Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by jonah on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @11:50PM (#3078944)
Minor detail: The Air app is still available and may work as a desktop solution on Linux.

http://www.rdio.com/#/apps/air/

(I personally love rdio and am completely confused by spotify.)

Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by chrischen on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @07:17PM (#3078045)
Matching iTunes collection only matches songs which are also available in Rdio's catalog. Everything else you'll still have to open up iTunes to play, and you can't even mix and match.
Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by tptacek on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @07:25PM (#3078062)
You sound surprised. How could that feature work otherwise?
Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by chrischen on Sunday October 09, 2011 @03:31AM (#3089928)
Well in spotify your itunes music is imported into the spotify player.
Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by bennesvig on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @07:11PM (#3078030)
The social aspects of Rdio are what I love a lot. The ability to follow people, view and subscribe to their playlists, collaborate on playlists, etc.

All of that makes for a better overall music experience, especially for people always on the search for new music.

Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by russell_h on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @06:00PM (#3077813)
Do you know how the availability of content on Rdio compares to Spotify?
Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by shuzchen on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @06:14PM (#3077861)
I've encountered different stories about the availability of content, but I think it really boils down to what sort of music you listen to. Personally, I find Spotify has more of the things that I listen to - but like I said I've talked with friends (that have different taste in music) that claim the same about another service.

That said, I think everyone I've talked to agrees Grooveshark has the best coverage, but everything there is so disorganized (and nobody is really sure of the legality).

Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by elektronaut on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @06:25PM (#3077898)
Grooveshark is legal (AFAIK), but their business model is somewhat sketchy. Content is peer-to-peer sourced, and if you don't want your music on Grooveshark, you'll have to file a DMCA infringement claim.
Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by ktusznio on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @06:10PM (#3077844)
Re:Sean Parker's Email to Daniek Ek of Spotify by ralphc on Wednesday October 05, 2011 @08:47PM (#3078457)
I'd agree with that, I especially found with metal that Spotify has a larger selection.