Not entirely. Here's another article:
https://nltimes.nl/2022/03/22/historians-contradict-findings...
Accusing someone's grandparent of a heinous crime to sell a book is a bit different, and, well, I mean, nothing's stopping you doing it, it's _legal_, but unless you can prove it (as they appear to have failed to), people aren't going to be too thrilled about it.
Like, this wasn't a sober academic paper, it was a mass-market pop-history book.
[Edit] I don't mean you, rsynnott.
My father fought for the British Army in Malaya. I'm not campaigning for the suppression of information about the crimes the brits committed there.
Among my ancestors are people who were in the cotton business, in Liverpool; the ships went from Liverpool (manufactured goods) to the Gold Coast of Africa (sell goods, pick up slaves) to American colonies (sell slaves, buy cotton), and back to Liverpool. I'm not campaigning to block that information either.
No, historians are not there to speculate, make up stuff and then act overconfident.
- Now a new report by a team of World War Two experts and historians has said its research does not stand up to scrutiny.
And then: - The new report into the book contradicted its findings, calling its work "amateurish".
- "There is not any serious evidence for this grave accusation," the experts found.
So, maybe the question is, what motivates people to cherry pick one sentence out of that article and then lie about nature of complains?Perhaps the BBC article is just really badly written.
This seems like it is less about concerns about whether the book is true, and more that people did not want the theory to be true.
I find this trend of conflating the two very problematic.
And to be honest, even if Anne Frank was betrayed by a Jewish man to save his own family, it in no way makes the Holocaust any less horrific and in no way excuses any of the guilt of the Nazis. I think it actually makes it more tragic in that people were faced with ethical and moral choices they should never have been faced with. (Having to decide between the lives of strangers and the lives of your family is a horrendous choice)