News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Anne Frank betrayal book pulled after findings discredited by PHGamer on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @07:02AM (#30777155)
no. nothing should be ever free from questioning. else things get distorted or exaggerated over time.

It would have been enough imo if the book just had a forward that noted some of it was conjecture based on whatever info they had. No one can truly know as I imagine there was either no documentation or it got destroyed in whatever allied bombing happened.

also blaming white people for shirking responsibility is a bit rich given that term encompasses a lot of nationalities including the British and Americans who fought against the Germans who were the ones doing the geocoding.

Re:Anne Frank betrayal book pulled after findings discredited by watwut on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @09:20AM (#30778161)
> It would have been enough imo if the book just had a forward that noted some of it was conjecture based on whatever info they had.

No, it would not be enough. It would be enough if the text of the book itself expressed a lot of uncertainty around facts that are uncertain. Not just CYA in forward and then writing it all confident and convincing to those who did not went through massive amount of work it takes to verify it all.

Re:Anne Frank betrayal book pulled after findings discredited by mcphage on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @07:58AM (#30777525)
> nothing should be ever free from questioning

Nothing should be free of questioning, but I don't think a major publisher has much interest in publishing a book whose research has been discredited. That's just basic common sense—just like (most) people don't go around repeating things that they know to be false. Except for things like Santa Claus, I guess.

Re:Anne Frank betrayal book pulled after findings discredited by sodonotaskis on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @07:32AM (#30777363)
If: 'no. nothing should be ever free from questioning.'

Than: "It may be 'Sympathic, a pianoplayer appears playing in pantofles' for some, but others may..."

was listening to > hint://youtu.be/GLujhLBZdPg?t=188

P-:

Re:Anne Frank betrayal book pulled after findings discredited by validuser on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @06:49AM (#30777074)
That was sarcasm, right?
Re:Anne Frank betrayal book pulled after findings discredited by jhoechtl on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @06:53AM (#30777103)
I think well-crafted sarcasm is one which cannot be judged as such.

If the OP doesn't respond my bet is yes.

Re:Anne Frank betrayal book pulled after findings discredited by kergonath on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @07:30AM (#30777346)
It’s way too close to some narratives that are pushed in nominally-liberal but actually quite regressive parts of western societies (how can you pretend to be progressive when you’re arguing that truth is secondary if it makes some people feel bad?)

It’s like Nazi edgelords. If your sarcasm is indistinguishable from propaganda, then either you’re very bad at it, or you’re using “free speech” as a cover because you know your opinions are not acceptable. In either case, these posts do not belong in a civilised discussion.

Re:Anne Frank betrayal book pulled after findings discredited by a_imho on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @08:12AM (#30777617)
not agreeing with the parent, but if that is not the main use case of free speech then what is? Stating things others might consider inconvenient, disrespectful or outright unacceptable. Indeed, if one is serious about freedom of speech they will find themselves defending the rights of all kinds of extremists, it is inevitable.