News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by ouid on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @10:02PM (#30774014)
I don't know really how to argue this here, but there is no such thing as a switch. It's a general purpose computer, implemented on a very specific set of hardware, restricted in its use by software whose only purpose is to maintain the illusion that a switch is a thing.
Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by haswell on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @12:20AM (#30774912)
Do these things not exist?

- My LG Smart TV

- A TI-84 calculator

- The Peloton (exercise equipment)

Are you trying to argue that because the Switch uses components also used to build general purpose devices that this somehow implies some kind of general purpose “identity” on all derivative devices and an expectation that somehow every product should be more clear that “well actually, this product doesn’t exist because it has a CPU and a screen”?

I’m truly grasping trying to understand your argument here.

Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by ouid on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @02:36AM (#30775636)
The switch runs extremely general software. Drawing a parallel between it and a ti84 is extremely disingenuous.

The smart TV is basically just a worse version of a monitor with a very cheap computer attached.

The peloton is a BIKE.

Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by haswell on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @10:08AM (#30778603)
> The switch runs extremely general software. Drawing a parallel between it and a ti84 is extremely disingenuous.

I specifically mentioned the TI-84 because I have played Mario on mine, among many other things that it was not intended for. Respectfully, it belongs on the list.

But you still haven’t answered my question. Do these products not exist?

> The peloton is a BIKE

The Peloton is also a product, and a product that uses a general purpose OS (Android) and general purpose screen. It’s still built to do one thing.

It’s not just a bike - I have three of those, and none of them have a screen, and I can ride them outside.

The point here is that products are real things, have specific purposes, and often use general purpose tech to achieve a very specific outcome.

Is it cool to run Mario on my TI-84? Yes! But I wouldn’t be bent out of shape if I couldn’t.

Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by ouid on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @02:06PM (#30781427)
Ok, but you should be a little bent out of shape that your PC can't run switch games.
Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by haswell on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @03:15PM (#30782151)
Why?

Should I be bent out of shape that not every native Mac app has a Windows/PC counterpart? Or vice versa?

Setting that aside, personally, I have no desire to play Switch games on my PC. The Switch is the best device for playing Switch games. Does that imply some kind of moral failing on my part?

If you have philosophical issues with console gaming in general, that's one thing. But then this becomes a conversation about something else entirely.

I'm still curious about why you continue to sidestep the question. This conversation is no longer moving forward.

Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by saagarjha on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @04:21AM (#30776235)
TI-84 can be rooted to do pretty much whatever you want. Not sure about the other two.
Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by haswell on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @10:38AM (#30778885)
Exactly! It’s also still a TI-84 calculator.
Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by kiratp on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @10:24PM (#30774140)
If we are arguing “it’s a Turing Machine!” Then you could argue that WiFi light bulbs are

> implemented on a very specific set of hardware, restricted in its use by software whose only purpose is to maintain the illusion

Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by norvvryo on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @11:32PM (#30774607)
The Switch has a 720p touchscreen display, a reasonably powerful CPU, and 4GB of RAM. It's not fair to compare that to the specialized embedded hardware in a light bulb.
Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by haswell on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @12:09AM (#30774843)
Do those characteristics somehow automatically equate to some expectation about the hackability of the device? Must hardware creators cater to a niche part of their user base just because they use those components?

Don’t get me wrong. I like to tinker, and I’ve had plenty of fun using hardware for unintended use cases. But I don’t understand the seeming entitlement that some feel that Nintendo is not worthy of their purchase.

Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by norvvryo on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @12:47AM (#30775059)
In a vacuum, allowing for hackability is easier than building a walled garden. Locking a device down requires hardware and software to be developed that would otherwise be unnecessary. From that perspective, it's understandable that some people feel entitled to be able to use the hardware they paid for in whatever way they please.

Of course, in the real world, hardware like the Switch is subsidized by publishing fees and the like. I imagine that that revenue must outweigh the R&D costs of gimping the device.

Re:Nintendo Switch prevents downgrades by irreparably blowin... by ouid on Wednesday March 23, 2022 @03:06AM (#30775806)
Fortunately, I wasn't arguing "it's a turing machine". I'm arguing that a switch is a quite powerful computer that has been crippled by its software to do less. Much less. The result of this is the thing that you think of as a switch, but "being a switch" is not fundamentally different from being banned from a particular bar, or being allergic to peanuts, as a descriptor.