From Apple's previous statement on this matter: "While the current draft patent policy does state a “preference” for royalty-free standards, the ready availability of a RAND option presents too easy an alternative for owners of intellectual property who may seek to use the standardization process to control access to fundamental Web standards. A mandatory royalty-free requirement for all adopted standards will avoid this result."
If Samsung has granted a license(either with royalties or royalty-free) to everyone else besides Apple, they aren't following the FRAND standard. If they have, and this is a result of negotiations falling apart(which is highly unlikely, considering that these are "essential to the reliable functioning of telecom networks and devices", and the iPhone 1 presumably infringes on these), then Samsung has a case.
Otherwise, Samsung may be violating agreements that they have with the standards agencies. This will be pretty interesting how it plays out.
See http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2011/oct/05/samsung-app... for more info.
CDMA is a superset of that, apparently, and can also apply with certain GSM providers.
And yes, Apple was wrong to have shot first.
Apple shot first in the mobile industry the same way Greedo did.
http://news.cnet.com/8301-27076_3-20073471-248/a-brief-histo...
previously on HN:
"broad detente in the industry"
I call shenanigans.
Your stuff is right there, I parsed the quote I originally responded to that made it clear you were very clearly not originally talking about a specific case -- a "broad detente in the industry" that Apple was the first to violate. Saying after the fact that you were only talking about Samsung is moving the goalposts. Maybe we don't disagree there but I'm hardly wrong for pointing out what I did when I did.
"You think either of those is a good thing?"
I think Nokia had many innovations that Apple infringed on and Apple probably deserved to be sued by Nokia and they paid up. I certainly don't remember anyone crying about how Nokia started "high stakes asshattery" in that case. Apparently it's only when Android vendors are the target of lawsuits that people get up in arms.
I think Samsung comes very close to if not crossing the line of infringement and Apple has the right to test that in court. You call this "high stakes asshattery" but you can just as easily make the case that Samsung is the asshat for blatant copying.
I think Samsung (like Nokia) has many technologies that Apple may infringe on. Based on limited evidence we've seen it's not as compelling as Nokia's but they have the right to test this in court or leverage it for a settlement or whatever.
Florian Mueller makes a reasonable case that Samsung is trying to assert a very different kind of patent in a highly unusual way - http://fosspatents.blogspot.com/2011/10/samsungs-attempt-to-.... TLDR: these kind of patents fall under the FRAND (fair reasonable non-discriminatory framework) and Samsung is obligated to grant them to anyone ("non-discriminatory") that wants them for a "reasonable" fee. To press an injunction without any arbitration violates the basic spirit of FRAND. Agree with their case or not, Apple's patents in question do not have these restrictions.