News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by PaulKeeble on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @07:09AM (#30697388)
There were quite a few protests in the UK last year against the lockdowns, despite the fact there was no lockdown at the time or planned (nor did it happen) in the future. Quite a few cults seem to go past their doomsday date and simply choose another into the future. They just carry on as if the lack of the event never happened.
Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by dustinmoris on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @07:21AM (#30697461)
Those protests happened because new lockdowns were introduced in the EU at that time and the Labour party was calling for harsher restrictions again despite all evidence from South Africa suggesting that Omicron is nothing but a super mild cold and people already being double jabbed anyway. People were terrified of another lockdown and that is why they went protesting to offer a counter voice to opposition party MPs who tried to instil another wave of fear.

I never went to any protest, not just this but in general, but I was very pleased that there were huge protests in the UK and elsewhere at that time, because I had enough of restricting my own life for the sake of others.

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by creativenolo on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @07:33AM (#30697542)
> all evidence from South Africa suggesting that Omicron is nothing but a super mild cold

I get your point. And the UK didn't lockdown. But this statement is a stretch.

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by kennyadam on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @07:32AM (#30697537)
As long as you realise just how selfish your last sentence is. Presumably you never expect anyone to even help you out at any cost to themselves, no matter how small?
Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by dustinmoris on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @07:37AM (#30697567)
I expect my family and friends to help me out. I don't expect the entire world around me to dance to my tune because of a fear I hold. When I was 10 years old nobody stopped smoking around me in indoor places, so now the same people who smoked all their life and ate themselves obese are afraid of my fresh super healthy fit breath? Sorry, not my problem and I honestly couldn't care less. On my list of priorities that is as far down as it could possibly be. And I don't think I'm selfish, I'm human. Everyone is selfish. It's selfish of those people to demand huge sacrifices on healthy young folks because of their own shortcomings. I'm happy to take a vaccines, which I did 3x against COVID, because it has no impact on my life, if anything it helps me, but I am not going to restrict my freedoms and lock myself at home, stop working, stop seeing family and friends and stop living life because of others.
Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by tomgp on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @07:49AM (#30697624)
Wow! We're talking about wearing a face mask for a short amount of time in very specific situations here, a tiny inconvenience which has proven benefits for a broad swathe of the population (not just the old). No one's asking you to lock yourself at home and not see friends and family. Wearing a mask on a plane is going to reduce the chances of those more stringent measures being put back on the table.

Also, not everyone is selfish, you're projecting the way you see the world onto other people.

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by brigandish on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @10:47AM (#30699492)
> proven benefits

Why did the DANMASK RCT fail so spectacularly?

> Also, not everyone is selfish, you're projecting the way you see the world onto other people.

Uncalled for. You might consider that to impose your views on others could easily be considered far more selfish than someone unwilling to participate in an activity, even one with such unimpeachable, proven benefits.

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by goto11 on Thursday March 17, 2022 @04:53AM (#30708982)
> Why did the DANMASK RCT fail so spectacularly?

Because it had too few participants, or happened when the overall infection rate in society was too low. The number of infected in both groups were too small to conclude anything confidently.

If I remember correctly the group without masks were infected about 20% more than the group with masks, but since the absolute numbers were too low is could have been due to random chance.

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by brigandish on Thursday March 17, 2022 @07:24AM (#30709869)
> Because it had too few participants

From the study[1]:

> A total of 3030 participants were randomly assigned to the recommendation to wear masks, and 2994 were assigned to control; 4862 completed the study.

That's more than enough people.

> or happened when the overall infection rate in society was too low

The study was conducted in April and May of 2020, there were clearly enough infectious people in the population[2] to warrant the study showing some importance.

> The number of infected in both groups were too small to conclude anything confidently.

From the study:

> Infection with SARS-CoV-2 occurred in 42 participants recommended masks (1.8%) and 53 control participants (2.1%)

> Although the difference observed was not statistically significant, the 95% CIs are compatible with a 46% reduction to a 23% increase in infection.

Don't you think it's strange that proven benefits are so hard to substantiate in a randomised controlled trial? These proven benefits can't be proven or shown to be beneficial across thousands of people, during a pandemic?

That's not going to fly with me, especially since every other RCT done on masks prior to the pandemic failed to show efficacy against influenza, even in clinical environments.

Maybe we could rerun the study now, while the highly infectious Omicron variant is running rampant, which apparently masks and vaccines are rubbish at preventing.

It's almost as if the proven benefits aren't proven and hence, not benefits.

Forgive the sarcasm but if people want to make bold claims then I suggest I may be able to poke holes in their case by mocking it, as I would with people knocking on my door claiming the apocalypse is nigh, or those telling me to change my behaviour because of whatever other pie in the sky belief they hold. When they come back with the RCT that shows the efficacy of masks - something, I might add, that should be possible in a pandemic - then there'll be something to discuss. Otherwise, the criticisms of the study, which weren't given before it was published I might add, are all quibbles.

[1] https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M20-6817]

[2] https://ourworldindata.org/explorers/coronavirus-data-explor...

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by goto11 on Thursday March 17, 2022 @08:16AM (#30710294)
Sorry, I'm not sure I understand what you are arguing. Are you saying the result was statistically significant?
Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by brigandish on Thursday March 17, 2022 @01:11PM (#30713455)
Statistical significance relies on more than just the number of participants, but if you want me to make my argument more simple for you, I can:

When making bold claims, the claimant should provide evidence for those claims. Supply me with the RCT that proves the benefit of wearing masks.

Do you have it?

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by usedtoprog on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:54PM (#30703245)
The absence of proven benefits is the issue. It is unscientific to mandate behaviour without proven benefit.

The issue for me, and I'm reading it in a lot of these comments is that there is no endgame. The times I've been asked "where is your mask?" I've never had an empirical answer to "when does it stop?"

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by brigandish on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @07:39AM (#30697574)
> despite the fact there was no lockdown at the time or planned (nor did it happen) in the future

Did you not consider the possibility that the government bowed to pressure, such as the protests, and didn't lockdown?

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by hughrr on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @07:15AM (#30697431)
My aunt is one of that lot. She basically lives a completely normal, boring and uninteresting life (lucky woman!). The old idiom "The devil finds work for idle hands" may apply.
Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by hihihihi1234 on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @09:22AM (#30698461)
Have people already forgotten how much pressure the government was under in December to lock us down again? SAGE were predicting 6000 deaths a day, as if their modelling hadn't already been discredited ten times over, and all the usual suspects in the media and the Labour Party were screaming for more restrictions. If it hadn't been for partygate, the backbench Tory rebellion, and massive public resistance in the form of protests and more, Boris would have caved to SAGE and we'd have had another two months of our lives stolen, another Christmas ruined, another term of school missed, another million livelihoods destroyed and another ten billion added to the public debt - and it would have all been completely unnecessary, because Omicron was a fat load of nothing and SAGE's modelling turned out to be wrong yet again. But people would have pointed to the low death rate and said "I told you lockdown was necessary! If we hadn't locked down we would be seeing 6000 deaths a day!"

Also, these protests werent just against lockdown. There were enormous protests against vaccine passports, and they were successful - the govt had vaxpasses ready to go in the summer and pushed them back repeatedly before cancelling them in the face of public pressure and tireless campaigning from civil liberties groups like Big Brother Watch. If it hadn't been for the protests then you wouldnt have been able to go to Sainsbury's in the last six months without scanning your QR code.

Finally, there were also protests against vaccine mandates, and in particular the vaccine mandate for NHS staff. Personally I found those protests silly - I would have thought that NHS workers of all people would understand the importance of getting vaccinated, but the facts are that the government initially announced that NHS workers would be fired if they didn't get the jab then walked this back when it became clear that enforcing this rule would mean firing tens of thousands of intransigent NHS staff and they couldn't afford the shortages. There was a gigantic protest in London in January against the NHS vax mandate (not that you'd have heard about it on the news) - a protest which unequivocally achieved its goal.

If you don't think people were protesting against anything real or that the protests didn't achieve anything then you haven't been paying attention.

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by thinkingemote on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:02AM (#30699667)
About the NHS. I also thought that healthcare workers would most understand be behind vaccines. However an employment expert told me that healthcare workers are basically low paid workers, often from minority backgrounds, the exact same demographic that are vaccine hesitant. The vast majority of NHS staff are not doctors.

It was, therefore a class / social / demographic issue, but there is indeed crossover with the foreign healthcare worker but its on that class rather than where they come from.

I think (but I didnt discuss it with the expert) that the doctors themselves were on the whole opposed to compulsory mandates for ethical reasons. E.g. first do no harm extends to respecting a persons conscience.

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by hihihihi1234 on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:19AM (#30699865)
Yeah I've wondered the same thing. I don't have the statistics in front of me but I'm pretty sure that the unvaccinated are on average poorer, browner and more working class than the vaccinated. Which is to say that the same people who don't trust the jabs are generally the same people who have longstanding reasons to distrust a wider society that's weighted against them.

It's easy for me, as an affluent middle-class white guy, to say "shut up and do what you're told because the experts know best" - but on some level I really can't blame people from less advantaged demographics for being so distrustful of the "experts". After all, it's not like the governments and corporations pushing these vaccines have always worked in the working class's favour in the past.

To be clear, I believe that the vaccines are safe and effective and that everyone should get jabbed. But I can't help but feel like all this demonisation of the unvaccinated is driven at least partly by good old fashioned snobbery and class hatred. "How dare these lower class inferiors not do as we say? Why can't they be smart and sensible like us, the wealthy enlightened?"

Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by mbg721 on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:12AM (#30699778)
Another possibility is that healthcare workers see how the sausage is made and have less faith in medical advice in general than the average citizen does.
Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by hihihihi1234 on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:21AM (#30699898)
Well as a programmer I've seen how the sausage is made in the tech industry, and thus have less faith in the security and reliability of software than the average citizen does. So what you say could make sense.
Re:Masks on planes requirement dropped by some UK airlines by brigandish on Thursday March 17, 2022 @02:42AM (#30708317)
That would ignore the many experts who were among them who also took issue. For example, NHS infectious diseases consultant, Simon Fox[1]:

> I can't support the mandating of vaccines in this scenario

He goes on:

> If you want to mandate people to have vaccines you have a moral duty to provide evidence that it's necessary, and now the evidence isn't just lacking that it's necessary, but the evidence that is now coming out is demonstrating that it doesn't help reduce transmission from healthcare workers.

Intensive care consultant Milena Chee[2]:

> What I’m against is the vaccination status to be tied to employment rights. I’m against the language of hatred, which is rampant. We are supposed to be such a tolerant society, but all of a sudden have become the complete opposite.

Professor of oncology at St George's and infectious diseases expert (notably, HIV, which has similarities to COVID-19), Angus Dalgleish:

> I think it is absolute madness to have a mandate for everyone to be vaccinated at this stage… The people who are not vaccinated have all given very good reasons.

> Just do an antibody and a T-cell test. If you did that in large numbers it would be cheaper than giving everybody a booster

He goes into more detail[3] which you may enjoy if you're interested in the immune system.

Dr Tony Hinton, retired consultant surgeon on the mandate[4]:

> It makes no logical or scientific sense whatsoever

> Many of the people I speak to have had their 2 jabs but do not want to take a booster.

From NHS100k's open letter to the government[5]:

> We as a collection of professionals pride ourselves on our ability to critically analyse fact based, evidence-based, and science-based information to apply in our practice.

> 1. Emerging scientific evidence that is contrary to the narrative of mandatory vaccinations:

> We point to the work of Dr. Gunter Kampf of the University of Greifswald published in The Lancet Regional Health Europe on 19 November 2021. In this published article Dr. Kampf pointed out: ‘It appears to be grossly negligent to ignore the vaccinated population as a possible and relevant source of transmission’.

> Weekly reports from the UK Health Security Agency3 consistently show that among adults, the number of cases of Covid 19 in vaccinated population greatly outnumbers that of the unvaccinated population since the rollout of the vaccine programme. We point to the work of Singanayagam et al published on 29 October 2021 in The Lancet Infectious Diseases which showed that people with breakthrough infections have the same viral load regardless of vaccination status. It further adds that regardless of vaccination status the rate of spread from an infected person is the same among household contacts.

> This is not an exhaustive list however we are highlighting these articles as examples to cast reasonable doubt on the assertions made by the Secretary of State, Sajid Javid. Mr Javid declared that our ‘Duty of Care’ towards our patients could only be discharged through the act of inoculating our bodies with a product, that there is now growing evidence of it being inadequate in preventing the transmission of this virus.

The letter is actually damning of the kind of narrative the mainstream media, along with the government, has fed the public. The letter to Chris Witty is similarly damning[6].

Lilith, a paramedic and founder of NHS100k[7]:

> What we're concerned about is the precedent it will set. If you can mandate these vaccines for the NHS, when will it start occurring to the public. When does our health become our choice or when does it become the government's choice? We're very much ralliers for the right to choose. It's such a core issue for healthcare professionals where we must respect patients' decisions

Mr Ahmad Malik, consultant orthopaedic surgeon[7]:

> On one hand we've got mandates and on the other hand we've got freedom, personal freedom, bodily autonomy, informed consent. If you think you can have both, you're gravely mistaken, because they're the exact opposite.

> [Consent] is the cornerstone of medical ethics. Having the ability to choose what's done to your body or what's not done to your body is something we've taken for granted for centuries.

> If we have this mandatary vaccination coming through, that's earthshattering, that demolishes that whole concept of personal bodily autonomy and we're opening a Pandora's box.

They underline your last paragraph, but I think your employment expert needs to familiarise himself with the actual people opposing this instead of making hasty generalisations that act as easy dismissals of a view that may by sincerely held by well educated people.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRApq2IRqn4

[2] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/health-fitness/body/nhs-medics-p...

[3] https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=1367946743636118

[4] https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=274024381492297

[5] https://nhs100k.com/Resources/Static/NHS100k%20CEO%20Letter....

[6] https://nhs100k.com/Resources/Static/Letter%20to%20Chris%20W...

[7] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XGY7s8avhw