News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Plasticity Is CAD for Artists by danboarder on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @12:41AM (#30695393)
I find this to be a very cool NURBS-based CAD project, can't wait to play with it more. From what I can see it borrows a lot of concepts from solid modeling CAD tools like Solidworks, but also has UX similarities to other common surface modeling tools like Blender. Here is a video of how it works:

Plasticity - Fresh NURBS Modeler for Everyone! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l16YkZnT5zM

Re:Plasticity Is CAD for Artists by hnarayanan on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @02:26AM (#30695903)
This is really cool, both in terms of what it can do, the approachable pricing model and the video that shows it off.

(Since I’m not aware of the details…) Is this similar to using NURBS as the representation in Blender?

As in what makes this more CAD-ey?

Re:Plasticity Is CAD for Artists by semi-extrinsic on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:31AM (#30696200)
Blender as a tool is very far from CAD-ey, in the sense that precision work - this should be 120 mm and that should be 1.41 times this - is not really a supported workflow. There isn't even a constraint solver in Blender.

You can make Blender work as a CAD-ish tool with practice and self-discipline and lots of keyboard shortcuts. But e.g. Fusion360 or even SketchUp is what a CAD-oriented workflow feels like. There is a big difference.

Haven't tried this yet, but I expect it to retain enough of the CAD-oriented approach that the workflow still feels quite different from Blender.

Re:Plasticity Is CAD for Artists by ur-whale on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:49AM (#30696312)
> There isn't even a constraint solver in Blender.

Not 100% correct. There are a number of add-ons that do this. I even think someone managed to hook-up the solvespace engine in a blender add-on

There are also a whole slew of add-ons that can make Blender more CAD-friendly.

However, you are correct, this is not the primary intent of Blender.

Re:Plasticity Is CAD for Artists by nkallen on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @04:59AM (#30696670)
I think the main thing to understand is that blender has minimal nurbs support. For example, try doing booleans, fillets, or offset surfaces with blender nurbs. You can’t.

Nurbs are good for some shapes and bad for others. In addition to manufacturing, nurbs are great for hard surface / scifi assets for video games and movies.

Plasticity is for artists. It is more in the tradition of MoI3d than say solidworks. It has a very powerful geometry kernel and the user interface is meant to be familiar to blender users and modern looking.

It’s still very beta and changing every day

Re:Plasticity Is CAD for Artists by S0und on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @09:52AM (#30698823)
I get PTSD when i heard the acronym of NURBS. Decades ago when Subdivision modelling wasn't a thing YET, people though that NURBS was a viable modeling method.