Either that, or maybe the grocery stores could give out coupons based on soft drink purchases. The coupons provide health insurance discounts and are paid for by the soft drink companies. They're the ones making money by getting people addicted to sugar so IMO they should be the ones paying for the costs.
Russia and China aren't America's big problem. Our lack of personal responsibility is a much bigger problem IMO.
Okay so literally ban it but make the punishment worse than fine or jail, that'll go over well.
The difference compared to prohibition is that, en masse, young people aren't clamoring to start smoking. I know a few people my age who vape, none who smoke cigarettes.
Then why is the law necessary?
Taking away an addictive and much-used item from a population who is in full-use mode is entirely different than never introducing it to a population that has never used it.
Banning tobacco for a population with smokers in it is hard and will lead to the same problems as prohibition did. However, the population born in 2010 are as of yet not allowed to purchase tobacco (because, they are 12 years old!), so only a vanishingly small part of them are active smokers. Never letting them purchase tobacco will be a none-change for them, their lives are not changed by this, execept for the healthier. Those few who are bent on becoming smokers, will still do so, but there's no good reason to think there are any significant number of them.
The future generations even less so.
It should be clarified that the act of smoking won't be prohibited, it is the act of selling tobacco products to someone born after 2010 that would, so there will be some black market for a little while, but it's kinda difficult to get new clients, it's not as addictive or nice a product as hard drugs are..
Maybe Denmark can pull this off because they are a small country compared to the US. I hope we never try it, because we need to be going in the other direction: if people want to kill themselves, let them do it legally, tax it, and deny them health insurance. At least that will cut down on "crime" and all the court, legal, and police infrastructure that goes with it.