News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by bduerst on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:00PM (#30674922)
Couple things:

- C4 fixation is a characteristic of smaller, monocot plants. Trees are slower-growing dicots. There are more pathways to these organisms than just increasing energy production efficiency. For example, have you proven that trees actually reinvest the excess glucose into growth, rather than trigger negative feedback pathways to slow glucose production?

- Also, you claim that the plant is faster growing with harder wood. Typically with trees, the speed of growth is inversely proportionate to the strength of the wood - i.e. cottonwoods and box elders grow fast but are terrible woods, while oak and maple are the inverse. Given the long lifespan of these organisms, have you any preliminary data to back up these claims that these trees are growing faster and stronger?

I used to do plant transgenics in a past life, and while skeptical, I do see projects like this as a solution for the future - though more along the lines of faster growing algae because ultimately the bottom line is the variable cost of converting sq meters of sunlight into carbon energy. It's just super easy to fall for hype and go straight to science fiction rather than focus on the science.

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by maddiehalla on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:01PM (#30677456)
Good question, the research we are doing on increasing the durability of wood is separate from the research on photosynthesis. The durability of wood largely has to do with the ratio of lignin to cellulose. Historically organizations focused on increasing growth rate for bioenergy have worked on changing that ration to create fast growing but less dense wood. That's different from what we are doing at Living Carbon. We don't expect to see increases in wood durability from photosynthesis-enhancement alone.

Biochemically our photosynthesis-enhancement strategy is a metabolic bypass pathway that reduces the energy that goes towards photorespiration allowing for more energy to go toward growth. When talking to investors I sometimes say it's like putting the plant into ketosis :) albeit that is not the perfect analog.

When it comes to improving the durability of wood, one of our approaches focuses on improving the ability of trees to accumulate and store metals in their lignin. Metals act as natural fungicides and slow the decomposition of trees. Other ideas include some of the world the Salk Institute has done on increasing Suberin production. Here's a paper that demonstrates how a doubling in nickel concentration in norwegian spruce led to slower decomposition: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09291...

The crazy thing here is that there is SO MUCH precedent from accumulation of metals by trees in nature. In certain parts of New Caledonia a tree called pycnandra acuminata thrives in ultramorph aka Nickel rich soil. It has up to 24% nickel sap concentration and can be tapped for nickel citrate actually.

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-45398434

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by elihu on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @02:49AM (#30682338)
Wow, that's really weird: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pycnandra_acuminata

Is there a danger of the trees themselves becoming hazardous waste if they accumulate the wrong kinds of metals? Though I suppose that could be a feature if it creates an incentive to harvest the trees and then sequester them in such a way that they won't be a problem for humans in any conceivable timeframe.

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by SideburnsOfDoom on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @09:15AM (#30684809)
> the trees themselves becoming hazardous waste if they accumulate the wrong kinds of metals? That could be a feature

The jargon to search for in this area is "Bioremediation via Bioaccumulation" and yes it's an existing thing. Not usually with trees though.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B978032385...!

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by webmaven on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @04:55PM (#30691577)
More specifically, "phytoremediation" should bring up more tree-specific research in this area.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by Apofis on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:16PM (#30681024)
You guys are amazing. This has been one of my wet dreams as far as a natural carbon capture mechanisms go. It always seemed like a no-brainer to me. I wonder how far this can go? I know it's a fantasy, but imagine we can get sequoias to grow at a monstrous pace? It'll be a massive boon to CO2 draw-down, which is the real issue since not a single country on earth is on track to meeting 2050 Paris Accord goals. Good luck guys and hopefully maybe one day in the future we may partner on project. Keep on rockin'!
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by ncmncm on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @01:54PM (#30688561)
This seems like good work, and engineering trees to sequester hazardous metals, or to (e.g.) tolerate nickel-rich olivine soil additions will be a net good. Planting trees costs little.

But if we are interested in mass carbon capture, there may be more value per dollar invested in pumping surface water down to very deep ocean depths. Such pumps could be driven directly by floating wind turbines, maybe without need for expensive electrical components, and could also raise deep, cold, neutral water to the surface to help mediate acidification and high-temperature coral bleaching.

Probably we should be seeding both, along with lots of others, and see which ones achieve more. We will probably be surprised by the results.

Edit: To be clear, there may be much more value here in the other things they are doing than in increased carbon capture, and we should be evaluating the work more on the other things. If they capture carbon, too, that is good.

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by danuker on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @05:50AM (#30696930)
A back-of-the-envelope calculation [0] shows that, to offset the US CO2 emissions, you need to plant about 20 million trees PER DAY.

[0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gqht2bIQXIY

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by ianai on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:52PM (#30675609)
And with algae my mind switches to the oceans. Ocean water's actually got lithium deposits and other things that, if we could get to them, would be useful. So it'd be cool if algae + science could somehow output the oceans contents in more industrial friendly formats. Especially if that meant carbon sequestration.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by bduerst on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @03:24PM (#30690059)
That's an interesting take. I was thinking more along the lines of huge (albeit expensive) algae bioreactors in empty deserts for a more controlled GMO environment, but one that would allow for much more accelerated carbon capture to desired outputs, like biodiesel, plastic precursors, etc.

It's true the oceans are filled with aqueous rare metals, but the volume is such you'd need a fast-processing mobile operation, and like the other commenter said, I'm not sure we need another anthropogenic operation harvesting from the ocean.

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by always2slow on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @12:14PM (#30687144)
Maybe the lithium in the ocean serves a purpose we are unaware of and we shouldn't screw with it?
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by ncmncm on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @02:05PM (#30688734)
Hint: we are already screwing with the ocean on a mass industrial scale. The question should be whether there is a way for any given activity to help mitigate the more harmful of those effects.

Changing nothing is actively harmful, and anyway impossible. Human activity is big enough that the only responsible course available is stewardship.

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by always2slow on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @12:25AM (#30695300)
Did you just advocate for a tragedy of the commons like it was a good thing?
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by ncmncm on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @01:01AM (#30695502)
Stewardship is exactly the opposite of tragedy of the commons.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by always2slow on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:54PM (#30703243)
Yes, but I guess what I'm implying is that you're just going to have multiple actors exploiting whatever they like under the banner of "Stewardship"
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by ncmncm on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @08:01PM (#30705796)
Literally all actors are doing whatever they like, today.

Most particularly, they are dissolving gigatons of CO2 into surface water, acidifying it.

Besides that, a few are trying to control overfishing in coastal waters they have asserted a day over, with varying levels of success, both externally and domestically, subject to politics.

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by ncmncm on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @10:09PM (#30706787)
*asserted authority over