News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by nicoburns on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:28AM (#30672837)
> It also means TSMC’s 3 nm process isn’t ready, probably not shipping until late 2022. Apple, by virtue of their tight partnership with TSMC has known about and taken precautions against the 3 nm schedule, hence the initially undisclosed M1 Max UltraFusion design wrinkle, likely an early 2021 decision.

I find it hard to believe that this was a last-minute decision. Rather, I think this pattern of a new core design (using a new process if there is one) releases first for the smallest devices (iPhones), and the gradually moves its way up the lineup all the way up the Ultra before the cycle repeats with a new generation is likely Apple's new strategy going forwards.

My understanding is that this is pretty much what Intel and AMD do too (releasing their smaller dies on new processes first) and that this is a general strategy for dealing with poorer yield number on new process nodes. The idea that Apple would ever have considered releasing their biggest chip as the first chip on a new node seems far-fetched to me.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by paulmd on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:15PM (#30674250)
It absolutely was not. The A15/"M2" architecture isn't even going to be on 3nm, it will be N5P, so only a "plus" of the current node. There was absolutely no scenario where Apple was on 3nm this year.

Incidentally this means that Apple will no longer have a node advantage once Zen4 launches - both Zen4 and A15 will be on the same node, so we can make direct comparisons without people insisting that Apple's performance is solely due to node advantage/etc.

But yeah, that does go to show that 3nm is slow to launch in general - Apple would not willingly give up their node lead like this if there were anything ready for an upgrade. I don't think it's actually falling behind in the sense that it was delayed, but it seems even TSMC is feeling the heat and slowing down their node cadence a bit.

Also, as far as this:

> Second, the recourse to two M1 Max chips fused into a M1 Ultra means TSMC’s 5 nm process has reached its upper limit.

There is still Mac Pro to come, and presumably Apple would want an actual Pro product to offer something over the Studio besides expansion.

marcan42 thinks it's not likely that quad-die Mac Pros are coming based on the internal architecture (there's only IRQ facilities for connecting 2 dies) but that still doesn't rule out the possibility of a larger die that is then connected in pairs.

Also bigger/better 5nm stuff will almost certainly be coming with A15 on N5P later this year, so this isn't even "the best TSMC 5nm has to offer" in that light either.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by marcan_42 on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:02PM (#30677468)
> quad-die Mac Pros

I said quad-Jade Mac anythings aren't coming because that die is only designed to go in pairs (that's the M1 Max die). Everyone keeps rambling on about that idea because that Bloomberg reporter said it was coming and got it wrong. It won't happen.

Apple certainly can and probably will do quad dies at some point, it'll just be with a new die. The IRQ controller in Jade is only synthesized for two dies, but the architecture scales up to 8 with existing drivers (in our Linux driver too). I fully expect them to be planning a crazier design to use for Mac Pros.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by caycep on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:38PM (#30675410)
What would be interesting in the far future is if, say, Zen 4 (or 5+) and M2(+) claims some of Intel's new foundry capacity...the comparisons would be very interesting...
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by miolini on Monday March 14, 2022 @08:44PM (#30680436)
It's not only because 3nm is not ready, but also because ARM v9 around the corner.
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by wlesieutre on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:56AM (#30673170)
Incidentally, there's a rumor that the iPhone 14 is going to use a new A16 processor in the iPhone Pro, but stick to last year's A15 for the non-pro version.

That's a big change from Apple where they've historically put their newest processor in every single phone they launch (even the $430 iPhone SE announced last week has the A15 now).

I wonder if it's purely a cost cutting measure, or if they're not expecting good enough yields to supply them for every iPhone, or if they're holding some fab capacity back to have room for the higher end chips alongside the A16.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by hajile on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:36AM (#30673663)
I'd guess that they are having product differentiation issues between the iphone and the iphone Pro. Most people just don't see the value in faster screen, stainless band, and a not-so-great telephoto camera (I own a pro, but I'm hardly their primary market). An entire processor generation difference would give a big selling point to average consumers for paying the extra few hundred dollars.

There's been rumors that they'll be skipping A15 cores for the upcoming M2 processors.

If they skipped over the best-selling iphone, that would give them a TON of extra space for M2 chips. This would allow them to put a little more ground between the new Air with the M1 and the pro iPads. It would also allow them to drop a new version of the macbook air and drive a lot of sales there. I know I'd gladly upgrade to a M2 model -- especially with a decent CPU bump and a 24/32GB RAM option.

Then again, they could just stick with what people expect. I wouldn't be surprised either way.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by dangus on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:00PM (#30674035)
I feel like I can see increased efforts at differentiation on the 13 Pro compared to the 12 Pro.

The iPhone 12 Pro was perhaps the least differentiated high-end model Apple has ever put out.

I think the 13 Pro has a few features that make it a bit more of a compelling buy:

- The new telephoto lens is a massive improvement (I wonder if your last experience was with the 12 or older? The new camera is actually worth something while the old one had mediocre quality compared to the main lens).

- ProMotion has no tangible benefit, but it makes every interaction with the screen look smoother. When you go back to old phones that don't have it, it's jarring. I can see why some of the Android-using tech enthusiasts have criticized Apple for not delivering high refresh rate for so long.

- The previous iPhone 12 had identical main/wide cameras with the Pro model unless you got the Max variant, which is no longer the case. The iPhone 13 Pro has different/better cameras all around over the 13.

- The GPU of the 13 Pro has an extra core over the 13, which was not the case for the iPhone 12 lineup. Anyone who does mobile gaming on graphically intense games should probably choose the Pro model over the regular one.

- Significantly better battery life over the non-Pro version, which was not the case for the 12 models, which had identical ratings.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by hajile on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:36PM (#30674553)
For an average consumer, are those things worth hundreds of dollars?

I know the value, but I work in tech and spend tons of time digging into hardware as a hobby. Camera matters to some, but most of the rest are pretty bare features compared to the $200 (20%) increase in price.

When I list all the things I can buy with $200, where do these features rank in comparison to those other things? I'm blessed with a good job, so I can afford the luxury. I was poor when I was younger and I definitely wouldn't be spending that for those features. $220 out the door would be almost 20 hours of work at $15/hr (after taxes).

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by dangus on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:48PM (#30678065)
I think that's a valid question. Objectively, no, those features are not necessarily worth the literal dollar value the price segmentation is commanding.

But, there are some other points to consider:

- It seems like most people in the USA who buy mid to high-end phones finance their phones from carriers, and pay 0% interest for it. So, what the consumer is really considering is "is the Pro model worth $5-8/month more to me?" or "Would I pay $200 extra over 2-3 years?" and I think that's an easier justification for many people.

- Carriers offer a number of financial incentives and discounts in exchange for loyalty (there aren't any contracts anymore, but there are "bill credits" that function the same way).

- You did use $15/hour as an example, which around the median US salary, but Pro models are not intended to be the top selling model for the median earner in the US. They're marketed at, I would guess, the top 20% of earners, which lines up with the Pro/Pro Max models only making up 20% of iPhone sales in 2020 [1]. That would mean that Apple would expect individuals buying the iPhone Pro models to make about $75,000/year or greater. About 10% of the population makes a 6-figure salary. [2]

- Smartphones are the primary communication and computing device for many if not most people. I think that there are many people who see the smartphone as the most valuable possession they own.

[1] https://www.knowyourmobile.com/phones/most-popular-iphone-mo...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_income_in_the_United_...

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by nicoburns on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:36PM (#30678695)
> So, what the consumer is really considering is "is the Pro model worth $5-8/month more to me?" or "Would I pay $200 extra over 2-3 years?" and I think that's an easier justification for many people.

I find this attitude bizarre. It's not any cheaper! I guess it can make a difference if you have cash flow issues. But an iPhone Pro is decidedly a luxury, so if you have cash flow issues then you probably just shouldn't buy one?

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by dangus on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @11:26AM (#30686496)
Your point about cash flow is absolutely why this happens. I think that a lot of people operate on monthly budgets, not total cost.

It's not really about the total price paid, it's about whether the item is affordable on a monthly basis.

I agree with your philosophy where a lot of people are way too willing to let easy financing change their budget. I also assume that free financing would inflate prices (e.g.: cars and homes).

Would the iPhone and other flagship phones cost $700-1000 if financing wasn't so common? I don't think so, personally.

The other aspect of this is that, mathematically, $200 paid now is objectively worth more than $200 paid over time thanks to the time value of money. [1]

Let's say we're at a "normal" 2% rate of inflation. If I buy a $30,000 car today with 0% financing over 6 years, by the time I hit year 6 my monthly payment is representing a 12% lower value (inflation compounded yearly) than when I started.

Technically, even if you have $1000 in cash to buy your new iPhone, you "should" just finance it and invest/save/use the rest elsewhere.

[1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/timevalueofmoney.asp

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by faeriechangling on Monday March 14, 2022 @07:19PM (#30679819)
>an iPhone Pro is decidedly a luxury

With my ADHD issues, the combination of

>The generally long battery of the ProMax in particular (I had issue with my phone dying midday, forgetting to charge)

>iOS 15 Focus mode

>UWB wireless trackers

>The most effective ANC in any wireless headphones

>Apple watch for notifications, timers, etc

Are all very helpful and the promax is just good for pragmatic and practical reasons. I would definitely say it's a high priced item but I wouldn’t frame it as a luxury. I fundamentally see my phone as assistive technology, it can’t die on me, Apple makes their longest lasting phone their most expensive.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by faeriechangling on Monday March 14, 2022 @07:12PM (#30679769)
>ProMotion has no tangible benefit

Sure it does, particularly for a direct input device higher refresh rate screens improve input speed and accuracy.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by nicoburns on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:16AM (#30673403)
I'd imagine if anything it's a capacity issue now that they're producing mac chips in addition to iPhone chips. I suspect the fact the current chip is already so fast may also be a factor. Pretty much nobody using an iPhone is clamouring for a faster CPU. I have an iPhone 6s, and even the A9 in that is fast enough that my phone never feels slow.
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by gumby on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:36AM (#30673666)
> I have an iPhone 6s, and even the A9 in that is fast enough that my phone never feels slow.

Last year I upgraded from a 6s+ to a 12 and I can confirm this the other way around: my old phone did feel slow for a couple of key apps; turns out they are still slow on the new phone. They are just poorly written, and one is basically just a CRUD app with no excuse.

So my lesson is to likely keep this phone for a decade. It's not like I couldn't afford to upgrade but why bother?

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by nonamenoslogan on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:24PM (#30676061)
I will echo this, I was on a 7 and it broke, so I got a regular model 12. The phone itself feels much faster, it loads quicker, the batteries last longer and the screen is much nicer to look at--but some of the apps I use are about the same for opening/loading time. I blame the apps not the phone; some are much better--Pokemon Go for example loads in just a second or two on the 12 but takes 30 or so on the 7.
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by lolive on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:43AM (#30673767)
Isn't the camera better? And also the battery life?

[happy owner of a 6s here]

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by lynguist on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:57AM (#30673992)
I found the biggest difference to be the display. I changed from iPhone 7 Plus to iPhone 13 mini. From 7 on the display is wide color and the newer phones are all OLED with true blacks. They’re impressive.

Another big difference is 5G. I can easily get 500+ MBit/s downstream while outside.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by tblt on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:49PM (#30675558)
How did you find the change in display size?
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by lynguist on Thursday March 17, 2022 @04:41AM (#30708906)
I found that I can adapt to any display size. I used to have an iPhone 5s which I replaced with a 6s Plus and a 7 Plus. Recently I have changed my mind and I wanted a compact phone again to carry less weight and to distract me less. I thought it might deter me from watching videos all the time. I like how the small phone feels like, it’s more elegant.

Oh, and about the cameras: the one update I especially like is the night photography, I can now even take photos of the starry night sky.

Besides that: it’s just a phone, it just has an absurdly powerful CPU in it, and now it does text detection in images. Screenshots and photos have selectable text in it.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by gumby on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:25PM (#30676075)
The camera is better at low light photos but I don't really care about that. Camera plays no role in my selection of phone and I wish the lenses didn't protrude (which they could address by putting more battery in!).

Yes, the battery was kinda shot but I could have replaced it.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by josh2600 on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:18AM (#30673439)
Honestly, my guess is that the fab production issues impact everyone. I wonder if they get the same number of runs per $ as they used to pre-covid, my guess would be no. If that’s the case, that drives BoM up and Apple is hyper margin conscious.
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by dom96 on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:47AM (#30673843)
Side question but I'm curious if anyone knows, where are we heading with this constant decrease in nm for chip manufacturing processes? When will we hit a wall and where will gains in performance come from then?
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by monocasa on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:04PM (#30674096)
Like most curves that looked like exponentials initially, Moore's law turned out to be an s curve. We're already on the top half of that curve where gains are increasingly more difficult and increasingly spread out over time. There's still a more or less direct road map for another five or so full nodes, and we'll probably come up with some cute way to increase density in other ways.
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by barbacoa on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:12PM (#30674197)
>When will we hit a wall and where will gains in performance come from then?

nm notation used to mean the width of the smallest feature that could be made. Even today there are processes such as atomic layer deposition (ALD) that allows singular atom thick features. The difference between nodes now are in shrinking macro features, you don't necessarily make them smaller, more important is density. This is currently done with 3d transistors (finfet) and perhaps in the future going full vertical. When all other optimization have been exhausted it's likely to see multiple layers of stacked transistors simulator to what they are doing with NAND memory chips. Eventually even that will hit a wall due to thermal limitations. Beyond that people have proposed using carbonnano tube transistors. That tech is very early but has been proved to function in labs. If we ever figure out how to manufacture carbon nanotubes chips, it will be truly revolutionary; you could expect at least another 50 years of semiconductor innovation.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by sharikous on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:15PM (#30674244)
> If we ever figure out how to manufacture carbon nanotubes chips

That's the problem. We can't. All those technologies are in such a primordial state, if at all, that we don't even know if we will ever be able to use them efficiently 20 years from now.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by whazor on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:50PM (#30678882)
Besides shrinking and increasing size chips, there is another big problem that might cause us to hit the wall. When the transistor count increases, it also increases the amount of effort. This is a big problem because chips need to be profitable.

Although if you just shrink the chips and keep the transistor count the same, then you have a more energy efficient chip. Which is especially useful for portable devices.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by sharikous on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:13PM (#30674212)
We have already hit the wall. Decreases have been minimal, and came with a high cost. The numbers you hear about "7 nm", "5 nm", etc.. are just false. They do not represent anything real.

The real numbers have been around 20 nm for a decade. They decreased a bit with Intel's competitors achieving better lithography than them before them. And we are in the realm of tons of little tricks that improve density and performance - nothing really dramatic but there are still improvements here and there. The tens of billions of dollars thrown at research achieved them but it is not comparable to the good old days of the '80s, '90s and the '00s

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by kllrnohj on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:36PM (#30674561)
> And we are in the realm of tons of little tricks that improve density and performance - nothing really dramatic but there are still improvements here and there.

I don't think that's fair. Density is still increasing fairly substantially. Just going off of TSMC's own numbers here:

    16nm: 28 MTr/mm2
    10nm: 52.5 MTr/mm2    
    7nm: 96.5 MTr/mm2
    5nm: 173 MTr/mm2
Performance (read: clock speeds; but for transistors those are one & the same) are not really increasing, though, those have pretty much plateaued. And the density achieved in practice doesn't necessarily keep up, as the density numbers tend to be for the simplest layouts.
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by paulmd on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:27PM (#30674411)
Yes, to emphasize: "nm" marketing is just marketing. There is no dimension on a 5nm chip that is actually 5nm. It used to represent gate length and half-pitch but that stopped being true about 20 years ago and officially became nonsense about 10 years ago, it's "what size planar node do we think these features would perform like" now.

Because it's all subjective now, companies went wild with marketing, because consumers know "lower nm => better". But, say, GF 14nm is much more comparable to Intel 22nm, and GF 12nm is still solidly behind late-gen 14++, probably more comparable to TSMC 16nm. Generally Intel has been the most faithful to the "original" ratings, while TSMC has stretched it a little, and GF/IBM and Samsung have been pretty deceptive with their namings. Intel finally threw in the towel a year or so ago and moved to align their names with TSMC, "10nm ESF" is now "Intel 7" (note: no nm) and is roughly comparable with TSMC 7nm (seems like higher clocks at the top/worse efficiency at the bottom but broadly similar), and they will maintain TSMC-comparable node names going forward.

Anyway, to answer OP's question directly though, "what comes after 1nm" is angstroms. You'll see node names like *90A or whatever, even though that continues to be completely ridiculous in terms of the actual node measurements.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by corey_moncure on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:13PM (#30675074)
900 angstroms = 90 nanometers
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by akmarinov on Monday March 14, 2022 @06:14PM (#30679140)
Good bot
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by querulous on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:31PM (#30674476)
nm is purely a marketing term and has been for 10 years or 25 years depending on what you think it measures

future improvement is going to come from the same place it mostly comes from now: better design that unlocks better density and a revolutionary new litho process that as of yet doesn't exist

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by jasonwatkinspdx on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:46PM (#30675520)
No one has a crystal ball, but here's the industry road map: https://irds.ieee.org/editions/2021 (start with executive summary).

TL;DR: things get really murky after a notional 2.1nm generation. Past that we'll need a new generation of EUV sources, advancements in materials, etc, that AFAIK are still quite far from certain (but I am not an expert on this stuff by any means).

I personally think we're headed to a stall for a while where innovation will focus mostly on larger packaging/aggregation structures. Chiplets and related are definitely here to stay. DRAM is moving in package. Startups are playing around with ideas like wafer scale multiprocessors or ssds. I think clever combinations of engineering at this level will keep us with momentum for a while.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by PaulKeeble on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:34AM (#30672912)
Oddly for GPUs its the other way around and has been for a while. Nvidia and AMD seem to start with the mid and big dies first before filling out the small ones later. Intel seems to be coming from small to big however so they may reverse the trend at least for themselves. But it could still be driven by yield issues where the margins are less good for smaller dies and they sell in much larger volume so things need to be working well to hit the volume of the market and still be highly profitable.
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by mschuster91 on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:11AM (#30673353)
> Nvidia and AMD seem to start with the mid and big dies first before filling out the small ones later.

For GPUs, yield is less of an issue... the chips are manufactured with the expectation of a number of cores of the many thousand small (in terms of silicon area) ones being defective - overprovisioning, basically. That allows them to simply bin the sliced chips according to how many functional core units the individual chip has.

In contrast, even the Threadripper AMD CPUs have only 64 large cores which means the impact of defects is vastly bigger, and overprovisioning is not feasible.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by chickenimprint on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:46AM (#30673823)
Current AMD chiplets come with a maximum of 8 cores.
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by Macha on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:28PM (#30674431)
Right, that's a different strategy again. If you're making a monolithic 64 core die and one of the cores is defective, and the next one down in your product lineup is the 48 core, that's going to make the 64 core model harder to stock (and maybe not worth aiming for at all, if your yields are bad enough that this happens often).

Meanwhile if you're making 6 x 8 core chiplets and one of those cores is defective, well that chiplet can go into a 48 core or be a midrange consumer cpu or something, and you'll just pick one of your many many other 8 core chiplets to go with the rest for the 64 core.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by agloeregrets on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:41PM (#30674616)
Ala: The 14/16 inch MacBook Pro making all full-die function models built to order. I do find it interesting that they did a 7 core GPU version of the M1 much like the A12X/A12Z binning. I wonder if getting full function M1 was ever the intent.
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by snek_case on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:41PM (#30675455)
Probably because the beefier GPUs for the server or compute market are way more profitable for Nvidia than high-end gaming GPUS, which are also way more profitable than chips Nvidia might make for laptops or low end gaming.
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by GeekyBear on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:25PM (#30674387)
It looks like Qualcomm is bailing out of Samsung's leading edge node, so competition for TSMC's leading edge node is higher than ever with Intel, Apple and Qualcomm all in the running.

>Qualcomm has decided to switch back to TSMC for the Snapdragon 8 Gen2 Mobile Platform. Samsung’s 4nm process node is plagued by a yield rate of as low as 35 percent.

https://www.techspot.com/news/93520-low-yield-samsung-4nm-pr...

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by auggierose on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:53AM (#30673134)
I was thinking the same. Once UltraFusion has been designed, why not use it for 3nm later on as well?
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by BolexNOLA on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:46AM (#30673041)
This article is a little nauseating in its low key drooling over Apple but I think articulates what you’re saying somewhat. Basically build a product around the chip and move it down the product line, double capacity at regular intervals.

https://www.theverge.com/22972996/apple-silicon-arm-double-s...

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by gumby on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:16PM (#30675935)
> This article is a little nauseating in its low key drooling over Apple

The author ran Apple Europe and then moved to the US and was an Apple VP for a long time. If anyone is allowed to have this kind of attitude then it's reasonable in Gassée.

In people in general, it's...weird.

Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by BolexNOLA on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:06PM (#30676741)
Wasn’t aware of that - thanks for the context!
Re:Apple M1 Ultra Meanings and Consequences by acidbaseextract on Monday March 14, 2022 @07:45PM (#30680011)
Gassée also started Be Inc which created BeOS. Beyond being great in and of itself, BeOS was also slated to be the successor to Mac OS 9. If you're an operating system or file system nerd, you will find it very worth looking into BeOS. Gassée overplayed his hand and Apple's acquisition of Be Inc fell through.

Apple ultimately went with the NeXT / Steve Jobs combo, quite wisely, but for a long time there was a whole gang of BeOS fanboys lamenting that decision.