News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by hunglee2 on Monday March 14, 2022 @05:50AM (#30670377)
Putin may be rational and still decide to launch.

What is or is not rational is based on objectives and timelines. It is imperative we understand what these are, as they form the frame of what decisions might be made.

Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by andyjohnson0 on Monday March 14, 2022 @06:13AM (#30670540)
Are you saying that objectives and timelines are the _only_ factors that can be used to evaluate leadership rationality? In what circumstances is it rational for Putin to trigger a large-scale, first-use nuclear exchange that would probably kill hundreds of millions of people?

Edit: I can see how it might be rational for Putin to threaten to use nuclear weapons. But I can't understand how that extends to actually using them.

Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by hunglee2 on Monday March 14, 2022 @09:31AM (#30672189)
alright i will have a go at this:

Let's say Putin's core objective is 'not letting US win' - this is the only thing he cares about.

War goes badly, but this core objective doesn't change. If he wants to achieve this objective, armageddon would achieve it - everyone loses, so US doesn't win. That is better than Russia loses, US wins, so it is rational in this frame to push the button.

Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by AnimalMuppet on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:09PM (#30674163)
But that isn't what he wants. He doesn't want the US to lose; he wants Russia to win. He thinks he needs NATO to collapse for that to happen, but the end goal is Russia winning, not NATO losing.

He can't get Russia winning by a nuclear war.

The larger problem is that he is increasingly surrounded by people who tell him what he wants to hear, not what is true. That might lead to a situation where he thinks Russia can win by a nuclear war.

Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by hunglee2 on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:35PM (#30674540)
my example was illustration of how triggering nuclear war could be a rational decision. I do not have any privileged access to Putin's objective
Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by pydry on Monday March 14, 2022 @07:00AM (#30670858)
To save his own skin.
Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by arethuza on Monday March 14, 2022 @09:16AM (#30672039)
He'd also have to be confident that he personally could survive a counter strike - which would be quite a decision to make.
Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by aerostable_slug on Monday March 14, 2022 @03:24PM (#30677001)
What counterstrike? If he pops a small, relatively clean nuclear weapon over a Ukrainian airfield, the United States will almost certainly not retaliate against the Russian homeland — that path nearly inevitably leads to general war. This is doubly true if Putin decides to cause a high-altitude nuclear EMP event.

We are in a serious policy vice and the odds of him resorting to a nuclear demonstration are non-zero and grow by the day. Even the best outcome of that scenario likely means a massive proliferation crisis as countries around the world put plans into effect to join the nuclear club ASAP.

Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by andyjohnson0 on Monday March 14, 2022 @07:26AM (#30671065)
> To save his own skin.

So Russia as a functioning society is destroyed in the inevitable counter-attack. How does that benefit Putin? How does that allow him to go on living in the way that he clearly wants to?

Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by pydry on Monday March 14, 2022 @07:55AM (#30671324)
I think he probably visualizes the gradual encroachment of NATO ending up with a bayonet shoved up his ass a la Libya. He apparently watched the Gadaffi video obsessively and he was certainly publicly outraged about it, particularly in light of the broken promises the west made to gafaffi that he'd be left alone.

In the 2000s he probably would have felt somewhat safe losing power. I think after that video his attitude was probably that if Russia loses its military power and he loses power in Russia he will die a messy and horrible death.

And hes been in this state for over 10 years now. Theres probably some truth to the notion that COVID isolated him but I think Libya contributed most to his paranoia.

Im pretty sure this puts nuclear weapons strikes on large population centers on the table.

Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by Mikeb85 on Monday March 14, 2022 @09:35AM (#30672231)
>Putin may be rational and still decide to launch

And what about the others who need to follow through to complete his order? Putin can't launch anyway without the cooperation of at least a few others...

[dead]
Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by yetihehe on Monday March 14, 2022 @08:10AM (#30671444)
> they push various coup like founding the Solidarność "syndicate" in Poland

If you think that Solidarność is some sort of criminal movement, I don't want to be on your side. Maybe they are not relevant now (outlived their purpose a little), but I live in Poland and DO NOT want to be back in Russia. Some old people say "under communism it was better", but when asked a little more they say things like "we had almost nothing and we were happy" while watching some recent news on flat screen in comfy home with all the kitchen appliances they want. Cool, now Russia will be like that old times, they can go there and compare how good it is.

Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by kkfx on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:19AM (#30672747)
Solidarność was evidently criminal by history, but that does not means Soviet's were good guys, that's the common error too many commit following actual propaganda: Putin IS clearly a dictator and that does not at all means that on the other side they are less criminal or more just.

The blackbird is black and that does not imply the crow is white.

Beside that: consider a thing, the Soviet have done some BIG criminal act, for instance on Ukraine starving many to death just to nourish their newly born industry needed for war and cohesion, again that does not means that the white financed by UK, France and others were less criminal or just. States do their own math for specific reasons and sometimes things are complicated. Understanding what happen means being able to comprehend who's right or wrong and at what extent.

Another historic example during WWII in France Philippe Pétain, a former WWI hero decide to sign an agreement with nazi German founding Vichy regime. If you read the history at that level he was a hero turned in a monster. That's nor true nor false. He have well seen WWI where French officers where killed taken as a sample "to push troops" while he see that Germany troops were FAR less self-aggressive, he see the degree of separation between officers and soldiers in the army while far less happen on German side, so he just make a small computation: "if we can't win it's better being under Germany than under a corrupted regime that want to sell France to UK" (that's was the plan, read "In The Thick of The Fight 1930-1945" by Paul Reynaud) and many was with him both because they agree and both because they think he will turn side again sooner. He became evil after. Knowing that really change the history, he was both a hero and a villain and the same was valid for many others.

Actual Poland gov. for what I've read should be arrested en mass for high treason, attempted coup d'etat and others crimes for instance, and that does not mean opponent of actual gov are good guys. Again we have to read the complexity before judge.

Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by yetihehe on Monday March 14, 2022 @12:42PM (#30674633)
> Solidarność was evidently criminal by history

Not evidently. Otherwise it would be known more widely. Unless you consider ANY resistance to be criminals. And I mean actual murderers who killed just to enrich themselves, not "declared unlawful by dictatorship regime".

> Actual Poland gov. for what I've read should be arrested en mass for high treason, attempted coup d'etat and others crimes for instance

Yeah, everything they do looks like they want communism back.

> Again we have to read the complexity before judge.

So, we should just talk about ideal governments and do nothing because we consider both sides criminals? Or do you just like talking about how both sides are ugly?

Re:What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Ir... by kkfx on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @05:15AM (#30683183)
> Not evidently.

Of course, winning side dislike news against itself, a small historic example: how many know that USA companies and various part of the government helped the nazi's in WWII even after the start of the war? How many know that IBM provide systems to them to track Hebrews and political opponent, Standard Oil provide petroleum products etc to a point that one of the master of USA propaganda, Eduard Bernays was thanked by hitler and goebbels for it's inspirations? How many know that UK crown pay mussolini in Italy and then probably manage to kill him when they can't rescue him to avoid at that time that such infos became public? How many know that Marshall plan was NOT a generous donation to war-destroyed countries but a masterpiece of theft where forcing loosing power to withdraw their resources imposing even new currencies (Amlire in Italy, Neue deutsche mark in Germany) actually just giving back some of the resources they steal from them? How many recall "Operation Unthinkable" or "Operation Dropshot"?

As Bernays so Anne Morelli states in her "10 principes élémentaires de propagande de guerre" the wining side must be only angelic and the loosing side only demoniac...

> Yeah, everything they do looks like they want communism back.

They do worse than that: socialism (witch was the start, communism came after and some think came thanks to UK crown and Germany money to subvert the inizial revolution) impose a "religion of the party" that makes many disaster but at least push countries toward modernization, too quickly, making disasters, but with results, newer regime choose classical religions obscurantism (just look recent anti-abortion laws in Poland but also in the USA) witch have done worst because it's the same oppression and have no modernization aspects. Soviets say "work hard to create paradise of workers in life" classic systems say "work hard to get a paradise when you are dead" so at least the former leave a dream...

> So, we should just talk about ideal governments and do nothing because we consider both sides criminals?

For Ukraine both sides are criminals, but Russian side have interests but also some good reasons, the nazi-NATO side have just interests. Ukraine Russian-speaking populations was persecuted, killed, raped, systematically since at least 2014's Euromaidan not by Ukrainian-speaking part of the population but by nazi militias like Azov battalion, C14, Pravy Sektor etc that are armed and trained by NATO. So Putin is a dictator and want Ukraine for it's position and resources, BUT also have reasons to act because many (few millions?) Russian-speaking Citizens suffer countless crimes in a year long attempt of genocide. So while remain a dictatorship have all the right to say "we do special ops, even not war, because a war is against a state-enemy, not against common crocks armed and trained by some enemies, to stop a genocide of our friendly populations". Something USA can't even say for Iraq or Afghanistan, so to speak... That's the main difference. And Russians do not left a Russian speaking population in Ukraine, while USA create talibans (and probably also ISIS) for their own interests and that's turned bad at a certain point in time.