Re:RISC-V J extension – Instructions for JITs
by sdbbp on Friday March 11, 2022 @09:18PM
(#30648382)
This organization of functionality is intentional. It provides support for code modification orthogonal to instruction cache coherency support. The range of types of implementations of RISC-V is broad enough that imposing instruction cache coherency on all of them wouldn't be optimal. The I/D consistency proposal provides SW control now, while not requiring particular implementations.
Particular RISC-V Platform specs may end up requiring I/D coherency, like Arm is recommending in SBSA Level 6, but that's left for later, if ever.
Re:RISC-V J extension – Instructions for JITs
by Taniwha on Saturday March 12, 2022 @02:04AM
(#30649549)
Right, I think it's OK as written, I'm just encouraging people to make general specs rather than ones with special cases that are important for one end but slow everything else down
Particular RISC-V Platform specs may end up requiring I/D coherency, like Arm is recommending in SBSA Level 6, but that's left for later, if ever.