News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Just Say No to Central Bank Digital Currencies by AnthonyMouse on Friday March 11, 2022 @02:20AM (#30637237)
> A good reason to have them would be that it'd be really easy for the government to pay you, for instance if we had a UBI or one of those things everyone on here loves. Right now they're surprisingly bad at it. A lot of government agencies have to pay people with prepaid debit cards, and there's people who never got their stimulus checks still.

That seems like a good reason to not have them. Sending people checks is profoundly simple 17th century technology. Putting people who can't even master that in charge of securing against stealing an arbitrarily large amount of money over the internet is like that xkcd about voting software:

https://xkcd.com/2030/

Just no.

Re:Just Say No to Central Bank Digital Currencies by kevin_thibedeau on Friday March 11, 2022 @04:35AM (#30638014)
The issue isn't the inability to send checks. Many Americans can't get bank accounts to deposit checks into.
Re:Just Say No to Central Bank Digital Currencies by selfhoster11 on Friday March 11, 2022 @06:13AM (#30638552)
That's literally an American problem. Here in the UK, it's extremely easy to set up a bank account even if you don't earn very much, or if you recently declared bankruptcy. If America wanted to help the unbanked, they have every opportunity to do so.
Re:Just Say No to Central Bank Digital Currencies by jacobr1 on Friday March 11, 2022 @08:39AM (#30639709)
There are plenty of ways for the unbanked to get an account. From online banks with $0 deposit requirements, to local banks with $25minimums. While there certainly are literacy or accessibility issues, the number one cause of not having a bank account, according to FDIC surveys is not trusting banks.
Re:Just Say No to Central Bank Digital Currencies by wan23 on Friday March 11, 2022 @12:04PM (#30642572)
The first time I tried to get a bank account as a mostly broke college student, I walked into a branch of the bank that had an agreement with my university to supply ATMs on campus. I said I wanted an account. They did everything in their power to not give me an account. Eventually, they rejected me because I had a NYS non-driver's ID card instead of a license. "We've had problems with these," they said. This bank branch was in downtown Manhattan, where roughly no one drives.

A few years after I managed to get them to give me an account, I overdrafted my checking account by a few dollars and they disabled my ATM card. After my next deposit cleared, I went back to that bank branch to get my card reinstated. They did not want to do it. The manager eventually said he could help me if I "promised I wouldn't do it again". I asked for my account to be closed instead, and I will always remember how pleased the guy seemed to be losing me as a customer.

It is not easy for everyone to get and maintain a bank account.

Re:Just Say No to Central Bank Digital Currencies by htkibar on Friday March 11, 2022 @02:01PM (#30644474)
If you don't mind me asking - why?
Re:Just Say No to Central Bank Digital Currencies by wan23 on Saturday March 12, 2022 @03:15PM (#30654496)
I just looked like someone who was not worth their time. I never did have more than $100 in the account, and dealing with me might have cost them more than they made on me since I didn't pay any fees except for the one time I overdrafted.
Re:Just Say No to Central Bank Digital Currencies by AniseAbyss on Friday March 11, 2022 @07:13AM (#30638890)
It's literally illegal in my country to be unbanked. The government wants to know exactly where your money comes from and where it goes to.
Re:Just Say No to Central Bank Digital Currencies by astrange on Friday March 11, 2022 @02:53AM (#30637409)
Inability to send you a check is a sign of privacy. It means they don't know your address or bank account number.